3 ms·
I'm really not convinced that Linux is successful because of Linus's jerk-ness. I think it's successful because the BSDs were under a cloud of legal suspicion
by geofft 10y ago
I'm really not convinced that Linux is successful because of Linus's jerk-ness.
I think it's successful because the BSDs were under a cloud of legal suspicion in the early '90s (the USL lawsuits) and Mach didn't have zero-copy message passing, and so as a result, Linux was basically the only free software general-purpose UNIX-alike for 386s that existed. (MINIX resisted being general-purpose until 2005.)
Once you have that, it's basically a matter of network effects.
There are a ton of things Linus did right, of course. There are also a ton of ways he could have destroyed the project, but didn't. All of those are praiseworthy. But we have exactly one data point, and I don't think we can extrapolate a rule from that, certainly not a rule that everything he did was right. If there had been Linux and 386BSD competing on equal terms, who knows what would have happened.
Brilliant jerks are, in fact, often to be found at the beating heart of successful software. That is true. But would that software have a different beating heart if not for them? Would it be more successful?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]