5 ms·
We can't afford to maintain the surface roads & bridges we already built, and tunnels are more expensive and require more maintenance by like an order of magnit
by dahart 10y ago
We can't afford to maintain the surface roads & bridges we already built, and tunnels are more expensive and require more maintenance by like an order of magnitude. (I made that up, but I'm pretty sure it's right, to within an order of magnitude... but if tunnels are 1000x more expensive, then I'm wrong).
I can admire someone who has the resources to exclude himself from the traffic problem instead taking action to try and solve the whole problem for everyone. He could do what other billionaires do and buy a helicopter.
Still, the only way that tunnels can "obviously" solve the traffic problem is if they're so cheap that we can easily build more of them than we ever need -- and we can't currently do that with roads, even if we have the space. New York and Boston and other places have some tunnels, and also terrible traffic.
If we really do have the resources to take on an infrastructure project of this magnitude, wouldn't it be worth re-evaluating why we're driving, and reducing that instead? The problem with traffic is the traffic. If there wasn't all the traffic, there wouldn't be congestion, we wouldn't need more roads & tunnels.
The contractor end of a tunnel building project might be a good deal though. Convince enough people it's a good idea, and you've got big business for decades to come.
- noja 10y agoIsn't the problem with traffic (in most places) that people are using the roads at the same time?
- XaspR8d 10y agoYeah, pursuing a culture shift that discourages pointlessly-standardized working hours and encourages remote work when possible might even have a tangible effect on traffic. That said traffic is often one of those unfortunate predator-prey type dynamics, where congestion being reduced often encourages more folks to drive until the system returns to an (unfortunate) equilibrium...
- dahart 10y agoYeah, totally. At least that's one way to look at it. There are multiple right answers. Lowering driving rates helps, flexible work hours helps, increasing public transportation helps. Any of these would diffuse traffic jams, and no there's no one single problem and no one single solution -- unless nobody drove at all. But that's why building tunnels doesn't seem like the best first-line defense. It's expensive, and it's fixed and inflexible, and doesn't reduce demand. It could help, but it could also hurt unless tunnels are less expensive to build & maintain than roads. I was trying to be playfully sarcastic by saying the problem with traffic is traffic. Most larger cities in the US, there's only a traffic congestion problem during rush hour, accidents, and road construction. (The city I live in does enough road construction every year, enough that it's widely considered to be a top contributing factor to traffic congestion.) LA traffic, which is what the article referred to, is worse than that, it's density is getting high enough that traffic congestion lasts all day in some places, rush hour is not just slow but crushing, and accidents can and do routinely prevent tens of thousands of people from working. It does seem like there must be a large economic cost to LA's traffic.
- grey-area 10y agoCars and public transport are vastly different in capacity. A tunnel for cars is obviously a crazy idea but what if it carried some sort of pods that carried lots of people at once, maybe in a vacuum, at fast speeds?
- mrighele 10y agoWe could even fill those pods with burritos [1] ! (Sorry, couldn't resist) [1] http://idlewords.com/2007/04/the_alameda_weehawken_burrito_tunnel.htm http://idlewords.com/2007/04/the_alameda_weehawken_burrito_t...
- lmm 10y agoYou couldn't make efficient pods while complying with US railroad regulations (the US high speed trains are the heaviest in the world because the laws basically require trains to be armoured. Comparison to the US love of SUVs left as an exercise to the reader). If you can find a way around those regulations that would work, but seems overcomplicated compared to just applying your way around those regulations to ordinary high-speed rail.
- motoboi 10y agoI think you probably made a joke, but this is exactly what Hyperloop is.
- grey-area 10y ago
- RhodesianHunter 10y agoThe whole point is that he's working towards making tunneling cheaper. If he builds a cheaper tunneling machine, and a cheaper to operate tunnel via hyperloop, then what exactly are you complaining about?
- XorNot 10y agoThe US can easily afford to maintain it's infrastructure. It would make money in doing so. Expense is not the reason the US has infrastructure problems.
- TulliusCicero 10y agoYes and no. The US is rich enough to where, yes, we could raise taxes and fund infrastructure better. At the same time, some forms of infrastructure have been over-built. We've demonstrated a massive preference for (wide) roads over walking/biking/transit, and it turns out supporting mostly single-occupancy vehicles as the default transportation mode is extremely expensive. For example, take this blog post analyzing why a poor area of town is a better revenue generator than a more affluent area; part of the reason is that the older, poorer area just has narrower roads, which reduced upkeep costs: https://www.strongtowns.org/journal/2017/1/10/poor-neighborhoods-make-the-best-investment https://www.strongtowns.org/journal/2017/1/10/poor-neighborh... It should go without saying, but having low-density design throughout our country drastically raises infrastructure costs. The roads needs to be longer (and wider), you need more miles of pipes, and electric wire, and fiber, etc.
- markdown 10y ago> The US is rich enough to where, yes, we could raise taxes and fund infrastructure better. It isn't necessary to raise taxes; reducing military spending would more than suffice.
- dahart 10y agoIf that's true, what is the reason? Is it because roads are public spending and not private development? I guess I do have to clarify that saying we can or can't afford it is overloaded. We may have the money to do it and still not be able to afford it for a variety of reasons including politics and higher priorities. I think it's fair to say we can't afford it when we have debt and we're not fixing the problem. All the money we have is currently going to other things. So how do we make money fixing it? If we would make money, why are we falling behind rather than getting ahead, if it was such a clear win economically, why aren't we doing it already? This article implies that our current annual rate of return on highways is less than 10%: https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2016/11/15/business/dealbook/dealbook-infrastructure.html https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2016/11/15/business/deal... FWIW, I also think it's fairly easy to look at the actual scale of existing infrastructure and come to the conclusion that the magnitude of the problem isn't something that billions or a trillion dollars will put a real dent in; it looks bigger than that to me just looking at these maps: https://www.washingtonpost.com/graphics/national/maps-of-american-infrastrucure/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/graphics/national/maps-of-ame...
- mrfusion 10y agoI wonder if maintenance would be cheaper. Think about it. A constant temperature. No rain or sun. No freeze thaw cycle. No salt. Those are all things that damage roads.
- jartelt 10y agoPerhaps, but in a tunnel you have to deal with preventing water leaks and pumping out ground water, maintaining ventilation systems, lighting, etc. Plus fixing things like potholes will be more costly in a tunnel.
- mabbo 10y agoDepends what you use tunnels for. Subway systems encourage density in cities. In a plane, you can see the Toronto subway lines based on the density around the stations. But new subways tunnels are the big expense that blocks more of then being built. (Though I've heard station construction also is a big cost). Dense areas lead to more walkers, less drivers, cheaper overall infrastructure. It's not about having more infrastructure to maintain, it's about replacing the expensive stuff we have with efficient infra instead.
- erikpukinskis 10y agoHave you looked at a map of Boston? How could you not have horrible traffic?