3 ms·
I'm not surprised that people who design boring machines or design tunnels are not regular readers or commentators here on HN :-). Like Musk, I've felt that tun
by ChuckMcM 10y ago
I'm not surprised that people who design boring machines or design tunnels are not regular readers or commentators here on HN :-). Like Musk, I've felt that tunneling is under utilized (unfortunately I don't have the resources he has to bring to bear on it) but there is a wealth of information out there on the current state of tunneling. Three interesting projects that have a number of 'explainers' and various papers out there are the Channel Tunnel (the 'Chunnel'), the Gotthard Base tunnel in Switzerland, and the Seattle Alaskan Way Viaduct.
These three provide a useful survey level of understanding of the elements of building tunnels, the challenges to be met, and to some extent what is possible today.
Seattle is particularly instructive with regard to the impact on existing buildings vs depth and the challenges of fixing a tunneler mid-bore as it were. The Chunnel provides some great experience on depth and the ability to withstand pressure, and the Gotthard tunnel went through everything from sand to bedrock and speaks well to the ways of mitigating different materials. Taking the time to read the material on those three projects can certainly make you feel like you understand some of the issues.
Musk is correct in that there are a lot of things that are "well known" now by various engineering firms. For example producing pre-stressed wall sections so that a boring machine can leave behind tunnel instead of an unfinished hole. The process of supplying material and removing it, the build as you go narrow gauge rail lines for moving the tunneler and the material, and mitigation factors for different kinds of material (from rock to sand). There are practical considerations that aren't technological. For example you need ventilation. And that means a vent shaft to the surface periodically, and that means negotiating with people above the tunnel for access for that. Getting in and out of the tunnel is also its own challenge. If you want to let people drive their own cars in a tunnel you need a way to get in and get out, if you put a bus or a train in the tunnel you need stations where people can board. Those kinds of things, which involve negotiation with people who might not share, and might even resent, your vision seems to be the "hard" problem to the idea.
- abduhl 10y agoI design both boring machines and tunnels and am a regular reader on HN. I have worked on tunnels ranging from the smallest to the largest, rock to soil, and all forms of construction. I have stopped commenting on any tunnel related Elon topic due to people refusing to believe my experience and expertise when it does not align with what Elon Musk and his team of "experts" have said or published in their desk studies.
- toomuchtodo 10y agoWhat's the going rate for a used tunnel boring machine? EDIT: "New machines normally cost at least $15 million, but a decade of frantic subway construction in China has created a glut, and lightly used models can be had for 90 percent off sticker." I could Kickstart a tunnel boring machine purchase. What a time to be alive.
- ChuckMcM 10y agoAwesome! I've got a question that I have not been able to answer. Seattle's "Big Bertha" is surplus once they finish the Alaska Viaduct project in a few months. What process could I use to establish whether or not one could use that machine locally? Assume I can get an inventory of all parts used in the machine. And a related question, is there a way to estimate the cost to retarget a used machine to a new mission?
- abduhl 10y agoI doubt Bertha will be purchasable given the litigation on the SR 99 job. I don't know what you would be able or want to use it for - it's 58.5 ft in diameter. It is unlikely that you will get an inventory of all the parts in the machine. If you really want a machine then you would just call the contractor and ask them their price. You would likely have to pay for delivery. The process to establish whether or not one could use that machine locally is just whether or not you have a job that needs a 58.5 ft diameter TBM set up the way theirs is. In other words, the process to establish whether or not one could use the machine again locally is basically to go through the design process for the tunnel (preliminary design, geotechnical exploration, laboratory testing, final design, etc.).
- ChuckMcM 10y ago> I doubt Bertha will be purchasable given the > litigation on the SR 99 job. Can you say a bit more about this? I had reasoned that the litigation would make it more likely that Bertha would be purchasable as a way to offset costs/losses for the party that holds title to the equipment. > I don't know what you would be able or want to > use it for - it's 58.5 ft in diameter. One of the longest bus routes in the Bay Area is the '22'. It travels up and down El Camino Real from San Jose to Palo Alto. El Camino Real keeps going north right up the peninsula to San Francisco. To the south it goes down to Gilroy. My proposal is to tunnel from the where it crosses Highway 152, up past Palo Alto and into Milbrae where there is both a CalTrain and BART station about 200' off of El Camino Real. My proposal would be to create bus stops along the way that took you up to the surface street of El Camino along the way. Then run bus service north south, with several different bus types "express", "local", "intercity", etc. The tunnel diameter can support four lanes of traffic (two in each direction) allowing for buses to pass one another and to support multiple schedules in the same tunnel. Based on my evaluation of the Viaduct plan this plan would use it in substantially the same way.