3 ms·
This sort of question is itself poor history. We cannot cleanly use today's popular cultural boundaries like "europe" and "arab world" to describe people 600 ye
by UncleMeat 10y ago
This sort of question is itself poor history. We cannot cleanly use today's popular cultural boundaries like "europe" and "arab world" to describe people 600 years ago. The assumption that we can bake all european nations into one civilization that has coherent and universal cause-effect relationships is not really solid.
- woodandsteel 10y agoSo what is your explanation as to why the West charged ahead, but the Middle East stagnated?
- UncleMeat 10y agoIts the wrong question, which is why you don't tend to find a lot of respected historians writing books that seek to answer this question. A lot of assumptions are baked into this question that historians do not think are valid. The sort of "why the west won" pop history makes experts cringe in the same way that articles on AI hysteria might make experts here cringe.