2 ms·
> That is not how it works It depends on what you're trying to achieve. That time is a poor metaphor for distributable currency? It still leaves healthcare an
by Chris2048 10y ago
> That is not how it works
It depends on what you're trying to achieve. That time is a poor metaphor for distributable currency?
It still leaves healthcare and QoL as issues.
- mikeash 10y agoWho said anything about time as a metaphor for currency? Health care and quality of life disparities still won't get you anywhere near the level of inequality seen with money.
- Chris2048 10y ago> Who said anything about time as a metaphor for currency? I did. You talk about distribution of time, then definite as an un-distributable thing. What has mortality got to do with wealth inequality, if it isn't a metaphor?
- mikeash 10y agoTwo different meanings of "distribution." Think "probability distribution," not "transfer." A metaphor is when you literally talk about one thing, but are actually referring to something else. I'm not doing that here. When I talk about time, I'm actually talking about time. I'm comparing it to money, not using it as a metaphor for money. As for what they have to do with each other, it's simple: The usual way to allocate scarce goods is to use supply and demand to set an equilibrium price, and then let people spend money in order to obtain it. Another way to allocate scarce goods is to require people to spend time in order to obtain it. People tend to consider the first way to be unfair, especially for goods with high emotional value, and whose cost to produce is not connected to the price. People tend to consider the second way to be more fair, because time is more equally distributed among humans. The first paragraph is fact. The second paragraph is observation and speculation. No metaphors in sight.
- Chris2048 10y agoA metaphor according to dictionary : "A figure of speech in which a word or phrase is applied to an object or action to which it is not literally applicable.". If you don't consider time to be transferable, talking of it in terms of a currency is exactly this. > People tend to consider the first way to be unfair Time and money are linked, so I see both ways as the same. I disagree with the above, some people thing this, but I have no idea what %.
- mikeash 10y agoI'm not talking about time in terms of a currency.... All I'm saying is: requiring people to give up time to obtain a scarce good tends to be seen as more fair, because time is more equitably available to people than money. I can't understand why you keep thinking I'm somehow using time as a metaphor for money.
- Chris2048 10y ago> I can't understand why you keep thinking I'm somehow using time as a metaphor for money. I said currency. If you exchange one thing for another (or talk abstractly in terms of this), it's a currency. > requiring people to give up time to obtain a scarce good tends to be seen as more fair People too poor to take time off work, or with high-paid careers that leaves them little free time won't have time to spare. People who are wealthy with no associated constraint on their free time (e.g inherited wealth, or retirees), the unemployed and children/students have plenty free time. Why does the latter group deserve tickets more than the former? > time is more equitably available to people than money Time is more 'equally' (but not necessarily more 'fairly') distributed than time, but what does that matter? Daily toe-nail growth is more evenly distributed than money, and maybe more evenly distributed than time too, so should we ditch time in favor of exchanging good for toenails?
- mikeash 10y agoThere's no exchange when you ask people to give up time in order to obtain something. That time is just lost. If it was a currency, then the people selling the goods would receive the time you spent. Your toenail hypothetical, and much of the rest of your comment, entirely misses my point. I'm not saying we should do this or that. I'm merely saying that people find it to be more fair when there's a time requirement. That's not the same thing as "we should require people to spend time."