10 ms·
Magic Leap: When Reality Hits the Fan
- coldcode 10y ago"Error establishing a database connection" - also reality I guess.
- serg_chernata 10y agoGoogle cache version as the blog seems to be up and down. http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:oh3mPHO2NwQJ:www.kguttag.com/2016/12/06/magic-leap-when-reality-hits-the-fan/+&cd=1&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=us http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:oh3mPHO...
- asymmetric 10y agoarchive.is copy, if you don't want to hit google: https://archive.is/DONtE https://archive.is/DONtE
- nissimk 10y agoThis generation of AR is going to be like the last generation of VR -- a cool gimmick with great promise of things to come, but not really advanced enough to deliver on that promise. Even the virtualboy was pretty cool at the time, but it took 20 years to get to occulus. If someone can make these things work like they do in the movies then everybody will get one, but the technology doesn't seem to be there yet. I don't understand most of the words in this article, but it sounds like even if the computation equipment is powerful enough to render these images that the hardware to transmit them to the viewer has a lot of limitations. I used the HoloLens at a demo and it was amazing, but after 3 demos of 5 minutes each over the course of 30 minutes, my eyes felt tired for the next hour. And the limited field of view did detract from the experience. I've been wanting a heads up display in my glasses for years ever since the first "wearable computing" wave. Eventually it will happen, but all the hardware breakthroughs are so much slower than software.
- pvg 10y agovirtualboy was pretty cool at the time The Virtualboy was objectively, empirically utterly uncool the second it came out. There are multiple peer-reviewed papers on this. The µVb was a widely used unit for uncoolness for a while at the time.
- M_Grey 10y agoDo you have any idea how that turkey made it through multiple levels of management to eventually reach the market? You seem knowledgeable in this arena.
- slantyyz 10y agoWasn't the Virtual Boy created by Gumpei Yokoi, the guy who basically created the Game Boy? Maybe it got through based on his reputation alone? I recall reading (unconfirmed) stories in the gaming press that after the Virtual Boy failed, Yokoi was basically relegated to an office where he basically did nothing.
- leoc 10y agoApparently https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Virtual_Boy&oldid=765361493#Development https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Virtual_Boy&oldid... Yokoi didn't really choose to ship the product that actually came out: like many another long-drawn-out, ambitious project Virtual Boy ended up being basically thrown out the door as-was once senior management lost patience with it.
- ashark 10y agoThey looked back at what the Vectrex 3D Imager had done a decade earlier and thought, "the technology has advanced; this time it's different!" ?
- slantyyz 10y agoI dunno. I believe a lot of kids at the time did think the Virtual Boy was cool (less so for adults), but the timing of its release was also unfortunate. People were getting their first taste of the 3D rendering capabilities of the Playstation and Saturn around that time. Given a choice between asking their parents to spend their hard earned money on what was basically a new monochrome vector based, single player VirtualBoy and the new, flashy 32-bit systems that supported multiplayer, it's pretty clear which systems were going to win. Add the fact that Nintendo fans were also saving up their money for the Nintendo 64, and the Virtual Boy all of a sudden becomes a very hard sell.
- erikpukinskis 10y agoMagic Leap seems like it's on the trajectory to be a patent holding company in an emerging market.
- AstralStorm 10y agoUnfortunately for them, other big players already have similar related patents.
- nxmehta 10y agoAnd "patent holding company" is not what their investors spent over a billion dollars on.
- sebringj 10y agoI was one of the people dooped into believing this was going to happen because I assumed a huge investment from Google meant something and they were so secretive because it was that good, like Steve Jobs was so secretive. At least we can look at tangible VR at this point but those sales are lagging as well. Overall, I'm bummed out but I still hold onto the hope we'll have 3d holograms coming out of phones or contact lenses that overlay huge arrows on the road for driving directions.
- ghaff 10y agoYou have to squint pretty hard to see VR today as any sort of success. It's mostly the province of a gamer niche that's willing to overlook shortcomings, some of which will be inherently hard to overcome, and general lack of content.
- zardo 10y agoHow is that not a success? They have hundreds of thousands of units out, developers of all sizes working on content, and an enthusiastic (and paying) community of users. That's a pretty good launch for a new consumer tech category.
- lokedhs 10y agoDo you remember the enthusiasm just 6 months to a year ago? Did you see how media was was proclaiming that VR was the next big thing, and I even recall that line repeated on the Motley Fool podcast. Then the devices came out, and you hear nothing anymore. Sure, there are a bunch of people who bought it, but when none of the vendors are even releasing sales figures, you know it's disappointing. With the recent news that Oculus is closing their demo stations because no one is using them suggests that things aren't going too well. VR is probably not as bad as 3D TV in terms of a flop, but I don't think anyone can call it a "success" unless your expectations are very different from that of most people.
- ghaff 10y ago
- SirensOfTitan 10y agoThe Economist published a decent look into the tech of augmented reality a couple weeks ago. They asserted two main ideas, both of which I agree with. AR will: 1. Not achieve a form factor acceptable to the general consumer for a while. 2. Be more immediately useful to companies looking to improve worker productivity (like on assembly lines), where form factor is a lesser concern. As a consequence of (1), we will probably start seeing more robust applications of AR tech using the smart phone and camera (like Pokemon GO and Snapchat filters) before we see any reasonable hardware device.
- abakker 10y agoI completely agree with point 2, and see it validated in what CTO/CIO types are paying attention to. I will further that by saying that there are tangible benefits in commercial cases that are better than the ones in the consumer space. Consumers have TVs, consoles, and computers. Businesses are looking now for transformative tech to replace systems that are much older and more outdated. For the enterprise case, AR capabilities on the phone are a great and cheap place to start in order to get a HUD view around them. Kludgy solutions like reading QR codes also work fine for their expected use cases - i.e. reading machine states, maintenance records, etc. These solutions solve a mobile interface problem that helps align information retrieval with the context of being out the field looking at a physical object. My personal favorite AR application would be drone operation, though. AR goggle can do two things. They can assist the Remote pilot in command in maintaining a computer aided visual line of sight to the drone. (circling it in red, in your field of view, for example). It also can provide a HUD of the drone's status (battery, altitude, attitude, settings, perceived wind speed, etc.), and finally it can allow you to view an overlay of FPV from the drone to aid in your both maintaining direct LOS to meet Part 107 requirements, and also to ensure that the pilot can be inspecting, aiming, orienting and piloting the drone successfully by relying of FPV input. Those capabilities don't quite exist yet, but I wouldn't doubt that it will be my first AR use case.
- edblarney 10y agoThough industrial applications 'seem' like a natural choice, it's a really tough market. Mostly because the numbers just are not there. Specific industries will want specific versions, specific apps - and without the scale ... it's hard to make money. And although it may 'seem' rational to want to production line workers into a HUD ... the actual, tangible and measurably improvement in productivity may not be that much. Today, if workers need 'data on the fly' they can ref their tablet or mobile. Does a HUD really make such a huge difference that it's worth the cost? That's a real question. So - I think you're right, essentially about the application opportunities, but the business case is really hard for that. The numbers just don't work out very well.
- aroman 10y agoShould have a "2016" appended to the title, as this is from December of 2016.
- asimpletune 10y agoI really don't understand a lot of the terms in the article, but one thing that I always found very attractive about magic leap is the amount of people they have staffed that are "story tellers" - professional movie types. I can imagine that magic leap will be the next Pixar. They would combine technology that they develop in house with content also made in house. No one knows why google gave them so much money. Maybe this half of the equation, which you can't really ascertain from patents and technical sources, is what is missing for people to crack the code.
- devons 10y agoGoogle (and others) gave them so much money because ML is aiming to build a platform that is not only the thing after smartphones, it's the thing after the Web: spatialized information seamlessly interleaved with reality, everywhere. At that time (>2 years ago), Magic Leap seemed to have achieved the holy grail of Mixed Reality: optics that selectively block out light in real-time. Combined with demos, mockups, and sketches of real-world applications, this tech provided compelling evidence that ML was going to unlock true Mixed Reality real soon. As erikpukinskis commented, even if Magic Leap fails to deliver, it will likely end up with an extremely valuable IP in an emerging space. Magic Leap did not invent Mixed Reality, but they filed patents on many first-order applications of the tech (there are countless others).
- cududa 10y agoJust a quick note, not to debate the whole premise of this post or it's parent - but I don't believe Magic Leap (or anyone else) has developed the ability to selectively block out light. The most I've seen done in this space is using very very bulky electrochromatic glass of which the 'pixels' are ~32x the size of actual pixels on the AR display, and have extremely "fuzzy" borders
- mhermher 10y agoThey hired those story tellers to make attracine promo videos basically. Using traditional animation technology. They seem entirely "aspirational".
- man5quid 10y agoWe hugged it a bit hard, anyone got a link to text?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- adam12 10y agoIf you are getting the database error: http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:oh3mPHO2NwQJ:www.kguttag.com/2016/12/06/magic-leap-when-reality-hits-the-fan/&num=1&hl=en&gl=us&strip=1&vwsrc=0 http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:oh3mPHO...
- Dangeranger 10y agoLooks like the site is getting so much traffic that it's no longer available. Here is an alternative cached view: http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:http://www.kguttag.com/2016/12/06/magic-leap-when-reality-hits-the-fan/ http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:http://...
- grmarcil 10y agoArchive.org link while site is down: http://web.archive.org/web/20161221172829/http://www.kguttag.com/2016/12/06/magic-leap-when-reality-hits-the-fan/ http://web.archive.org/web/20161221172829/http://www.kguttag...
- jsgo 10y ago(removed due to wrong company, thanks josephpmay)
- josephpmay 10y agoYou're confusing Magic Leap with Leap Motion. Two totally different companies
- jsgo 10y agoyou're right, my bad.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- rm_dash_rf 10y agoThe microsoft hololens is a great piece of tech. Works great, no cords. Its development only though. It's cool that I can tinker with it, but at the end of the day I cannot sell a product with it.
- kguttag 10y agoSorry Guys, there was a problem with the website running on my host. I think it has been fixed
- bobsil1 10y agoUse free Cloudflare caching maybe?
- theoh 10y agoThe article references a weird quote from Fortune: "Abovitz says that Magic Leap's "light-field" technology essentially mimics the brain's visual-perception mechanisms to create objects and even people who look and behave just the way they would in the real world, and interact with that world seamlessly." If Magic Leap's use of the term light-field is anything like its meaning in the literature, and it does sound like it, from one other source that I googled, then it is very much not to do with "the brain's [...] mechanisms", it's a totally geometric/optical concept that any optically equipped device/creature could enjoy. It could be tailored for the typically horizontal human eye arrangement, like some previous autostereo displays have been. That is an anatomical/geometrical shortcut, though. If there's real neuroscience-style brain science here I'd be interested to hear more about it.