4 ms·
The phrase "virtue signalling" confuses me. What use is the phrase if it follows your definition? Say I say "Thing X is good" or "Thing Y is bad" in a public
by ZeroGravitas 10y ago
The phrase "virtue signalling" confuses me.
What use is the phrase if it follows your definition?
Say I say "Thing X is good" or "Thing Y is bad" in a public forum. How can I avoid that being called virtue signalling?
Am I only allowed to say things that annoy my in-group? Wouldn't this apply to all sorts of things e.g. the speeches of Adolf Hitler or Donald Trump's tweets? Why aren't they accused of virtue signalling?
- derefr 10y ago"Virtue signalling" is mostly used to describe rhetorical devices that serve no other purpose than to give positive strokes to your in-group (which also usually serves to identify yourself as part of that in-group—at least in their minds), so that said in-group will be more willing to side with any actual arguments you make in the same debate, regardless of those arguments' objective merit. Political speeches, and specifically political debates are indeed full of virtue signalling. The only reason it doesn't come up is that 1. it's not a term nearly anyone is familiar with; and 2. it's so universal in politics that accusing someone of it would be like accusing a bird of laying eggs. You can't find a politician who doesn't use virtue signalling (or any of a host of other rhetorical devices), so why bother calling out the 100% who do? It's pointed out more often outside of politics, where effectively it's a way of saying "this person is playing dirty with the audience's emotions, like a politician." "Virtue signalling" as a debate tactic is effectively a kind of "applause light" (http://lesswrong.com/lw/jb/applause_lights/ http://lesswrong.com/lw/jb/applause_lights/), which I find a more useful general term for the kind of problematic rhetorical effect it has. "Virtue signalling" outside of debates is isn't really a thing people care much about, though; everyone does it all the time and nobody pays it any mind (unless you're an anthropologist trying to break down why a given seemingly-useless verbal exchange occurs frequently in a culture.)
- Mikeb85 10y agoVirtue signalling is showing (signalling) that you have a certain opinion for the sole purpose of appearing virtuous. For example, all of the people suddenly support for illegal immigration because Donald Trump is against it, even though every 'progressive' country in the world deports illegal immigrants. Or the "Women's March", which was basically an anti-Trump protest, and had nothing to do with women's rights (if it did, it wouldn't have used a hijab as a symbol of women's rights, as women in Islamic countries generally protest the use of the hijab as a tool of oppression).
- ZeroGravitas 10y agoSo the people who disagree with you, don't really disagree with you, they just pretend to disagree with you, because all of their peer group disagree with you? There appears to be a logical hole here.
- verylittlemeat 10y agoI'm not the OP but I'm curious what do you see as the logical hole? There is social value in disagreeing with someone who claims to have the objective truth. It's not so much about being right as it's claiming to have the truth which socially, emotionally and culturally is related to power. If you don't want a person to have power it doesn't matter if they're right or not. All that matters is the fact that having the truth means having power.
- tropo 10y agoThere is no logical hole. That is exactly what happens. People do pretend to disagree.