2 ms·
I can't speak for the original commentor, but I'd be inclined to take the last interpretation there. My objection isn't about gun rights at all, but the way in
by geofft 10y ago
I can't speak for the original commentor, but I'd be inclined to take the last interpretation there. My objection isn't about gun rights at all, but the way in which he argues for gun rights as if you're not worth paying attention to if you disagree.
See the reductio linked at the bottom: http://www.catb.org/~esr/guns/reductio.html http://www.catb.org/~esr/guns/reductio.html
I could try to explain why that's wrong as an argument, and I'm sure you could too (the difference between banning guns in a home and banning them in a state, the existence of armed law enforcement, etc. etc.), but that's hardly the point. The point is that if you don't agree with the reductio, you are apparently "intelligence-impaired" and should "give up on public policy". There's no room for intelligent people who disagree.
And he does the exact same thing in technical contexts, which should be completely unsurprising. See http://esr.ibiblio.org/?p=7294 http://esr.ibiblio.org/?p=7294 on the specific topic of an implementation language for NTPsec:
"And the core docs don’t presently offer me anything like the survey of options you just laid out.
"I trust you understand why this is a problem without my having to spell it out."
There are good reasons why the Rust team specifically and consciously doesn't include this information in the core docs, but tries to make sure that it's extremely easily discoverable. I'm happy to debate the merits of standard libraries vs. well-trusted third party libraries with people who are interested in debating that. But, apparently, there's no room for intelligent people who disagree with his opinion here, either.
This is poisoning the well. This is not simply arguing a technical point forcefully, but arguing that anyone who disagrees with the technical point is not worth arguing with. This kills projects and communities. I've worked with maybe two or three people who think this way, and it's still too many to want to work with another.
- philh 10y agoI have no particular reply to this, but I would like to say: yes, this is the kind of comment that I was trying to push towards. Thank you.