4 ms·
What is frustrating is that the LEOs in the case had no clear standing for detaining Turner. TX is not a Stop and Identify state [1] (neither is CA). Amazing
by r00fus 10y ago
What is frustrating is that the LEOs in the case had no clear standing for detaining Turner. TX is not a Stop and Identify state [1] (neither is CA).
Amazing that the police can essentially ignore the laws they're sworn to uphold when it conveniences them. That and "the left him [in the back of a police car] to sweat for a while with the windows rolled up" method of coercion boils my blood.
It's like the definition of prejudice - if they think you're a criminal they'll treat you like shit.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stop_and_identify_statutes#States_with_.E2.80.9Cstop-and-identify.E2.80.9D_statutes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stop_and_identify_statutes#Sta...
- obstinate 10y agoThat is why the judge reversed the determination of qualified immunity for the two officers. :)
- dmix 10y agoSeems like a high bar to pass to have law abiding citizens treated with respect for the law. Same with getting cops to not be so quick to pull the trigger and default to respecting people's life. This attitude of absolute power that some American police hold is as much a cultural issue than one of legal semantics. It has to be confronted without being blown off as an attack on police. The best approach is probably taking a reasoned, most cops are good, approach and focus in on the minority who flaunt the law. The solution might be via policy (making it easier to fire cops) or training. But thanks to the all powerful unions I'm sure this will be a big uphill battle.
- obstinate 10y agoIt is far too high a bar. The police have always been very resistant to actually allowing the freedom the Constitution promises. This is only the latest example. One could wish for the police to just be decent people, and one could wish for a billion dollars. If wishes were horses ...
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- convolvatron 10y agoI don't understand this focus on the unions. as far as I can tell the entire* justice system acts as if this kind of extra-legal violence and coercion is necessary to keep the peace. cops, judges, prosecutors, elected officials, correctional facilities are all in on it. it seems like it would be more useful to bring it out in the open and discuss whats correct rather than pretending everyone has certain rights and simultaneously building institutions which systematically violate them.
- curun1r 10y agoOnly partially. The decision ruled that the officers were entitled to qualified immunity on the first amendment claim because, while the first amendment does protect his right to film, that wasn't clearly established at the time of the incident. It was only the fourth amendment claim for which the court ruled the officers don't deserve qualified immunity. Had they only hassled him and made him stop recording, they'd be getting off without a punishment. It was only because they arrested him (and it was only ruled that they arrested him because they didn't act with enough urgency to figure out what to do with him once they'd handcuffed him and put him in the pack of the police car) that they're being denied qualified immunity.
- wyldfire 10y ago> that wasn't clearly established at the time of the incident. Silver lining: it is now (in the jurisdiction of the fifth circuit).
- gozur88 10y ago>Amazing that the police can essentially ignore the laws they're sworn to uphold when it conveniences them. Except that they can't, it seems.
- r00fus 10y agoOne case where they're caught, where hundreds of times where their interpretation of the law is not questioned. I suppose it's a start, but I doubt this decision will result in operational changes directly.
- koenigdavidmj 10y agoNothing sufficient to deter an officer happened. The taxpayers pay a cursory fine and the department adds some training, when their training probably already outlined acceptable conditions to arrest someone. Only when officers are personally imprisoned will they have any second thoughts about doing this kind of thing again.
- aisofteng 10y agoPrejudice is defined as >preconceived opinion that is not based on reason or actual experience. Being a criminal is a choice. Treating someone differently because they you have sound reason to believe they are a criminal is not prejudice.