3 ms·
If that "vision" relates only to the design or structure of the software, then I believe that meritocracy means conforming to the project owner's standards. But
by krapp 10y ago
If that "vision" relates only to the design or structure of the software, then I believe that meritocracy means conforming to the project owner's standards. But if it's about politics or social issues taking precedence over the code, then I would be opposed to it.
There are plenty of angry, uncivil, misogynistic and racist 'thought leaders' in tech who are respected not for their political views (although sometimes, yes) but for the quality and popularity of their projects, so I think the premise of software being meritocratic is fairly well established.
- wolfgke 10y ago> If that "vision" relates only to the design or structure of the software, then I believe that meritocracy means conforming to the project owner's standards. At least in this case "meritocracy" does not mean "the opinion (about code structure etc.) that is (necessarily) shared by the majority of the contributors".
- krapp 10y agoWell, yeah, many if not all open source projects are dictatorships by necessity - not everyone's opinion can matter when only one or a few people are actually able to accept pull requests. Even the ones that accept the will of the majority are doing so by an arbitrary fiat. But if the majority of contributors disagree with the owner about fundamental design issues, that's what forks are for.