5 ms·
I'm very rarely for new regulations (very much libertarian and conservative), but this is one issue I will gladly "reach across the isle" on. In the end it'll s
by exabrial 10y ago
I'm very rarely for new regulations (very much libertarian and conservative), but this is one issue I will gladly "reach across the isle" on. In the end it'll spur all the things I like: small businesses, competition, market diversity, and innovation.
- dmix 10y agoOne of the issues is that this is a state policy and may act as a deterrent for global companies wanting to sell products within the state. It may very well be easier to just skip Nebraska and focus resources elsewhere. Especially for low margin electronics products. I'm sure Apple has enough resources to follow through with this but not all companies can afford the lawyers and special operations centers to appease local regulatory laws in a single state. Just look around you house and consider how many electronics came from a low budget Chinese vendor. I'm all for state rights but the costs should always be considered. As Thomas Sowell said: "Economics is not about good intentions and hopes. It's about cause and effect". For ex: US Chamber of Commerce just posted this article that 1/3 of small businesses surveyed said they hire less people because of health care costs. It's easy not to spare a tear for big companies. But the real victim of regulatory burden is not mega corps its the small businesses who account for 50% of all employment in the US and 90% of businesses are SMB. https://www.uschamber.com/above-the-fold/small-businesses-tell-congress-they-can-t-afford-obamacare https://www.uschamber.com/above-the-fold/small-businesses-te...
- mikeash 10y agoWould this really add a burden? These companies already make parts and service manuals available, some of them just restrict who is able to obtain them. To comply with the law, they would just need to stop restricting them.
- exabrial 10y agoAgree, but I will go out on a limb and say very few SMBs produce electronics (although there's a recent the trend in hardware startups).
- gech 10y agoFor those not in the know, Thomas Sowell is a conservative historian, and the US Chamber of Commerce is not as official as it sounds; it's a group that opposes government protections. Maybe you're onto something, maybe we should only regulate big business.
- WillPostForFood 10y agoSowell is more libertarian economist than conservative historian.
- Eridrus 10y agoIf the low budget Chinese vendors don't have repair manuals or authorised repaid centres, they don't need to do anything under this law. This law is pretty much "give us access to what you already give your techs and let us order from the replacement parts you still have in stock"
- stonogo 10y agoAre you seriously saying you think Apple or HTC would stop selling things to Nebraskans? How's Apple gonna stop Amazon from sending iPhones to Omaha? eBay? Are they going to instruct Best Buy employees to demand proof-of-residence in neighboring states to prevent those conniving cornhuskers from replacing their batteries?
- dmix 10y ago> Are you seriously saying you think Apple or HTC would stop selling things to Nebraskans? I literally just said Apple isn't the one who will have trouble affording to pay for these regulations. And that it's difficult to spare a tear for a big company. Reread my comment.
- sverige 10y agoHow many small manufacturers make a large percentage of their income by having a lock-in on repairs to their proprietary hardware? I'm having a hard time understanding who these little companies are that you're worried will be harmed by this law.
- dmix 10y agoIf only it was just this one law. 81 major regulations were added each year on average under the Obama administrations 8 years. Major was defined as costing over $100 million each. The federal register recording legislation has exploded to 75,000 pages from 20,000 a few decades ago. There are plenty of statistics which show the level of downward pressure regulation puts on small business. This isnt just mega corps wanting to dump chemicals in rivers. It's death by a thousand cuts to reach some ideal perfect consumer marketplace through extensive administrative oversight. Meanwhile the number of people are starting small businesses has declined significantly and GDP growth has totally stagnated. It's not a mistake that small business optimism index reached the highest point in decades (since 1980) after Trump announced major regulatory reform.
- stonogo 10y ago
- guitarbill 10y agoYou could make the argument that this law is only required because copyright, patents, licensing, and other regulations have gone far too far already. But the genie's out of the bottle. Seems like a good idea to me, too.
- mindslight 10y agoI'm pro open devices and anti imaginary property myself, but I don't see your argument. The only way I can connect your points is that perhaps without imaginary property, companies wouldn't have developed such a culture of secrecy and control - software would have stayed being seen as an "uninteresting" requirement of making a complete device. But with the ever-increasing complexity of software and the inherent irreversibility of compilation, I don't think that era would have lasted long regardless.
- guitarbill 10y agoMany forms of limiting what you can do to a device are DRM based, e.g. printer ink. And you can't legally circumvent DRM to enhance/restore what devices are actually capable of, not for any technical reason though. As for "complexity of software", it often isn't. What's complex are all the software patents and the licensing. I think you see a similar thing hobbling a lot of wireless hardware, or interop with wireless hardware. I get that many things now have software in them, but some things still need to be treated as a tool instead of a "service" for which you are granted a license. And if it's a one-time payment, being able to update the license whenever a company wants doesn't feel right either. Good steps towards this include this law, or the ruling in Germany (I think) that EULAs are invalid when presented to the user after the point of purchase.
- mindslight 10y ago> things still need to be treated as a tool instead of a "service" for which you are granted a license I fully agree with your normative point. Especially as more of the world is computerized, humans are left powerless if they do not have control over the computers they "own". I'm coming from the same place as you here, but... > Many forms of limiting what you can do to a device are DRM based, e.g. printer ink. And you can't legally circumvent DRM to enhance/restore what devices are actually capable of, not for any technical reason though. Sure, but many are limited by technical means. For example, there are many phones for which custom ROMs are not available, either because there hasn't been enough interest in rerooting the device or supplying developer time to create the alternative distribution. There's a lot of interest in doing so for a new popular device, but as it keeps getting revved and additional manufactures enter the market, enthusiasm is diluted and dissipates. And while manufacturers save costs through standardization (eg Linux/Android), they also work to decommodify their products to keep from entering a race to the bottom. We're fighting an uphill battle, fundamentally because understanding (compression) is harder than execution (compiling). Furthermore, devices have become cheap due to economies of scale, which inherently supports the centralization that leads to that decommodification. It's hard to see that we'll ever have a cottage industry of electronics production that isn't drawing from some heavily-centralized component source. I'm not saying the situation is hopeless, and obviously there is an equilibrium that we are in. But one must acknowledge these fundamental gradients if one wants to have any hope of addressing the situation in a pro-freedom manner.