3 ms·
I hope that the network vendors and the IoT vendors sit down and think about how the devices and the network can work to mitigate things like large-scale IoT DD
by neom 10y ago
I hope that the network vendors and the IoT vendors sit down and think about how the devices and the network can work to mitigate things like large-scale IoT DDoS etc. Even if this mean new protocoling or whatever. I'm not sure I'm thinking about this exactly correctly, but I feel there is something in there?
- johnchristopher 10y agoFWIW, in my country the historical ISP is pushing for a dedicated network for industrial and hobbyists connected devices. The pipes are already wired.
- yorwba 10y agoCan you give more information? From your description, it sounds like "Let's limit possible DDOS targets for hacked things to just factories.", which doesn't strike me as a solution.
- goda90 10y agoPlus it leads to too much trust. One factory doesn't have good air gap policies and suddenly the whole network is infected because some designers trusted the network too much.
- neom 10y agoI recently did a small talk to some fortune CTOs who have sizable physical operations and logistics. Their heads exploded when I asked what the plan was for the 150,000 little computers they just placed on their LAN DDoSing the operational systems.
- kogepathic 10y ago> who have sizable physical operations and logistics As an outsider, I find that quite a strange reaction. I mean, when I ship something with DHL, Fedex, or UPS, they're able to give me (I assume) quite accurate tracking information. So clearly they already have a bunch of sensors in their sorting facility and trucks to monitor when a package has arrived/departed. From what I've heard of Amazon logistics centres, it seems that they would already have thousands of sensors there to scan, transport, label, etc items in the warehouse. But I do work with electricity utilities, where technologies like FTP and ModbusTCP are still considered cutting edge...
- neom 10y agoYeah, for sure not at that scale!!! I wish I was talking to their CTOs ;) Think 10-20MM a year in operating costs (small feet of trucks, few large facilities) - you're on the right track when you mentioned utilities. Even a business like $TWNK will likely have to think about this if they have not already. :)
- zanny 10y agoIoT vendors don't think, which is why the crap they sell is vulnerable to so much exploitation. Network operators should know better than to put cell radios into devices you know will be compromised in a year or two. Hell, the solution sounds pretty simple to me. Network attached devices must be openly disclosed with open source hardware and must have standardized wired update and control mechanisms. That way consumers can make intelligent decisions to buy products that can see long term support by their communities, because companies absolutely won't do it (and because they are international, you cannot really bind them to support terms of contracts - these negotiations have to happen at the import level, and nothing really stops them from dropping products a year down the road from support and bribing the right people / dissolving and reforming the company to circumvent consequences - but you can force them to disclose source and hardware architecture, enabling the consumers to maintain security themselves).
- yaantc 10y agoCellular IoT doesn't really have the problem seen with Mirai & co DDoS attacks. A cellular device is attached to a cellular network first, and for many application are not even on the Internet. In 3GPP cellular IoT (2G/GPRS, 3G/UMTS to HSPA, 4G/LTE) it is very common for devices to be on what's called a private APN. It's a private IP network, and the cellular operator provides a VPN access to this private network to let the managing company access the devices from their application servers. Only the application servers can access the devices, which are not on the Internet. In practice this removes the risk of remote attacks on the devices (if you either hacked the telco or service operators and can get to the devices, you already could get to more interesting stuff like aggregated data). This has been available since GPRS and will also apply to 5G --- no difference at this level. Of course the flip side of this model is that the end customer must go through the device associated service provider to get to the device. It may not be acceptable to all, but when it is using a private APN is really a very effective way to kill remote attacks on cellular IoT devices. Even for devices not using a private APN but having Internet access, the operator is still in between and could do ad-hoc filtering if called for. Another factor is that tier 1 telco operator tend to require support for FOTA (Firmware update Over The Air), so cellular IoT devices can be remotely upgraded. With all this cellular IoT is in a much better situation for security than LAN-based IoT. It's also more expansive.
- neom 10y agoThat was my point, in a massive IoT deployment devices are maybe safer when they stay off LAN.