17 ms·
How did Europe become the richest part of the world?
- flukus 10y ago> The costs of European political division into multiple competing states were substantial: they included almost incessant warfare, protectionism, and other coordination failures. Many scholars now believe, however, that in the long run the benefits of competing states might have been larger than the costs. In particular, the existence of multiple competing states encouraged scientific and technological innovation. I wonder if this is still true today and if globalism will ultimately make us worse off?
- vkreso 10y agoI wouldn't say globalism means uniformal activity and communication without competition as you would suggest, quite the contrary. Competition is far more bigger today but with much less violence.
- return0 10y agoGlobalism means more and more kinds of competition are removed as regulation is removed. For example, look at the coordination between the major central banks across the world. Also, monopolies prevail.
- vkreso 10y agoYes on that scale, but as regulations are removed, competition on a more micro level is booming. Although we see today somewhat institutional monopolies I wouldn't like to predict how long those will last and how long they will be stable especially since it's a complex system. We are, after all, only beginning globalisation (in the sense of collective global system coordination) and will probably (re)discover new mechanisms along the way.
- return0 10y ago> but as regulations are removed, competition on a more micro level is booming. If the internet is an example, that doesn't happen.
- anotherarray 10y agoSo, should we give up on relative peace for the sake of scientific and technological innovation? Not an attack, but an actual question.
- reacweb 10y agoAbout utopian world, this may interest you: http://io9.gizmodo.com/how-rats-turned-their-private-paradise-into-a-terrifyin-1687584457 http://io9.gizmodo.com/how-rats-turned-their-private-paradis...
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- basseq 10y agoThat quote doesn't say that "political competition" was the best approach to innovation, nor that globalism would be worse. Merely that the proverbial ROI of competing states wasn't negative. More importantly, it seems that the fragmentation in Europe allowed "peer pressure" to avoid descents into authoritarianism that would have limited intellectual innovation. And that fragmentation did not fragment "the market". ("Political fragmentation existed alongside a remarkable intellectual and cultural unity.") So: as long as globalization doesn't limit individual intellectual innovation, it might be a good think because of global unification. Competition helps drive innovation, but it doesn't have to be state competition and political division.
- lazyjones 10y agoInterestingly, they completely ignored the Hanseatic League, one of the most powerful economic and political entities for centuries: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hanseatic_League https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hanseatic_League Perhaps it was one of the most important contributing factors to Europe's success.
- ttsubotai 10y agoThe article overlooks a very important factor, that only Europe had colonies in the Americas, and that brought massive wealth to the continent since the XVI century. Before that, the Middle-East, India and China were , in general, more technologically and scientifically advanced than Europe.
- jcranmer 10y agoWell, the key question is why did the Arab World and Asian civilizations fail to do the colonization that the Europeans did. Also, the parity between Europe and the rest of Eurasia was largely achieved around the 1400s, which is to say, prior to the first wave of colonization.
- bluedino 10y ago>> why did the Arab World and Asian civilizations fail to do the colonization that the Europeans did Perhaps because of the sheer size of Asia. Western Europe isn't exactly large.
- clort 10y agoWestern Europe? Do you mean the landmass that extends all the way from the Atlantic ocean to the Pacific? You can walk all the way from the Bering strait to the Atlantic Ocean, and down to the tip of Africa.. thats a pretty large landmass and there was no gulf between Asia and Europe. (its pretty inhospitable in parts I agree, but the Mongol Empire reached the Mediterranean)
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- oh_sigh 10y agoAlso, perhaps, because the Arabs who were conquering were generally a land-based civilization, whereas the English, Dutch, French, Spanish, Portuguese, were all sea faring civilizations. Certainly the Arabs had boats and knew how to use them, but I'm not sure sea voyages held the same cultural cachet in the ancient Arab world as it did in the ancient European coastal civilizations.
- mercer 10y agoWhile I only just got started, there's a Cousera course named "The Modern World"[1] that, based on the introduction, explores this topic (among others). [1]: https://www.coursera.org/learn/modern-world https://www.coursera.org/learn/modern-world
- hugh4life 10y agoI remember coming up a book one time(maybe reviewed by Razib Khan) that made this exact point that much of Europe's progress came from it's internal conflict but I have not been able to find it again... does anyone have a clue what I may be thinking of?
- fbonetti 10y agoYou might be thinking of "Guns, Germs, and Steel"
- ptaipale 10y agoThat would be it (by Jared Diamond). An interesting followup from another angle is "Why nations fail" by Acemoglu and Robinson.
- UncleMeat 10y agoNote that GGS is not actually held in high regard by academic historians. Its pop history.
- woodandsteel 10y agoThat's really not true. Do you have any specific arguments against it? Is it your view, for instance, that non-euasian continents could have achieved the power of eurasia, in spite of their lack of suitable plants and animals, and if so, what accounts for what actually happened?
- UncleMeat 10y agoThis just comes with close personal association with a whole bunch of history PhDs. I myself am not an expert on the topic, but they talk about this book the way that psychologists talk about Gladwell. If you want an example of respected history that follows this sort of geographic history model you should read Braudel.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- vyodaiken 10y agoGo to any major European city. Look at all the loot in the museums. Figure it out. Mea culpa - too snarky. But there is a lot of research in this field and way too much self congratulatory material. A look at the Opium Wars should be enough to convince that more guns goes a long way to an explanation. Also Graeber's "Debt" gives some sense of how Europe managed to construct an economy that produced a desperation for loot that was quite remarkable.
- dang 10y agoPlease don't post unsubstantive comments to HN, especially not with snark on top. It degrades the level of discussion below what we're hoping for here. I'm sure you can make your substantive point informatively if you want to. If you don't want to (or don't have time), posting nothing is also an option.
- mafribe 10y agoThis begs the question: why didn't nobody else succeed in looting the Europeans. It's not like the other Empires around the world were Gandhian paradises of peaceful coexistence. They were waging war on each other, looting, and going on slavery raids just like Europeans. Go and look at Aztect ruins in Mesoamerica sometimes and marvel the the monuments where the prists were sacrificing humans. Yet, despite the experience with war and violence, they (almost) never managed to beat Europeans, and certainly never colonised Europe (after the Muslims were thrown out of Europe ... Well ... depending whom you ask, the (descendants of the) Ottoman Empire are still colonising parts of Europe today ... Just ponder why Constantinople is no longer called Constantinople). Why? What did Europe have they didn't?
- arjie 10y agoDoes the question make sense? The idea of a unified Europe is modern. Rome conquered Gaul, Serbia was in the Ottoman Empire, the Mongols traveled quite far west. The idea that Holland invading and capturing Britain meant different things then than it does now. Now they're both European nations. Then they were just two different nations. At least two books that provide hypotheses with some supporting evidence are: Guns, Germs, and Steel; and A Splendid Exchange. One thing that I found incredibly interesting in common was superior technology and the positive feedback loop with that. By this, I mean financial technology (loans, trade, financial derivatives) as well as weapons and mills.
- kartan 10y agoNo. War is not progress. War has cost a lot to European countries, being WWII one of the major loses in history in human lives and resources. I have hear other, more plausible, explanations. Weather is one. The fact that Eurasia is wide means that it has similar conditions in large portions of land, so you can reuse technology for agriculture across all of it. In Australia and Africa weather is not so good for agriculture. America is rich, but being narrow you need to create new agriculture techniques as you move south or north, as the landscape, weather and other factors are changing. War is present in all cultures. So some more unique qualities should be looked for. And luck can't be discarded.
- Cuuugi 10y agoThe article didn't specifically say war, just multiple competing states. This drove up trade, but also division. European history has had more conflict that any other region. Also, War has undeniably driven technological advances throughout history. Conflict does not create riches, you are correct. Competition does create riches ( and sometimes conflict)
- badsock 10y agoYes. I don't think it's a coincidence that the two periods in history that provided much of the foundations of Western civilization (Ancient Greece and the Renaissance) took place amongst intensely competing city-states.
- sqeaky 10y agoI agree with you on all sentences but one. > Also, War has undeniably driven technological advances throughout history. The opportunity cost of a war is huge. It can easily be argued that it is larger than the perceived gain of a war. Objectively measuring those two costs is another matter, but there is nothing undeniable about it. Let's pick WWII as an example. Rockets came out of it and put people on the moon. What if we had peace instead what would those rocket scientist have done instead? Likely they still would rockets and other vehicles, but their would have been input from more scientists and it would have taken a few extra years while those scientists made other things. The moon would have happened anyway, but probably in a more sustainable way than a postwar "space race". What about Nuclear power? Maybe delaying that a few years might equal the economic output of the two cities it obliterated. Another view, without the specter of nuclear war we could have built more of the cleanest and safest power source we ever devised and redirected all the labor on coal and oil to other areas that nearly limitless energy might provide.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- ThrustVectoring 10y agoThe article does not even mention geography, which is extraordinarily important for generating wealth. You need to feed people and ship goods in order to make stuff, and it's way cheaper and easier to use navigable rivers through arable farmland than any alternatives. This represents a huge chunk of free capital, and the network in Northern Europe is one of the largest ones (iirc, second to the Mississippi River).
- pan69 10y agoThere is an interesting documentary series by Naill Ferguson on this subject. In his series he discuses the "6 killer applications" that made the West dominate the rest: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wR6SFLhD32Q https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wR6SFLhD32Q
- vyodaiken 10y agoSeriously, Naill Ferguson is a poor historian. https://global.oup.com/academic/product/before-european-hegemony-9780195067743?cc=us&lang=en& https://global.oup.com/academic/product/before-european-hege... also http://piketty.pse.ens.fr/files/Pomeranz2000.pdf http://piketty.pse.ens.fr/files/Pomeranz2000.pdf
- stuckagain 10y agoBy defining "rich" in such a way as to put themselves at the top.
- skookumchuck 10y agoOne explanation is the book "Triumph of the West" by Roberts. He makes the case for it being the culture.
- dzonga 10y agoSimply, the quest to kill your enemies or paranoia of getting killed by them. Internet, GPS, Drugs etc to have an advantage in warfare
- distances 10y agoI have a feeling you didn't read the article.
- pm90 10y ago> The Indian subcontinent and the Middle East were fragmented for much of their history, and Africa even more so, yet they did not experience a Great Enrichment. eh what? The Indian subcontinent was one of the most productive regions of the world, accounting for almost 25% of the world GDP right before being colonized and having its creative/artisan class decimated. If no deliberate effort had been expounded to destroy its artisan/merchant class, Enlightenment ideas might have spread faster and created a much more dynamic economy.
- elevenfist 10y agoLooking at the comments in this thread, I'm really starting to get sick of the stupidity and ignorance of the hn community. I hope you're all just paid provacateurs. War isn't some special attribute of european history or success. While some people (mostly on the narc spectrum) are motivated by competition, many aren't Historical Counterexamples: Chinese warring states periods, Japanese warring states periods, post gupta and mughal empires in India, west African pre colonial history, and there's many more.
- fauigerzigerk 10y agoThis sounds like little more than pure speculation. Based on the exact same factors the article very selectively chooses to highlight, you could just as well claim that it wasn't competition but a very high degree of integration that has made Europe so successful and that all the competition and war between states has just obscured this fact. You could then go on and invoke the example of the United States to show that even deeper integration without too much internal warfare resulted in an even better outcome in terms of wealth. This is nothing but fluff. You could pick and choose your variables to prove anything and its exact opposite based on that sort of reasoning. What's the empirical basis for any of this? Why should we believe this theory and not some other theory? I don't see it.
- hodgesrm 10y agoHistory is like that sometimes. The root causes are tangled and we have to do the best with what we have. That said, I don't think this article is framing the question well. If you focus just on one part of the wealth, namely industrialization, it's clear that different countries have done this in different ways. For example if you compare England (first mover) vs. Japan (catch up driven in large part by defense) the outcome was still quite similar in that both countries successfully mastered mass production with corresponding economic benefits to the country as a whole. Yet the details of the societies at the start could hardly be more different. It's hard to escape the conclusion that many regions would sooner or later would have met the conditions for rapid economic growth. The question of why it happened in Europe is not necessarily the most interesting one.
- kenning 10y agoWelcome to the social sciences
- dang 10y agoPlease don't post snarky dismissals to HN. The comment you replied to was fairly substantive, so your reply takes the thread in the opposite of the desired direction. We detached this comment from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13670932 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13670932 and marked it off-topic.
- snambi 10y agoSimple, because they stole from the rest of the world.
- sgift 10y agoLike everyone else. Difference: Success.
- pm90 10y agoNot that simple, I'm afraid.
- Cuuugi 10y agoFALL IN LINE WITH THE NARRATIVE. WHITE MEN = EVIL INCARNATE
- EliRivers 10y agoThe amount of wealth they ended up with was far, far in excess of the total wealth that existed in the world when they started. You can't steal what doesn't exist.
- FreekNortier 10y agoEurope was great before she had any colonies. Living in Africa my entire life I can see that Europe and the countries where her children settled(USA, Canada, Aus, Nz) are the light of the world.
- woodandsteel 10y agoThe author mentions that there were a great many lucky accidents involved in the rise of the West. That is a factor that I think helps explain the Fermi Paradox. It is not enough to have an intelligent species, what they produce over the long term would seem to be civilizations that lack the sort of self-perpetuating technology dynamics that we have had in the West.
- FreekNortier 10y agoEurope was great before she had any colonies. Living in Africa my entire life I can see that Europe and the countries where her children settled(USA, Canada, Aus, Nz) are the light of the world.