3 ms·
This is the exact same issue PGP and other secure communicators face: noone will use them if they're INCONVENIENT. At this point Signal is just a worse version
by izacus 10y ago
This is the exact same issue PGP and other secure communicators face: noone will use them if they're INCONVENIENT. At this point Signal is just a worse version of proprietary WhatsApp and a significantly worse version of iMessage. It doesn't offer anything better or anything new. SMS might be insecure, but its integration offers convenience which makes for a great stepping stone to making Signal widely used and available.
If we actually take a moment to heed what history taught us is: noone gives a damn about security. It's a nice tick on the feature list, but it's a low-priority tick. It'll always be trumped by convenience and networking effets. Without understanding that, Signal is on its way to the garbage dump of history together with PGP, XMPP and countless other secure protocols.
SMS integration is a great trojan horse to make people use it - just replace the existing messenger and you can message to people via your computer! As the userbase grows, Signal switches to secure communication anyway until you can finall y drop the SMS support. But without that user growth, it's exactly what I wrote above - a shitty version of iMessage and WhatsApp.
- NoGravitas 10y agoBut except for the shitty MMS support (MMS groups never seem to work for me), Signal's SMS support seems just fine.
- Markoff 10y agoUI is quite horrible, good luck forwarding whole conversation to someone else, you need to select all messages one by one good luck sending more photos at once, you can send photos only one by one these basic case scenarios really make it look like it's made by some teenager