5 ms·
No surprise they went to Gene Munster for a comment. Munster is the dweeb predicted Apple would make their own TV for 6 years running, and frantically pestered
by valuearb 10y ago
No surprise they went to Gene Munster for a comment. Munster is the dweeb predicted Apple would make their own TV for 6 years running, and frantically pestered Apple on investor calls to make it happen. This despite the fact that the entire Television market is a tiny fraction of the PC market, let alone the smartphone/tablet markets, and it never made sense for Apple to ever make a TV set.
Most analysts have no clue what it takes to run a business, they are focused on balance sheet and income statements separate from the reality that created them (which is the exact opposite of what Buffett does). The Apple Watch was about as successful as was possible (probably the best selling watch in history by revenues), and some analysts flipped out that it wasn't as big as the iPhone (even though Apple Watch outsold iPhone in their first year).
The latest AppleTV is great, a substantial improvement to the previous model, and very competitive in every way other than cost (it's ease of use premiums is worthwhile though IMHO). I use Siri, play games with my kids, subscribed to HBO/Netflix, etc. The only reason sales declined over the previous model is that it's significantly more expensive. But the reality is the hardware can't ever be a big product for Apple, other than opening the door to getting a piece of subscription revenues for streaming content.
The only thing left holding back AppleTV, Xbox, Roku, Fire, Google, et al, is access to live and current tv content. Apple hasn't been able to crack the code to get live TV channels yet, but neither has most anyone else. The real problem is the cable business model, and it needs to fracture a little more before it breaks entirely and all the set top boxes get access to all the content.
- analogmemory 10y agoExactly, the cable industry isn't going to let go of their precious. I've had most of the tv "internet boxes" (Roku, Xbox, AppleTV, now Google via Shield) I still can't get live tv. Most of the TV apps require a cable login. The best I can get is youtube streams that is cast to the google box. But it's sub-optimal as it's prickly to find the content i want.
- bogomipz 10y ago>"Most of the TV apps require a cable login." This is reason I will never buy an Apple TV device again. There are regular "updates" to Apple TV. Those updates entail putting new crapware on the home screen which when you launch them want your Cable TV login. Why if I had cable TV would I use the Apple TV to access content I already have on Cable TV without the Apple TV?
- wil421 10y ago>Why if I had cable TV would I use the Apple TV to access content I already have on Cable TV without the Apple TV? Maybe you don't want to pay the monthly fee for another cable box. Maybe you're on vacation and brought your Apple TV. Or maybe the on demand access sucks (U-verse) and you can get full access to HD shows via AppleTV apps. Once these apps allow a DIRECTV now or SlingTV login I'll never buy cable again.
- analogmemory 10y agoSling TV has apps on every platform...
- djrogers 10y agoIt's hardly Apple's fault that the content providers choose to do business this way - the same cable login is required to use those apps on a Roku or FireTV. As for the updates, the previous generation of AppleTV didn't have an app distribution model, so adding new apps via updates was the only way they could do it. The current one that's been out for the last few years doesn't do this - if you want the CBS or NFL app you go to the app store and download it yourself.
- astral303 10y agoNew Apple TV (4th gen) doesn't automatically add new apps to your home screen anymore! No more crapware on update. IMO the new Apple TV is substantially better/more usable than the old Apple TV. It made me hate my cable box & DVR UI even more. > "Why if I had cable TV would I use the Apple TV to access content I already have on Cable TV without the Apple TV?" Because cable TV UI sucks super hard. Cable TV UI is slow, unresponsive, confusing. Pausing, rewinding sucks. Apple TV has an nice analog scrubber feel to it, which makes it quick to jump around and rewind an episode. Did I mention it's slow, and gets slower the longer the cable box has been on? I can watch non-live HBO on Apple TV and cable TV. Whenever possible, I use the Apple TV. Closed captions render better and more pleasant with ATV. I have an easy way to activate "loudness"/"compression" for nighttime viewing, instead of having to fudge with my amplifier's settings to accomplish the same. I use my cable box because I have to. If I want to watch the "Daily Show" the same night it aired, I have no choice but to use the cable box DVR. And then there's the live TV. Unfortunately, because there is no effective competition in the cable market, and because consumers do not complain loudly about shitty technology (cable box user experience), and because cable companies do not seem to care either, we are stuck in god knows how many more years of terrible cable box UI. Meanwhile, I'll be trying to use my Apple TV whenever I can.
- tcbawo 10y agoI have kids that watch copious amounts of Disney Jr. Their app allows watching the live stream in addition to on-demand content. We were close to going 'headless' with our satellite cable provider, but held back due to Comcast being flaky. This hybrid app model feels like a winning recipe for me. It seems to be only a matter of time before the content providers offer this directly without a bundled cable subscription.
- rajathagasthya 10y ago> The only reason sales declined over the previous model is that it's significantly more expensive. And with no 4K UHD support. That's the one stopping me from buying an Apple TV.
- nunez 10y agobut how many people have a TV that can actually display content at 4k?
- LargeCompanies 10y agoYou can now subscribe to Sling($20 to $50 a month), Direct TV Now($40 to $80 a month) and Playstation Vue to watch live TV over the web or whatever device. Soon Hulu will offer the same too for $40. Apple hasn't offered the same, but all these other services do. Overall none of exciting to me, as I just want and need Internet and watch things thru my TV connected to my Mac Mini (free & oodles of stuff to watch).
- weaksauce 10y agoThe touch sensitive remote in the latest Apple TV is fantastic. Sliding exactly where you want to be in an episode is great and navigating the menus with it is good.
- WorldMaker 10y ago«Apple hasn't been able to crack the code to get live TV channels yet, but neither has most anyone else.» There's two reasons I don't think anyone has cracked live TV. The obvious one is technical: cable companies don't want to give away the keys to that kingdom because they make a ton of money in equipment rental still. (With the change of guard in the FCC, it doesn't look like that will change, now.) But the other problem is more social. Even when the cable companies had a mandated technical solution (CableCard), "no one" used it. There are plenty of reasons given for this, but I think the main one is that "live TV" is probably a red herring. Outside of sports, certain types of "events" like award shows, and maybe news, no one actually seems to want Live TV. We'd all much rather have the option to pause, to rewind, to skip fast forward. Cable companies aren't differentiating themselves on how live their content is, they are competing for who offers the best DVR and/or On Demand platforms. Of course, they'd be doomed to be easily beat by the cable cutters and the smarter software solutions of Netflix, Hulu, et al, if they weren't also gatekeepers to internet access at all on the one side and ancient content contracts on the other side. Which is why, as you point out, the real problem is the cable business model and the fact that we let the cable companies conglomerate into just a few monopolistic megacorporations that own giant vertical slices of content and internet access. Cynicism suggests the cable companies aren't going to fracture or break: they will need to be regulated or destroyed.
- chaostheory 10y ago> Apple hasn't been able to crack the code to get live TV channels yet They haven't really cracked the on-demand channel problem yet either. imo Apple TV is the best platform in terms of technology as a TV set top box but Amazon Fire TV is superior because Amazon cracked the content issue. They even have add-on channels now