4 ms·
> The size of the country absolutely has something to do with how far apart things are. > Urban sprawl is enabled "Enabled" is the key word here. The US has e
by TulliusCicero 10y ago
> The size of the country absolutely has something to do with how far apart things are.
> Urban sprawl is enabled
"Enabled" is the key word here. The US has enough space to sprawl out if it so chose, and indeed, we chose that. We didn't have to, though, and we could choose differently for the future.
If we want better transit in the future, we could start choosing, via policy, regulations that encourage communities that are more walk- and transit-friendly. Other countries have little suburbs that still have decent transit, that don't require people to own a car to do normal errands, and we could have that too, if we wanted.
- sokoloff 10y agoYes, some people could choose that. Not everyone will, obviously, and maybe not even a majority of people will choose that.
- TulliusCicero 10y agoRight, I'm not saying we have to. But I do think it would be beneficial in a bunch of ways: more environmentally friendly, physically healthier, cheaper, safer, etc. And I think lots of other people agree those are good outcomes, the biggest issue is that people in the US have trouble imagining it working for them, because car-dominant sprawl is all they've known, and transit wherever they live is either non-existent or very bad.
- hnal943 10y agoYes. Maybe the people who want that already live in dense cities and the rest of the country is happy with the way it is.
- TulliusCicero 10y agoMost people don't even know that dense, walkable, transit-friendly areas outside of a major city are a possible thing.
- mason240 10y agoThank you for being honest about your desire to force other people to live how you want them too, rather than how they choose to.
- TulliusCicero 10y ago1. It's not about forcing people to choose one way or the other(a). It's about being honest about two things: a) That it WAS a choice, not some geographic inevitability, as is often suggested; we could've chosen differently, and we still can today. b) That this particular choice has some very real costs in terms of finances, health, safety, etc. My belief is that if Americans were more aware of the costs and the possible alternatives, many more people, possibly a majority, would probably support those alternatives. But there's a ton of cultural momentum behind driving in the US, and most people have never even lived anywhere where walking and transit were viable ways to get around, so they don't consider it a realistic policy option, even though it is. 2. My ideal is having a variety of transportation options be viable. Does being able to choose from walking, biking, transit, and driving sound like being 'forced' more than having no choice but to drive? The status quo restricts our choices much more than my ideal would. A - Although since we're talking about government regulations, it's true that no matter what happens, people are going to be 'forced' on some level, since you don't get individual choice over your built environment.