5 ms·
> I don't understand why Ubuntu is receiving so much bad comments from Linux community 12.04: System V 14.04: Upstart 16.04: System D 18.04: ??? Gahh...sti
by paulddraper 10y ago
> I don't understand why Ubuntu is receiving so much bad comments from Linux community
12.04: System V
14.04: Upstart
16.04: System D
18.04: ???
Gahh...stick with something. I'm tired of learning an entirely new init system every couple years.
To be fair, this is a problem with Linux stuff in general; I just wish Ubuntu could lead the pack in picking something and sticking to it.
- binarymax 10y agoYes this!!!! I develop lots of side projects that I always host in Ubuntu. They are web projects that require knowledge of configuring, stopping, and starting services on the box with ease. I am fully comfortable with upstart - but to learn systemD adds a huge amount of overhead to someone like me with little time who just wants to enjoy coding and shipping fun projects. I don't want to be a fulltime sysadmin just so I can launch a demo or game that nobody will ever use!
- slitaz 10y agoActually the move to systemd is quite easy. There are cheatsheets available.
- problems 10y ago> Gahh...stick with something. I'm tired of learning an entirely new init system every couple years. I had this problem too - I gave up and moved to runit. It's basically an improved version of DJB's daemontools, you write very simple scripts, it monitors their output, handles logging, and service management and that's it. Very minimalist, but quite capable. And, quite importantly, it's capable of running on top of another init system, it doesn't need to be PID 1, so I'm able to run it on FreeBSD with rc, Linux with sysvinit and Linux with systemd with the same script. It makes it so easy to write service scripts I went from running my personal stuff inside a tmux script to runit in about an hour.
- simosx 10y agoHere is the corrected table: 4.10: System V (in 2004), first release, adopted from Debian 6.10: Upstart (in 2006), see http://upstart.ubuntu.com/index.html http://upstart.ubuntu.com/index.html 16.04: systemd (in 2016) and it was gradual. This is part of the natural evolution of software. There are new requirements and new software is needed to implement them.
- paulddraper 10y agoWell, technically, systemd was 15.04.
- syntheticnature 10y agoTo be fair, this is a problem with Linux stuff in general; I just wish Ubuntu could lead the pack in picking something and sticking to it. It's the use of the CADT development model: https://www.jwz.org/doc/cadt.html https://www.jwz.org/doc/cadt.html
- digi_owl 10y agoI suspect they would still be on upstart if not logind was hogtied to the rest of the systemd shoggoth.
- jldugger 10y agoWhat's the chart look like on RHEL?