4 ms·
XUL has always been pretty terrible, IMO. But it has advantages over Chrome-style addons. Should Firefox support WebExtensions? I'd say absolutely yes. Shou
by ravenstine 10y ago
XUL has always been pretty terrible, IMO. But it has advantages over Chrome-style addons. Should Firefox support WebExtensions? I'd say absolutely yes. Should Mozilla remove XUL support? I'd say probably not. Or at least it should be optional, as there are clearly some people who want full control of their browser. I'm not one of those people, but I understand where they're coming from, and it would be like a food company deciding that they're getting rid of their other flavors and are just going to sell the one flavor that the competitor is selling out. Unless Firefox has an edge over Chrome, or even Chromium, there's very little reason for me to use it. This is coming from someone who was a Firefox evangelist for years since 2005.
Also, the Electrolysis project taking forever is one reason I ditched Firefox for Chrome, and I suspect I'm not the only one. It was only late last year that it finally got released(I think?), and that was a project being talked about at least since 2010. Chrome had process-per-tab a few years before that, and there was even word that Chrome was being developed in that direction long before its release. Firefox took nearly a decade to compete.
- sp332 10y agoThat's because chrome was built that way from the beginning, and Firefox had to break their browser into pieces. And while it did stall out for a while, remember they were completely changing their JS garbage collector at the same time, which was also a huge amount of work. And both projects kept compatibility with most addons.
- bzbarsky 10y agoThe Electrolysis project took forever in large part because of the attempt to support XUL addons with it. It's hard to take seriously complaints that "Electrolysis took forever" given in the same breath as "oh, but you should keep XUL addons and just pay whatever complexity and development time penalties are involved in keeping them". Pick one or the other, please....