13 ms·
Apple Says Right to Repair iPhones Will Turn Nebraska Into a ‘Mecca’ for Hackers
- Silhouette 10y agoThis seems to be about the most reasonable legislative idea I've seen in tech in years. It's not surprising that Apple don't like it, but I don't think anyone expected them to, and the desperation and implausibility of the arguments they're presenting against it just reinforces how reasonable the changes would be. I did laugh slightly at the part where the Apple rep discovered they were dealing with an elected representative who actually was technical and actually would defend their position.
- tempodox 10y ago> You don't have to be afraid of technology—you have to be afraid of the people who are trying to prevent you from knowing the things they know. I think Brasch hit the nail on the head with that.
- notduncansmith 10y agoMy understanding of Apple's argument is that currently, it would take a significant investment of resources to introduce a working hardware vulnerability to a target device, and that if this ability became commoditized (and thus viable on a larger scale) the decreased security might cause irreparable harm in the time it takes us to collectively correct it. Say, a device that stores screen tap locations and exflitrates as you walk by free public wifi? Don't know how practical that is but you get the idea. There's no hardware equivalent of a hash function to verify that what you've acquired is what you requested. Most people will never take it apart to check or would be able to spot something amiss if they did.
- meanduck 10y agoFrom the article: > Right to repair bills, which are currently making their way through eight states (Nebraska, New York, Tennessee, Wyoming, Minnesota, Kansas, Illinois, and Massachusetts), would require electronics manufacturers to make repair parts and diagnostic and repair manuals available to independent repair professionals and consumers, not just "authorized" repair companies. This seems like forcing Apple rather than releasing consumers. Just another example of over interfering Govts.
- prodmerc 10y agoIMO it's a very good law for the population/nation/citizens. Ignoring that it will help small businesses, being able to do what you want with the things you bought should be a right, not a privilege. The government exists for stuff like this. If they don't interfere, then what? Your car stops working because you haven't made your mandatory overpriced yearly checkup? Sounds neat Also having access to at least service manuals (if not complete schematics) can help repair and reuse electronics, which is great for the environment, low wage workers/families and developing nations in general.
- meanduck 10y ago> IMO it's a very good law for the population/nation/citizens. But this is how Govts make enemies in business communities. Actions like these what made China 2nd most wealthy nation in record time. > Ignoring that it will help small businesses. How ? Common sense tell me this will put more legal requirements; those are never fun. > being able to do what you want with the things you bought should be a right, not a privilege Absolutely. But this forces Apple/others. It does not release customers from restrictions. If there are such any restrictions, Govts would be with in their rights to make such user/customer agreements unenforcable. But again, thats what not happening here. > Your car stops working because you haven't made your mandatory overpriced yearly checkup? Sounds neat How about you look for more favourable company ? But you know thats what people do. Such anti-customer corporations you are describing does not last for long in the market unless ofcourse Govts are helping them in someway, as the history shows. > Also having access to at least service manuals (if not complete schematics) can help repair and reuse electronics, which is great for the environment, low wage workers/families and developing nations in general Irrelevent. You are curbing liberties. Thats the argument against the law.
- prodmerc 10y agoThe whole planned obsolescence and recently "repairs/modifications only by authorized companies" is utter bullshit. At least it's easier to stop buying Crapple than John Deere.
- eganist 10y agoThe latter may actually be illegal given this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magnuson%E2%80%93Moss_Warranty_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magnuson%E2%80%93Moss_Warranty...
- rasz_pl 10y agoWhat is the difference between Apple Authorized iPhone Repair and Independent Repair?: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I2Vz6FwoXUE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I2Vz6FwoXUE Turns out some of those bills were practically written by Apple lobbyists - they are worded in a way to "let you do as much as Apple certified Repair", which as this video shows means it lets you mail in your broken stuff to Apple ... :(
- mcphage 10y agoUm... good?
- mikeash 10y agoRight? I saw the headline and thought, awesome! Wait... they think that's an argument against, don't they.
- supremesaboteur 10y ago> "Apple said we would be the only state that would pass this, and that we would become the mecca for bad actors," Brasch, who is sponsoring the bill, told me in a phone call. "They said that doing this would make it very easy for hackers to relocate to Nebraska." Oh, they meant the other type of hackers
- zardo 10y agoThose nasty electronics repair for hire hackers.
- asdfasfdfasdf 10y agoIsn't all this depressing after realizing the origins of Apple. There are no machines for hackers these days.. it's all "look at the looks of this fancy UI" today, with actual interaction being all but an afterthought. It'd be a different, better world if Symbolics had survived... but you know evolution doesn't quite work that way.
- tmzt 10y agoThe Homebrew Computing Club would be raided for trafficking in bare components, such as a novel, hand-soldered motherboard from a tiny company founded by two guys named Steve.
- archgoon 10y agoCurse those model train enthusiasts!
- exabrial 10y agoI'm very rarely for new regulations (very much libertarian and conservative), but this is one issue I will gladly "reach across the isle" on. In the end it'll spur all the things I like: small businesses, competition, market diversity, and innovation.
- dmix 10y agoOne of the issues is that this is a state policy and may act as a deterrent for global companies wanting to sell products within the state. It may very well be easier to just skip Nebraska and focus resources elsewhere. Especially for low margin electronics products. I'm sure Apple has enough resources to follow through with this but not all companies can afford the lawyers and special operations centers to appease local regulatory laws in a single state. Just look around you house and consider how many electronics came from a low budget Chinese vendor. I'm all for state rights but the costs should always be considered. As Thomas Sowell said: "Economics is not about good intentions and hopes. It's about cause and effect". For ex: US Chamber of Commerce just posted this article that 1/3 of small businesses surveyed said they hire less people because of health care costs. It's easy not to spare a tear for big companies. But the real victim of regulatory burden is not mega corps its the small businesses who account for 50% of all employment in the US and 90% of businesses are SMB. https://www.uschamber.com/above-the-fold/small-businesses-tell-congress-they-can-t-afford-obamacare https://www.uschamber.com/above-the-fold/small-businesses-te...
- mikeash 10y agoWould this really add a burden? These companies already make parts and service manuals available, some of them just restrict who is able to obtain them. To comply with the law, they would just need to stop restricting them.
- exabrial 10y agoAgree, but I will go out on a limb and say very few SMBs produce electronics (although there's a recent the trend in hardware startups).
- gech 10y ago
- hogrammer 10y agoI'm sure Nebraska wouldn't mind at all if tech savvy 'hackers' started moving in.
- nakedrobot2 10y agoMicrosoft has become less evil than Apple in the mindshare of the "technical folks" these days. This is pretty amazing! I am very quickly starting to lose any sympathy for apple as they turn from a great product company into a financially engineered entity without a trace of real innovation. With a full-on user-hostile attitude, to boot.
- prodigal_erik 10y agoI'm always surprised people see this as a recent trend. If a machine has no expansion ports and the case is sealed with the weirdest screws they could find, it was meant to be an appliance for consumers rather than a tool for people.
- gaius 10y agoThey are the same screws BMW uses for wingmirrors.
- trome 10y agoMhmm, and BMW isn't well known as a pinnacle of open, easy to repair cars either. Usually you end up pulling apart the whole front end on your beamer for something that'd take a few minutes to fix/replace on most other cars.
- gaius 10y agoI just mention that incase anyone is wondering what tool to Google for ;-)
- mikhailt 10y agoI was on the Nebraska's side until I saw this, did everyone miss this part or did the article incorrectly wrote this? > Right to repair bills in each state require manufacturers to provide software tools to bypass locks that prevent repair. No, sorry. I do agree with companies (not just Apple) with locking down the security components to ensure no one could just take your device, replace a few components and give it back without your knowledge. We live in an increasingly mobile-only world and where such mobile components are getting more complex, powerful and more information-dense. We're not talking about a dumb mower that is not storing any of your personal information, we're talking about a smart phone with complex security systems in it. Apple has the absolute right to protect it in order to protect your data, even in the ways that prevents you from repairing it yourself. With this law, there's no barrier or visible line between your ex replacing parts to monitor you and you replacing parts to repair it. Apple has a security lock for a very clear reason, to prevent your ex from doing this. If you want to repair the broken Touch ID sensor and stuff, take it to Apple or if there's no store, mail it in. If you just want to replace the battery or screen, then yes, Apple should be forced to sell these parts, just not the security related parts. Did the law clarify this distinction?
- WayneBro 10y agoYour entire argument amounts to: Trust Apple and nobody else. What makes you think that's a good idea? > We're not talking about a dumb mower that is not storing any of your personal information. Exactly. That's why it's even more important that we be able to repair it ourselves. > Apple has the absolute right to protect it in order to protect your data, even in the ways that prevents you from repairing your yourself. There are no absolute rights. There are laws. I trust myself more than Apple and I don't think there's much you can say to convince me otherwise. > If you want to repair, take it to Apple or if there's no store, mail it in. Nope. I'd rather not, thanks! That's why we're going to get this law passed.
- mikhailt 10y ago> Your entire argument amounts to: Trust Apple and nobody else. What makes you think that's a good idea? I don't trust anyone, but I only want Apple to hold the keys, not all random repair stores. It is a FAR worse idea to force Apple to provide security bypasses. If security bypasses can be provided securely as LONG as you authorize it on the spot, then heck yes, force Apple to do this. But if they cannot, then nope, they shouldn't be forced. > Exactly. That's why it's even more important that we be able to repair it ourselves. I don't think we're disagreeing here, I'm totally on your side that we should be able to repair everything ourselves but I cannot agree with forcing companies to provide security bypasses in a manner that may be done without your knowledge. > There are no absolute rights. There are laws. I trust myself more than Apple and I don't think there's much you can say to convince me otherwise. You are correct, I phrased it wrong since there is a clear technical definition of what absolute right means. I didn't say you shouldn't have the right to repair everything yourself. I'm totally on this but I disagree again on the security components, you should be able to replace it as long as it can be securely does and with information that only you know. Forcing Apple to provide this to repair shops without explicit controls over it, is a bad idea. > Nope. I'd rather not, thanks! That's why we're going to get this law passed. I've edited my post after that.
- edko 10y agoTo save Nebraska, maybe Apple should campaign for similar laws to be passed in all states; then, there will no incentive for the hackers to move there.
- EliRivers 10y agoIt is so telling that when we [1] read this headline, we thought Apple was saying how great this would be for Nebraska; that Apple is suggesting Nebraska can boost its economy and profile by becoming a hub for technological innovation. Turns out they're trying to scare Nebraska into not doing it. Doug Barnes, of course, told us all along that Apple was hostile to hackers. [1] Or at least, "I"; I'm hoping it applies to other people as well.
- r00fus 10y agoHere's the actual legislation [1] (pdf). Of note, notice the carve-out for automotive industry. > Sec. 7. Nothing in the Fair Repair Act shall apply to motor vehicle manufacturers, any product or service of a motor vehicle manufacturer, or motor vehicle dealers. Why is Nebraska making it easy to repair farm equipment and cell phones but not cars? [1] http://nebraskalegislature.gov/FloorDocs/105/PDF/Intro/LB67.pdf http://nebraskalegislature.gov/FloorDocs/105/PDF/Intro/LB67....
- kl_r 10y agoThe Nebraska legislature website blocks non-US IP's, so here's a link if you're outside the US: https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/257484/LB67.pdf https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/257484/LB67.pdf
- smashingweb 10y agoI believe it's related to the sale of aftermarket car parts related to auto theft. The same reason you can't become a seller of auto parts on Amazon
- ilyagr 10y agoDo, if Apple becomes or buys a motor vehicle manufacturer, they are exempt? If their self driving car project gains steam, this is in the realm of possibility.
- elastic_church 10y agoThey could also just stop selling in Nebraska because nobody cares.
- purple-again 10y agoThere are 8 states trying to do similar including New York. That's not a viable strategy for the company.
- edko 10y agoThere is this guy in Omaha, the one whose company owns over 57 million Apple shares, who might care.
- elastic_church 10y agoEven a shareholder would care about impact to revenues more than his ability to get an iphone from a neighboring state But nice try, turns out you can also own shares of foreign corporations that do no business anywhere near you, so there goes the basis for that argument
- edko 10y agoI do not see how stopping the sale of iPhones in Nebraska would help Apple solve the potential loss of revenue from the new competition in the repairs market. The main thing it would do is reduce sales revenue. I think every shareholder (based in Nebraska or otherwise) would be concerned about that.
- devoply 10y agoSteve Mobs would be proud.
- HugoDaniel 10y agoThe ideology in their logic: "Mecca" is bad because muslims are bad. Hackers are bad because they "think different" about your intended use for the technology. "Apple said we would be the only state that would pass this, and that we would become the mecca for bad actors," (implying that hackers are bad actors) "They said that doing this would make it very easy for hackers to relocate to Nebraska." (implying that Mecca is where bad people go) Its good to know some things never change[0] [0] http://cdn.cultofmac.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/06/a2original.jpg http://cdn.cultofmac.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/06/a2origin...
- indlebe 10y agoYou're projecting this ideology onto Apple. Out of all of the places that people make pilgrimages to, Mecca is the most well known, and therefore commonly used to refer to a place that's popular for likeminded followers to visit. E.g:It's very common in Canada for marijuana enthusiasts to refer to Vancouver as the Mecca of pot in Canada. There's no negativity in that phrase at all.
- Fricken 10y agoI think you're underestimating how carefully Apple chooses it's words when it's crafting these one-line public statements. When they use an ambiguously charged word like 'Mecca', they have carefully worked through every possible sub-text that might be associated with it, and if they use the word, then they are intentional about having those subtexts be associated with their statements. They could have said that 'right to repair legislation will turn Nebraska into a hub for Hackers', but that's not what they said.
- indlebe 10y ago>When they use an ambiguously charged word like 'Mecca' I don't believe mecca is an ambiguously charged word, nor do I see any evidence to support this claim. It's probably the most commonly used metaphor for a gathering place of like-minded individuals, and was the perfect choice in this context.
- 10y ago
- vacri 10y agoSuitably facetious counter-argument for the facetious Mecca statement: Well, given that the Hajj is over a million folks per year and Nebraska only has two million people, being that Mecca would bring in a ton of tourist money and employment opportunities. A huge economic windfall for the state.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]