4 ms·
People have made fun of Christianity and religions, but now we can't make fun of Islam. I mean, people draw Jesus all the time, but they can't draw the prophet
by kiba 17y ago
People have made fun of Christianity and religions, but now we can't make fun of Islam. I mean, people draw Jesus all the time, but they can't draw the prophet Mommahad.
It is like parents shreking in horror because Harry Potter promotes witchcraft. No matter what religions you have, intolerance should not be allowed.
After all, free speech isn't about what speech you like or what I like, but what people hate. Someday, you're going to be on the opposite side.
- lutorm 17y agoYou can be in favor of free speech and still be in favor of not exercising that right just to offend others.
- mike_organon 17y agoIn this case, we need to offend people in order to protect free speech.
- natch 17y agoMaybe they are not doing it "just" to offend. Maybe there are other goals, like fighting against the ever-increasing curtailments on freedom of speech.
- kiba 17y agoI am in favor of no special treatment for Muslims or anyone else just because they are offended, or some members of their group murder someone. I mean, all we have to do is draw a very important prophet, for god sake! We don't even have Mommahad do bad things them for them to get offended. Someone will get offended. Somebody will say politically incorrect things. I don't like other people to act like children when Christians endure religious satire and people saying all Christians are hypocrite or something horrible, daily. You don't see Christians going around murdering political cartoonists for offending them do you?
- ErrantX 17y agoI mean, all we have to do is draw a very important prophet, for god sake! That's a little intolerant; you might not understand why they feel that way (I certainly don't) but it doesn't allow you to sneer at such things. Sure, that is all we need to do. Does that mean we should make a point of doing it? Walking around nude in front of visitors you your home is, clearly, going to offend some people. That is something I don't really understand because it is just bits, and we all have em! But would you deliberately take your clothes off when you had visitors? As opposed to accidentally opening the door naked to someone? There is a difference I think.
- lutorm 16y agoYou don't see Christians going around murdering political cartoonists for offending them do you? Relevance? I'm sure the ones who are ready to kill people for drawing Muhammad will be so impressed by your principled defense of free speech that they will see the error of their ways... Seriously, the only thing this will accomplish is to convince those that would NOT murder you but still consider what you are doing extremely rude that you care not one whit about what they think is important. In case you didn't reflect on what you just posted, you are exactly advocating special treatment for Muslims just because they were offended.
- tptacek 17y agoDrawing Jesus, even in cartoon form, doesn't violate a fundamental tenet of the faith. Nowhere in the Catholic catechism (for example) are illustrations of Jesus proscribed. I'm 110% with 'potatolicious on this. The people saying we shouldn't have to go out of our way to avoid offending Muslims are, of course, right. But there's no cause to go out of our way to offend Muslims, either. If I was a Islamist culture-warrior, things like "Draw Muhammad Day" would be a coup for me; it might even have been the reason why I'd threaten the lives of cartoonists. To provoke a counterproductive response from the west.
- flogic 17y agoThis response isn't counter productive. Immature and childish yes. Counter productive no. It helps to point out the importance of free speech.
- tptacek 17y agoSo does dressing up in white robes and goofy hats and marching with racial epithets on signs. The ACLU --- one of the few causes I actually donate too, despite them being unbelieveably annoying once you do --- made quite a bit deal of that. But the people doing the marching? Total counterproductive douchebags. We tolerated them. We didn't encourage them.
- flogic 16y agoI don't think EDMD is congruent with a Klan march. I think a number of people consider the primary reason for EDMD to be free speech where as the primary reason for Klan marches is racism. Also you don't get to change things like the color of your skin or sexual preference where as beliefs can change. In my opinion that makes religion fair game.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]