5 ms·
I think this whole thing is stupid. Don't get me wrong - I think we should have the freedom to draw whatever the hell we want and be free from threats of deadl
by potatolicious 17y ago
I think this whole thing is stupid.
Don't get me wrong - I think we should have the freedom to draw whatever the hell we want and be free from threats of deadly force. I think all the people who threatened physical harm to the original cartoonist are despicable, but this way of going about it is frankly extremely damaging.
Note: I am not Muslim, I am an atheist, and I want to apologize on behalf of atheists who have unfortunately chosen to participant in this disgusting farce. They do not speak for all of us. But, moving along...
Most Muslims are against violent reprisal. Are they offended? Yes, but like every other controversial issue in the world, only the extremists would go to the end of harming someone. The internet community that has fueled the popularity of EDMD is ignorant of this, and their numbers are muddied by the many racists and bigots also in participation for the wrong reasons. It's like if the KKK showed up at your political protest - there goes your credibility. As organizers of a principled stand for your rights, you need to make sure that your group cannot be conflated with racists, bigots, and other nasty people. The community around EDMD has done an extremely poor job at it (IMHO mostly because a lot of the core people spreading this around are themselves racist).
It is, frankly, juvenile, especially once you read some of the discussion by people who actually are participating in this.
Imagine if a group of atheists firebombed a church for making fun of atheism, and the Christians' response is instituting a "mock atheism day". Does this solve any problems? Does it create more understanding? Does this help improve the view, from either side, that most people are actually reasonable, sane people?
No, it simply promotes more polarizing viewpoints, more extremism, and eventually more violence from both sides. It is counterproductive and I'm embarrassed that so many atheists, who like to proclaim themselves freethinkers, have gotten on this bandwagon.
This isn't a principled stand in response to extremist action - this is an indiscriminate melee of offensive content that is not targeted at the groups and people actually responsible for making threats against people's lives for their expression. Speaking to my Muslim friends, they are as appalled by the violence of extremists as we are - the correct course of action is to work with moderate and liberal Muslims to combat the actions of extremists, not to alienate and offend the allies we need most.
- orblivion 17y agoSo what if they stuck to, say, "respectable" images of Mohammad? Something that says, "I'm sorry if this offends you, but I fear for my freedom of speech". Doing the same thing but making it clear that it's in self-defense, and that any offense taken is a side-effect?
- kareemm 17y ago~1.6B people consider drawing Mohammed to be a blasphemous action. That's not self-defense; that's antagonistic.
- sp332 17y agoAll the people drawing Mohammed have had their lives threatened. I'm not in favor of escalation, but I don't think backing down in response to a threat of this kind sets a good precedent. Edit: I mean, if they had been asked nicely I would totally agree with you. But it must be made clear that threats are not an appropriate way to deal with religious issues.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- tome 17y agoAbsolutely. If they'd asked nicely, and had some sort of non-violent, respectful protest I wouldn't feel the need to respond in any way.
- saikat 17y agoThe problem here is that the "escalation" is not against the people threatening lives. It's a blind escalation in the dumbest sense - just making the antagonistic act affect more people instead of the few guilty people more acutely.
- fgf 17y ago
- kiba 17y agoPeople have made fun of Christianity and religions, but now we can't make fun of Islam. I mean, people draw Jesus all the time, but they can't draw the prophet Mommahad. It is like parents shreking in horror because Harry Potter promotes witchcraft. No matter what religions you have, intolerance should not be allowed. After all, free speech isn't about what speech you like or what I like, but what people hate. Someday, you're going to be on the opposite side.
- lutorm 17y agoYou can be in favor of free speech and still be in favor of not exercising that right just to offend others.
- mike_organon 17y agoIn this case, we need to offend people in order to protect free speech.
- natch 17y agoMaybe they are not doing it "just" to offend. Maybe there are other goals, like fighting against the ever-increasing curtailments on freedom of speech.
- kiba 17y agoI am in favor of no special treatment for Muslims or anyone else just because they are offended, or some members of their group murder someone. I mean, all we have to do is draw a very important prophet, for god sake! We don't even have Mommahad do bad things them for them to get offended. Someone will get offended. Somebody will say politically incorrect things. I don't like other people to act like children when Christians endure religious satire and people saying all Christians are hypocrite or something horrible, daily. You don't see Christians going around murdering political cartoonists for offending them do you?
- ErrantX 17y agoI mean, all we have to do is draw a very important prophet, for god sake! That's a little intolerant; you might not understand why they feel that way (I certainly don't) but it doesn't allow you to sneer at such things. Sure, that is all we need to do. Does that mean we should make a point of doing it? Walking around nude in front of visitors you your home is, clearly, going to offend some people. That is something I don't really understand because it is just bits, and we all have em! But would you deliberately take your clothes off when you had visitors? As opposed to accidentally opening the door naked to someone? There is a difference I think.
- kareemm 17y ago+1. Wish I had 10 upvotes to give you.
- kareemm 17y agowow, why the harsh downmodding?
- potatolicious 17y agoI'm not sure in this case - it would seem to me that the community here is basically split 50/50 on this issue, and there does seem to be a lot of emotional modding going on. That being said, generally on HN one-liners that don't really add substantial elements to the discussions are downmodded to oblivion in an attempt to keep this place from degenerating into reddit ;)
- kareemm 17y agoFWIW, the grandparent was a genuine question, i wasn't trying to be a jackass. > That being said, generally on HN one-liners that don't really add substantial elements to the discussions are downmodded to oblivion in an attempt to keep this place from degenerating into reddit ;) ha. fair enough. though the long version of what i meant is "hells yes, thanks for saying this more eloquently than I could've".
- mike_organon 17y agoYou have no business apologizing for anyone else. Muslims that are offended need to get over it. They will if we don't treat them like delicate children.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- mike_organon 17y agoI disagree. If millions of Muslims didn't get offended and expect the civilized world to cave in, there wouldn't be riots and the death threats would be just from "some individuals" rather than Muslims. When adults speak freely, some will get offended. It's actually a certain amount of respect, expecting Muslims to act like rational adults to criticism or silly drawings, rather than hiding our adult words when they are around.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- tome 17y agoI don't think anyone (sensible) is suggesting that it's OK to go out of one's way to offend muslims. The point is that some things are more important than avoiding offending people (particularly, I might add, over something so ridiculous as drawing a picture).
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- tome 17y agoThose ones would fall outside the "sensible" category. I'm not interested in defending random nutters on Facebook, but if you can point me to an example of "suggesting that going out of one's way to offend all Muslim's is a good idea, and that they all deserve it because some Muslims are violent assholes" then I'll be happy to debate it with you.
- anamax 17y ago> It's like if the KKK showed up at your political protest - there goes your credibility. Actually, it depends on what you do when they show up. > Imagine if a group of atheists firebombed a church for making fun of atheism, and the Christians' response is instituting a "mock atheism day". Does this solve any problems? Does it create more understanding? Does this help improve the view, from either side, that most people are actually reasonable, sane people? I'll bite - what was your response when various Christians objected to "Piss Christ"? We're currently saying "we have to avoid anything that might offend Muslims because some of them might go violent". At some point, other groups are going to see if that generalizes. > Speaking to my Muslim friends, they are as appalled by the violence of extremists as we are Good for them. I note that Japanese-Americans turned in the few saboteurs during WWII. Italian-Americans turn on the Mafia. And so on. I hope that Muslims are doing the same.
- potatolicious 17y ago> "what was your response when various Christians objected to "Piss Christ"?" Not sure I was around for that one - but I highly doubt I would've participated in a worldwide public shaming of all Christians, which is really what this thing boils down to. > "We're currently saying "we have to avoid anything that might offend Muslims because some of them might go violent"." No, that's not what we're saying at all. What we're saying is "there's no need to troll and antagonize everyone of a particular belief just because a small minority of them are violent assholes". There's nothing in here that capitulates our freedoms to religious belief - drawing Mohammed is still legal, but for the sake of everyone getting along on this big lonely rock, maybe we shouldn't. Leveraging your freedoms to its maximum extent, even to the grave offense of others, is not protecting it, despite what some people seem to think. Your freedoms do not absolve from good taste and judgment. Let me put this in another way. Your neighbor is deeply offended, by, say lawnmowers. You still have the right to mow your lawn - and it would be unreasonable for him to ask you to ask you to stop mowing your lawn. But instead, you ridicule him for it and invite all the neighbors over to have a big lawn-mowing party. That's the line between exercising your freedom, and simply being a jackass. EDMD, IMHO, falls on the wrong side of this line.
- 17y ago
- zerokyuu 17y agoI completely agree with you, but I just wanted to point out that the idiocy is all over the place (found in the wikipedia discussion): "A prominent Iranian newspaper says it is going to hold a competition for cartoons on the Holocaust to test whether the West will apply the principle of freedom of expression to the Nazi genocide against Jews as it did to the caricatures of the Prophet Muhammad." http://www.nytimes.com/2006/02/07/world/africa/07iht-web.0207toon.iran.html?_r=2 http://www.nytimes.com/2006/02/07/world/africa/07iht-web.020... My point is just that everyone (atheists, christians, muslims, jews) needs stop being immature and realize that trying your best to piss off people with a different opinion is just going to cause polarization and make them think their way of thinking is correct.
- chbarts 17y ago> "A prominent Iranian newspaper says it is going to hold a competition for cartoons on the Holocaust to test whether the West will apply the principle of freedom of expression to the Nazi genocide against Jews as it did to the caricatures of the Prophet Muhammad." Oh, this is the one all those Jews entered, isn't it? The one where all the best (most offensive) entries were made by Jews? Yeah, I heard about that. They could have printed all of those cartoons over here in the Great Satan of America no problem. My point is they're trying to draw parallels where none exist. Jews are offended by David Duke and the Klan but they don't assassinate them. Christians are offended by Dawkins but, to date, none of them have taken potshots at him. How many people have radical Muslims assassinated?
- nooneelse 17y agoAs a member of "the West", let me reply to this Iranian paper's contest with this statement: Don't care, go on, whatever. See that, we aren't hypocritical on this... your turn to stop caring about the Mohammad cartoons. The ball is in your court.
- lutorm 16y agoYou weren't part of the Holocaust, I assume??
- metamemetics 17y agoYou seemed to be confused and to not recognize that religion is intrinsically violent. It is not simply "a few bad apples" scenario nor just about Islam but a systemic problem that had been occurring for thousands of years. Are you aware the punishment for Apostasy in Islam (no longer believing in God) is also death? In order to end violence, people must undergo cognitive dissonance, realize that one belief they hold prescribes death and another belief they hold prescribes that they shouldn't. The resolve this dissonance by permanently discarding the belief that prescribes them to kill, by encountering a situation that shows this belief to be absurd. People will NOT introspect on their deeply held beliefs unless beneficial situations like Everybody Draw Mohammed day occur. edit: 0 --|-- | / \
- potatolicious 17y ago> "Are you aware the punishment for Apostasy in Islam (no longer believing in God) is also death?" Because if it's written in some holy text, it must mean modern practitioners still follow it to the T, right? "Thou shalt not wear a garment of divers sorts, as of woolen and linen together." - Deuteronomy 22:11 It seems disturbing that those who are anti-Islam use the same fucked up interpretations of Quranic texts that the extremists themselves use. Kind of a sick irony I suppose.
- tshtf 17y agoThat treatment of Apostasy is a relatively mainstream interpretation. In Saudi Arabia today, the penalty for conversion to other religions is death: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freedom_of_religion_in_Saudi_Arabia http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freedom_of_religion_in_Saudi_Ar... The problem is that many practitioners do follow texts to a T, and I believe that's the point of most religious systems.
- eagleal 17y agoYeah, but it's like they don't want to lose followers/members. And the only thing they can do about it is just death penalty, like how did the Catholic Church centuries ago. It's important to note that christian descendant and "allies" control the majority of media. Eg. in Albania there is an estimation of 80/20% of Muslims (majority non practitioners)/Christians, while the government administration 80/20% Christians/Muslims. EDIT: I was talking about worldwide majority, not national or regional.
- endtime 17y agoThis didn't start because anyone threatened anyone. This started because an episode of South Park - which showed Buddha snorting cocaine, Moses as Zordon from Power Rangers, etc. - wasn't allowed to show Mohammed. This is a protest against self-censorship, in this case by Comedy Central.
- potatolicious 17y ago> "This didn't start because anyone threatened anyone." I'm under the impression that this started when a cartoonist drew a picture of Mohammed, inspiring violent threats from all over. South Park was simply dogpiling on this (as they do with all other contentious issues) - the notable part of South Park's involvement is that Comedy Central actually moved to self-censor.
- endtime 17y agoWell, yes; similarly, if you trace back far enough it started with the evolution of man. But this particular, recent series of events started with the South Park episode, which wasn't responding to any particular event. Rather, it was their 200th episode and they chose to celebrate it by, as they always have, testing the limits of what they can get on TV.
- bloch 17y agoLet me show you a recent example of what this is about: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pfW95sSaVVo http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pfW95sSaVVo This took place in a swedish university during a lecture about religion and freedom of speech. The video that Lars Vilks showed during this clip was made by an iranian artist. Before this he had showed examples of offensive material directed at christianity etc. And there is a funny kind of double standard involved, because practically nobody objects when artists offend religions where the response to the alleged offence isn't violent. EDIT: A few days after this attack, "somebody" tried to firebomb Vilk's house. All because of a series of rather tame drawings like this one: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Muh-hund-original-rondellliten.JPG http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Muh-hund-original-rondelll... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lars_Vilks http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lars_Vilks
- ErrantX 17y agoThere's no excuse for such idiocy. But comparing it to reactions to offensive material about Christianity is impossible; they just react differently is all. The history and teachings of Islam differ drastically from the way modern Christianity has gone. Defending the faith is still a core part of the Muslim religion - whereas Christian churches have been steadily pushing people away from those ideas. It explains why there is a difference. As to why the individuals do what they do; well that is a personal liability. I suggest that there are those who would do the same if Christianity preached similar teachings in the modern day (indeed, plenty of them did in the past. And look at the Christian extremists - who foster much the same ideas)
- bloch 17y agoWhy is a comparison impossible? The attackers were swedish citizens. This sounds exactly like the excuses and double standards I was refering to: "There is no excuse, but [insert excuse]."
- ErrantX 17y agoDouble standard? I don't understand what you mean. What I am talking about is that the way Christianity and Islam preach you should react to attacks like this are entirely different. Hence the different reactions. So you can't say "why do attacks on Christianity not get the same reaction" - because the answer is obvious. There is no excuse; but there is a reason. :) Here's an example which might help show my point: there is a difference between the way a "religious" Glasgow Rangers football supporter and a Bath Town supporter will react if you call their teams sissies (i.e. the stereotype Glasgow guy would punch you in the face while the Bath guy would ignore you). (EDIT: I realised that is a very UK centric example. Insert any sports team with religious and fervent followers for Glasgow and one with passionate but reserved followers for Bath) EDIT2: if you wish to downvote feel free; but it would be interesting to hear why you disagree (this is based on observation of the two religions so I could be wrong)
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- fgf 17y agoIn this case I believe there is a strength in numbers; if one paper publishes a cartoon they can threaten it's editor if a thousand do they lost; the solidarity inherent in publishing a cartoon today is, to be a bit dramatic, of the "then you'll have to take me too" kind. It will take care of the "moderates" they can't and they won't keep protesting forever. About those willing to use violence. What is the most successfully suppressed group of violent extremists in europe and america? Neo-Nazis. Was this done by appeasement? By appealing to the "moderate" nationalists? You know the answer. To me the right to offend is sacred and to threaten those who (only) offend you is sacrilege. The radicals can and should be dealt with in the same manner as neo-nazis. In norway 80 years ago christians tried to have a professor punished for publishing a text not unlike one of Hitchens in it's style and level of aggression. About 40 years ago Life of Brian was banned. There were protests, and book burnings too.. They lost, not thanks to people like the author of this comment. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pfW95sSaVVo http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pfW95sSaVVo, I imagine this make me feel like some muslim radical does when he watches a Mohammed cartoon
- lhorie 17y agoI definitely agree, this is stupid. The wikipedia page on freedom of speech (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freedom_of_speech http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freedom_of_speech) says this: In practice, the right to freedom of speech is not absolute in any country and the right is commonly subject to limitations, such as on "hate speech". [...] According to the Freedom Forum Organization, legal systems, and society at large, recognize limits on the freedom of speech, particularly when freedom of speech conflicts with other values or rights.[30] Limitations to freedom of speech may follow the "harm principle" or the "offense principle", for example in the case of pornography or "hate speech" And the page on hate speech (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hate_speech http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hate_speech) says this: Hate speech is, outside the law, any communication which disparages a person or a group on the basis of some characteristic such as race or sexual orientation.[1][2] In law, hate speech is any speech, gesture or conduct, writing, or display which is forbidden because it may incite violence or prejudicial action against or by a protected individual or group, or because it disparages or intimidates a protected individual or group. The law may identify a protected individual or a protected group by race, gender, ethnicity, nationality, religion, sexual orientation, or other characteristic. The one thing that bugs me the most is how quickly different aspects of the discussion quickly get muddled into a big mess 1 - You're about as free to draw Mohammed as a protester is free to say "burn the infidels". Heck, when it comes to controversial issues, people make life threats all the time. 2 - If you say something and someone kills you because of it, that's not a free speech violation. It's a criminal offense. They are completely different things. 3 - What a broadcasting corporation elects not to show on their air time doesn't have much to do with what you, as a individual can say, according to the law. If the government told the TV station not to air something, then we have a free speech violation. If the government throws you in jail for saying something, then you have a free speech violation. Did any of the two happen? No. Then, don't even mention free speech. Did you insult your neighbour and subsequently got beaten up? That's 1) your responsibility to not say stupid stuff and 2) criminal law jurisdiction if you do get hurt because you said stupid stuff. (edit: s/you/one).