3 ms·
> I feel the true meaning of a discussion has been lost. It has warped from "lets share our opinions to achieve a greater understanding" to "Let me show you how
by xg15 10y ago
> I feel the true meaning of a discussion has been lost. It has warped from "lets share our opinions to achieve a greater understanding" to "Let me show you how I'm right and try to dismiss all your opinions in every way possible".
Given that "rhetoric" was already a subject of study in ancient rome (and its politicians were skilled in using persuasion and propaganda to manipulate public opinion), I'm not sure there was ever a time where discussion was solely about sharing opinions and archieving a greater understanding.
But it's of course important to keep the ideal of discussion in mind and not go too far down the dark side.
- AlexB138 10y agoInteresting point. Rhetoricians and sophists appeared in ancient Greece, becoming popular along with the rise of Democracy. It's believed this is because the ability to argue convincingly lead to sway over the Demos, the people, and therefore the ability to influence law. Put another way, these people were politicians. They argued professionally, and were trained to do so, or made their living training others to do so. I don't think their existence can be used to inform how every day people had conversations at the time. More interestingly, maybe the problem is that everyone now thinks they're an amateur politician.