5 ms·
Atheism, a Computer Model
- awinter-py 10y agoHmm -- the american religion is the ballot box, public school and TV. Without commenting on their effectiveness, these things legitimize our social order. Compare this to the ceremony identifying a pharaoh with the egyptian pantheon -- that's what legitimized them. If somebody watches 4 hours of TV a week and thinks without any critical examination that public school works, that person isn't an atheist. What these researchers are modeling in 1700 isn't the emergence of modern ideas, it's the liberation of european academia from control of the church as printing proliferates. Anti-authority isn't a 'modern' idea, it's just an idea that is easy to suppress when the forces of authority control the media.
- milesf 10y agoThe problem with this line of argumentation is atheism does not explain or give reasons for the most basic questions we have as human beings. Who am I? Why am I here? Where am I going? Also, in the realm of morality, everything atheism purports to be true is completely optional. We can all agree that murder is wrong, but what's to stop an independent person from asking the logical question "who says?". Objectively, why is murder wrong? Societies are very delicate things, and it does not take much to spin them out of control. When chaos rises, people will trade their freedoms for order, and there will be guns in the street. Just look at the rise and fall of the Roman Empire. Have a look at the series "How Should We Then Live?" by the late Dr. Francis Schaeffer. His insights into art, music, and architecture being a reflector and record of history is fascinating. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z0Hr0RLHxnI&list=PLl7doUcMOrBYczX5XwN83qg8I9iUMeCxV https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z0Hr0RLHxnI&list=PLl7doUcMOr... So people may very well give up their beliefs, for a time, but then the pendulum will swing back the other way hard, and societies will be grasping at some other explanation to answer those basic questions: who am I? why am I here? where am I going? This is all very well trodden territory. People chase their tails their entire lives trying to live without God, and end up being right back where they started at the end of their lives, just like Bertrand Russell did.
- baconner 10y ago>Also, in the realm of morality, everything atheism purports to be true is completely optional. Well, no. Atheism does not purport anything to be true at all. It's a lack of belief in one thing. I don't understand why that's so difficult for religious people to understand. Atheism is not a replacement for religion. There is no atheist rulebook, no set of beliefs, nothing. Atheists can of course have morals but they don't derive from atheism and are not hindered by it either. They're unrelated. *Edit, expanding... Your argument presupposes that the only place morals can be derived from is religion where that the rules exist is the entire argument for why you should follow them. God says so, end of discussion. There are better ways to derive morals based on day to day reality. There are better reasons not to murder than god says so.
- erikpukinskis 10y ago> It's a lack of belief in one thing. This is the biggest misconception I see amongst atheists. They think they are rejecting one idea, so-called "God", when in fact they are rejecting 4.7 billion different ideas, without having even understood what 4.6 billion+ of them are. They reject the God of their parents, and then extrapolate to all the others, deeming them all "one idea". Atheism is a hold-out of the old "single reality" idea. Ironically both atheists and strict religious fundamentalists share that property: the belief in one true way to understand reality, whether it's God or not-God. Rather than a willingness to allow others to define reality on their own terms.
- baconner 10y agoMy experience is most atheists are a lot more educated about the wide variety of religious beliefs than the religious who tend to just stick with whatever their parents believe. That's anecdotal but I think it's natural to go find out about other faiths as part of the process of questioning the faith of your parents or society. There may be 4.6+ billion variants of the idea, but I rejected the root idea, magic.
- erikpukinskis 10y ago
- dropit_sphere 10y agoThis sort of thing annoys the crap out of me. Religion is a complex subject. So is atheism. Complex enough, that the idea of being able to model either of them for research purposes (as opposed to game purposes, like in Civ IV), just seems incredibly silly. Incorporate all of the following into your model, and it will still be insufficient: kin altruism, war, banditry, social trust, epistemology, famine, genetic defects, mate selection and sexual strategies, the hedonic treadmill---and then, for each doctrine, incorporate signaling, countersignaling, hypocrisy. Does it sound like I'm holding the model to impossible standards? Hey, I'm not the one who titled the article, "Atheism, a computer model." Or you can just do boring projections from current trends, but who clicks on that?
- mlhaufe 10y agoThe towers of belief may be assaulted through formal systems such as Doxastic Logic: <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doxastic_logic> https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doxastic_logic>
- kapauldo 10y agoAtheism and religion are not peers. Religious believers should not read things like this article or this thread, because they think its an invitation to debate atheism as if its a peer to religion.