7 ms·
Don’t Take My Folders Away: Organizing Personal Info to Get Things Done (2005)
- aytekin 10y ago"... to Get Things Done" If the goal is to organize things for easy future browsing, the folder approach works well. But, if the goal is to clearly see what the next actions are and make progress on them, it is not a good approach since the latest and important items are buried somewhere deep inside all the folders.
- ORioN63 10y agoWhat's your opinion there? Any suggestions, for someone building a personal db.
- _mhr_ 10y agoI'm also working on a personal DB. My email's in my profile if you're interested in chatting about our ideas.
- nextos 10y agoorg-mode and org-capture or org-velocity.
- peppersmith 10y agohttp://www.zim-wiki.org/ http://www.zim-wiki.org/ is a personal database I use to organise notes, projects and scripts. Simple cross-note linking and automatic TODO list generation are particularly useful features I use frequently. The 'database' is stored markdown-formatted files that can be easily version controlled and edited from the command line.
- wolfgang42 10y agoI've done some Zim evangelism on HN before ([1], [2]), so I'll merely link those here and mention that I'd love to answer any questions about how I use it. [1]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13232861 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13232861 [2]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13134401 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13134401
- rodgerd 10y agohttps://taskwarrior.org/ https://taskwarrior.org/
- pjc50 10y agoThat's a todo list, and you can maintain one in a file instead. The folders are for keeping incoming data, references, suggestions, related concepts, and partial or completed working documents in.
- brchr 10y agoLooks like this is a 2005 study from William Jones, et al. If folks are interested in this line of research, Jones has a 2007 book called Keeping Found Things Found that takes a more comprehensive look at personal information management.
- nhebb 10y agoThe ability to organize email into folders is one of the main reasons I prefer Outlook over GMail. But as the paper mentions, "Folders can obscure as well as organize", which is where tags come in handy. What I would really like - for both email and files - is the ability to create both folders and tags quickly.
- hodgesrm 10y agoI agree with you on documents, which tend to be small in number so you can index them manually using folders. But what about the case where you get hundreds of messages a day? If you get 300 messages a day you'll accumulate over 100K messages annually. Manual indexing seems like madness. I don't even try rule based tagging at that point. In this latter case the gmail model is great. I leave everything in the inbox and depend on gmail (a) never to lose it and (b) to find it easily through search. In fact you can use gmail as a doc store--if there's something I really value I make it an email attachment and depend on gmail to dig it up if necessary.
- nhebb 10y agoI think of search as a default functionality (although it was actually pretty bad in older versions of Outlook). But from a usability standpoint, software shouldn't pigeonhole users into one method or another. Since everyone's work flow is different, it's all about providing users flexibility.
- zokier 10y ago> But from a usability standpoint, software shouldn't pigeonhole users into one method or another. Since everyone's work flow is different, it's all about providing users flexibility. I'm not sure if I agree. I think it might be better to software to excel in one specific workflow rather than attempt to cater everyone. Of course this requires the market to provide different options for different workflows.
- vidarh 10y agoI get hundreds of messages a day. I don't accumulate over 100k messages annually as very few of those hundreds of messages a day are necessary to retain. What isn't automatically filtered, I look at, and either delete, archive or categorise. I don't leave everything in the inbox for the reason that I can't find what I want, in part because the search is awful. A large part of the problem is that unlike websites where pagerank and context provided by inbound links allow a lot of intelligence, with my e-mail it is often a struggle to find the right search terms, and so I want to add context in the forms of categorisation to the messages I actually have a reason to keep. Gmails poor folder support kept me from using it for my work account for many years, until they "surrendered" from their original hardline tagging stance and added more support to allow you to treat tags like hierarchical folders, for this reason. I can't imagine keeping an unstructured inbox like what you're describing - I wouldn't find a thing. I always despair when I have to resort to Gmails search as it almost invariably means I'm in for frustration.
- noonespecial 10y agoIf you think about it, folders are really like limited tags where the only relationship you are allowed is "and then". It would be nice to see a system that would present a tag set in the appearance of folders for all "and then" relationships but then let you mix in things like "and also", "or", and "but not".
- potato122 10y agoI think we're looking for the same thing.
- foobarbecue 10y agoI have been begging for this for years! Make it!
- NobleLie 10y agoSee my sibling post :-)
- NobleLie 10y agoHi. My brother and I are working on a note taking system; one of the focuses being increased utility of tags. Of note relating to tags: - tags are hierarchically organized and inherit their parents. (Systems like gmail and evernote dont do this?! o_O) - NOT and AND blocks - Option for seeing full lineage of tag - "Tag Clusters" which are basically a named group of tags that are commonly used and can be bulk applied to an item On the way: Full AST (abstract syntax tree) tag/user/text querying (the UI isnt the easiest to nail down for OR / parenthetical groups) Laddice.com (desktop app only right now) Feel free to check it out, make an account and email me with thoughts, opinions and/or requests (email's in my profile.) Would love to talk more about this with you!
- noonespecial 10y agoInteresting. I'm working on an image tagging system that basically does the same. It grew out of the fact that I'm the family historian and I have 40k family pictures spanning 8 households that go back to 1840. Gets hard to find that one picture you vaguely remember seeing once.
- potato122 10y agoI'm on a MacBook. Is there some type of virtual folder type that I can use that behaves like any other folder? Something where the files and folders within don't actually 'live' there. I don't like tags because they're not tangible. If they could live somewhere on the desktop where I could click them, or be nestable, I would use them.
- robwormald 10y agoYou might be looking for Smart Folders - https://support.apple.com/kb/PH22188?locale=en_US https://support.apple.com/kb/PH22188?locale=en_US
- zokier 10y agoSymlinks? Lots and lots of symlinks?
- coldtea 10y agoSmart (query based) Folders and Tags? Both of which macOS offers...
- _jsn 10y agoYou can create a Smart Folder that is based on one or more Tags (or any other combination of metadata, but Tags are useful in that you can manipulate them directly).
- jen729w 10y agoI do this rigorously with tremendous success. I can find anything, instantly. Yes, it takes a little work up front. For me, the payback is obvious and extreme. I have to get round to finishing my site so please excuse its current incompletion, but hey, if you're interested: http://johnnydecimal.com http://johnnydecimal.com I use this system at work and I have otherwise very competent Project Managers stare at me like I'm some sort of wizard when I navigate to the right folder, the first time, every time, and find exactly what I'm looking for. Email, our shared drive, SharePoint - I use it everywhere. I would be a mess without it.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- mxuribe 10y agoI just read the stuff on johhnydecimal.com and am near-instantly hooked! I've signed up for your mailing list, and am really pumped up to see when this is finished, and when more stuff gets added...and I appreciate that i can start implementing your recommendations immediately. Well done and kudos, I must say!
- jen729w 10y agoThank you thank you thank you so much. Glad I posted this here - now I have a real incentive to finish the thing.
- fabiandesimone 10y agoThank you! This is phenomenal. I already started implementing this + Hazel. Love it!
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- drieddust 10y agoGreat system, thanks for sharing. I think this will give my OCD brain something to hang on instead of trying to invent something every few months.
- nileshtrivedi 10y agoI haven't yet got around to use it but TagSpaces seems interesting: https://www.tagspaces.org/ https://www.tagspaces.org/
- ronaldvalente 10y agoA good folder hierarchy is key to my OCD sanity. I never truly trust search alone. Tagging is not reliable as it depends on your state of mind being 100% consistent every time you add a tag to a file. Reliably defining scope and organizing by category within scope is much more consistent. Nice Post!