4 ms·
> The costs of European political division into multiple competing states were substantial: they included almost incessant warfare, protectionism, and other coo
by flukus 10y ago
> The costs of European political division into multiple competing states were substantial: they included almost incessant warfare, protectionism, and other coordination failures. Many scholars now believe, however, that in the long run the benefits of competing states might have been larger than the costs. In particular, the existence of multiple competing states encouraged scientific and technological innovation.
I wonder if this is still true today and if globalism will ultimately make us worse off?
- vkreso 10y agoI wouldn't say globalism means uniformal activity and communication without competition as you would suggest, quite the contrary. Competition is far more bigger today but with much less violence.
- return0 10y agoGlobalism means more and more kinds of competition are removed as regulation is removed. For example, look at the coordination between the major central banks across the world. Also, monopolies prevail.
- vkreso 10y agoYes on that scale, but as regulations are removed, competition on a more micro level is booming. Although we see today somewhat institutional monopolies I wouldn't like to predict how long those will last and how long they will be stable especially since it's a complex system. We are, after all, only beginning globalisation (in the sense of collective global system coordination) and will probably (re)discover new mechanisms along the way.
- return0 10y ago> but as regulations are removed, competition on a more micro level is booming. If the internet is an example, that doesn't happen.
- anotherarray 10y agoSo, should we give up on relative peace for the sake of scientific and technological innovation? Not an attack, but an actual question.
- reacweb 10y agoAbout utopian world, this may interest you: http://io9.gizmodo.com/how-rats-turned-their-private-paradise-into-a-terrifyin-1687584457 http://io9.gizmodo.com/how-rats-turned-their-private-paradis...
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- basseq 10y agoThat quote doesn't say that "political competition" was the best approach to innovation, nor that globalism would be worse. Merely that the proverbial ROI of competing states wasn't negative. More importantly, it seems that the fragmentation in Europe allowed "peer pressure" to avoid descents into authoritarianism that would have limited intellectual innovation. And that fragmentation did not fragment "the market". ("Political fragmentation existed alongside a remarkable intellectual and cultural unity.") So: as long as globalization doesn't limit individual intellectual innovation, it might be a good think because of global unification. Competition helps drive innovation, but it doesn't have to be state competition and political division.