14 ms·
It’s Easy to Make Enemies of People We Only Read About
- aaron-lebo 10y agodelete: misread article, being a pedant, ignore That Rubio quote is completely nonsensical though. Uh, Marco, the 1960s were worse...
- nerdponx 10y agoI read this the other way around. This behavior of hating people you've never met is nothing new. It's a familiar pattern.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- MrsPeaches 10y agoDid they control for accents and pronunciation? E.g. I thought the guy in the video sounded less likely to be the barer of truth when he mispronounced divisive, compared to when I read the text.
- uxp100 10y agoAn uncommon pronunciation. I believe its the one Obama used though.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- nailer 10y agoI wonder if a large chunk of the audience read this article's position that they should listen to other people, threw away this idea because they couldn't empathise with the author, and didn't watch the video, confirming the research mentioned.
- aaron-lebo 10y agoIt can't really be as simple as reading vs hearing though. People watch videos of political opponents all the time and don't relate to them better afterwards. How does Jon Stewart exist if that's the case? How does Hannity? What's missing?
- nailer 10y agoPolitical pundits generally play small soundbytes of their opposition, then afford themselves a 10 minute rant.
- aaron-lebo 10y agoWould you relate to Trump more if you had to watch him for an hour? Would anyone but supporters?
- arximboldi 10y agoActually I did watch Trump for an hour once and it made me relate to him much more. It did not change my general opinion about him, but it made me understand why people support him.
- aaron-lebo 10y agoHuh. Your point is well made. Kudos for trying to understand someone else.
- elcapitan 10y agoThere are some videos with him from a couple of years before the election (on Letterman), I watched those a week ago and found him quite likeable as well. Even with the background knowledge of the disastrous policy he is now implementing.
- yummyfajitas 10y ago
- fedups 10y ago> In philosophy and rhetoric, the principle of charity requires interpreting a speaker's statements to be rational and, in the case of any argument, considering its best, strongest possible interpretation. [0] Although it seems super rare in internet conversation, a good way to practice is to keep in mind all the ways the Other Team misrepresents My Team and generalize this when the Other Team says something dreadful on the surface. But in the absence of the charity, concise, effective communication becomes all the more crucial. [0]- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Principle_of_charity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Principle_of_charity
- Vaskivo 10y agoI agree. I'd also like to add a new great concept I've learned recently: "steelmanning" https://wiki.lesswrong.com/wiki/Steel_man https://wiki.lesswrong.com/wiki/Steel_man. I feel the true meaning of a discussion has been lost. It has warped from "lets share our opinions to achieve a greater understanding" to "Let me show you how I'm right and try to dismiss all your opinions in every way possible". And, in reality, what happens is "let me say my opinions to the air so the ones who already agree with me agree even more".
- AlexB138 10y ago>I feel the true meaning of a discussion has been lost. It has warped from "lets share our opinions to achieve a greater understanding" to "Let me show you how I'm right and try to dismiss all your opinions in every way possible". What a wonderfully astute observation. Conversations have become a competition where each side feels they need to "win", often at any cost. I grew up on the internet, having first gotten a connection in '93. I remember a time when online conversations were "let's share..." and have watched them transform into their current state. I suspect a lot of the current deteriorated state of in-person conversations came from the deterioration of the online conversation, which agrees with this articles premise. Can any older members comment on whether this was happening so much before the internet was commonly used? >And, in reality, what happens is "let me say my opinions to the air so the ones who already agree with me agree even more". I would add that it's also a lot of virtual signaling[0]. Making statements you know your in-group agrees with in order to increase your social standing. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Virtue_signalling https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Virtue_signalling
- rustynails 10y agoIf you take a step back, there is a lot of hatred generated by much of today's media. I compared it to newspapers from 1970 and the nastiness and the sexism has increased by at least one if not two orders of magnitude. I challenge you to go to your local library or archive and compare for yourself. It's a stark contrast. I compared an entire year's worth of papers, so, I have a good basis to compare. Here are a few examples of things that did not happen in 1970 in the papers I read and there was nothing like it at all, The Verge lead a nasty attack on Matt Taylor for wearing a shirt designed by a woman, http://www.theverge.com/platform/amp/2014/11/13/7213819/your-bcowling-shirt-is-holding-back-progress http://www.theverge.com/platform/amp/2014/11/13/7213819/your... Or, many of the articles about Donald Trump (lunatic is a common term used by some big media outlets, Google it, there are too many links to list). Irrespective of whether you like his policies, the personal attacks (which are even very popular on HN) are unacceptable. To disagree with policy is fine, to personally attack the man is not. Or try the website equalmeansequal.com . It is very extreme in its gender prejudice and had gone without being challenged. For example, read the section about prisons/incarceration. Like Australia, even when police reports demonstrate there are many violent women (25-33% of perpetrators according to US and Australian statistics such as ABS), there is an almost universal denial in the media about domestic violence and female aggressors. Why? Why condone violence? You can't get much worse in breaching ethics and human rights. Why does it persist so universally? The linked article at nautilus.us also defends feminism. The central theme to each of these examples above is ... feminism. Feminism does not equal female (nor equality). I currently work with mostly females (about 95%). I'm anti feminist and not anti female! I strongly disrespect prejudiced movements/ideologies (KKK, neo nazis AND feminism). I also pointed out in another post that Hillary Clinton's exit speech was very sexist (far worse than Matt Taylor's shirt). Why were her segregating words necessary (ie. excluding boys completely in several instances)? Why did every single media outlet ignore this? Feminism. No matter how extreme or nasty, people won't condemn feminism. The absence of protests by almost every single feminist about reporting on domestic violence (or Hillary's sexism) is a clear illustration of the nature of the entire movement. Feminism is absolutely not the only scourge we have to deal with today, however, it's the only scourge that almost no media outlet will tackle. It's like opposing the KKK 100 years ago. Until we truly are willing to hold everyone to the same standard, hate speech will thrive. This hate speech often lives under the banner of political correctness. If I had to point 2 fingers at why the media has deteriorated so much compared to 1970, I'd put it down to feminism and political correctness and a refusal to condemn these selective prejudices. The attacks that we see (above) would rarely (if ever) have happened in the Australian media in 1970. However, today, they are the norm.
- LoonyBalloony 10y agoCan I share a video that (IMO) is relevant? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rE3j_RHkqJc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rE3j_RHkqJc
- dtech 10y agoMore relevant: this is the theory of memes [1], which the author avoids because that word has a very different connotation because of the internet. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Meme https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Meme
- gukov 10y agoHumor is the best way to learn. One side learns about the world by seeing memes, the other side by watching SNL. One thing is grassroots, the other one is paid propaganda.
- kolbe 10y agoAnd as true as that statement is, we aren't even to the point where that bias can take effect. We rarely even read what people say: we read what journalists choose to write about what people say.
- 6stringmerc 10y ago...and people with skills in communication will use Dog Whistle type terminology or purposefully phrase their remarks so that journalists will hopefully pick up their statement and deliver it as intended. Sort of like how time and again I keep hearing "This bill is about the protection of Young Boys and Girls!" regarding the Gender Identity Restroom bill, when statistically speaking, Young Boys or Girls are more at risk from abuse by their close family. Journalists aren't, in theory, supposed to point out the hollow, rather ludicrous assault on intelligence the "Think of the children!" argument is in this regard - that's for the public, you and me, to figure out. Unfortunately, I guess, considering the state of things.
- gukov 10y agoIt's 2017 and people still prefer to look at the world through someone else's lens.
- 6stringmerc 10y agoProbably more a human nature / social hierarchical / evolutionary thing than we'd care to admit. It's a weakness on an individual level, it may seem.
- isleyaardvark 10y ago>Rubio may have had on his mind what happened just a week earlier, at U.C. Berkeley Well, probably not, given what Rubio actually said: http://www.rubio.senate.gov/public/index.cfm/2017/2/senate-floor-speech-rubio-urges-both-parties-to-show-civility http://www.rubio.senate.gov/public/index.cfm/2017/2/senate-f... The context of the speech was regarding the vote to prevent Elizabeth Warren from reading Coretta Scott King's letter opposing Jeff Sessions. >These are the continuing rules of the Senate that have been in existence previous to this time and have carried over into this session, is that correct? >I imagine many people were not excited about the fact that [Hillary Clinton] would be secretary of state, to my recollection, and perhaps I’m incorrect, not a single one of those horrible things that have been written said about her, some of which actually did accuse her of wrongdoing, were ever uttered on the floor of the Senate. I lose track of the ironies here. There's the irony of Rubio lamenting we are "becoming a society incapable of having debate anymore" while in the very process of shutting down debate. There's also the irony of an article with the quote "The less we know about the mind of another, the more we use our own to fill in the blanks", that filled in blanks of Rubio's speech that didn't actually exist.
- dforrestwilson1 10y agoIs it a debate though? It was a dredged up letter from the 1980s, and didn't the initial dredger express regret about doing it?
- isleyaardvark 10y agoYou could call it "dredged up", or you could call it a letter from a civil rights leader vigorously opposing his appointment as a judge that would still have relevance to him being appointed as AG. As for regret, I haven't seen anything about Coretta Scott King changing her opinion, and if you're talking about whoever found that letter and spread it around, I don't see how that would be relevant. I don't know where you're getting this info.
- daleharvey 10y agoNot entirely sure what this article is trying to say, if we heard Milo's accent when he talks about how feminism is cancer that we would believe he is a real human being?
- csallen 10y agoI think this line in the article made its point well: "The less we know about the mind of another, the more we use our own to fill in the blanks." When we form our opinions entirely based on individual quotes taken out of context (at worst) instead of actual back-and-forth conversations (at best), we're not going to have an accurate perception of reality. If we then follow-up by labeling a person as not worth talking to, or not "a real human being", then we're gating ourselves off from even the possibility of improving the accuracy of our perceptions.
- mynameishere 10y agoI don't give a fig about "Milo", but what do you think when a noted feminist declares an entire race the "cancer of human history" [1]? How should people, whether on the left, right, or whatever, view this opinion? Scorn? Rioting? Approval? By denying her humanity? I'm guessing, if you are like most leftists, you would view such remarks with a mix of indifference and agreement. [1] https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Susan_Sontag https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Susan_Sontag
- mirimir 10y agoWell, she did declare that in 1967. It was an understandable reaction to the whole "white man's burden" thing behind colonialism.
- gydfi 10y agoNo, but if you listened to him and understood his world view and listened to the examples of why he thinks that, rather than his provocative headline, you might be able to come to some understanding. Arguing about "feminism" is stupid anyway because "feminism" has become a motte-and-bailey concept.
- guelo 10y agoIt's hard to take this seriously when the two examples are of fringe extreme leftists while mainstream conservative's hate of liberals is the main driving ideology of the party in power right now.
- makomk 10y agoUnfortunately, from what I've seen support for those "fringe extreme leftists" has become an expected norm on a surprisingly wide chunk of social media, and probably a more-or-less mandatory part of leftwing activism. Opposing it marks you out as a neo-Nazi sympathizer or worse in those circles. There was even something of a backlash against the ACLU for taking the other side, though more muted and conciliatory than the treatment less prominent individuals received. In unrelated news, I'm currently looking for better social circles.
- AstralStorm 10y agoThe problem is, even-handed people don't form circles, they form networks.
- kmicklas 10y agoI know a few alt-right types in real life (one unfortunately being one of my roommates). They are absolutely as insufferable face to face as they are online. If anything I hate them more because I have direct confirmation that they are despicable people and not just trolls with poor taste.
- DougN7 10y agoThere are despicable people in all groups - left, right and center. The trick is not to assume they're all the same, and stop listening to all of them. Most importantly, they'll never learn from you and perhaps change if they have to put their guard up when you're around. They don't realize the same is true for everyone that disagrees with them too.
- dabbledash 10y agoThe problem with this idea ("you find jerks everywhere") is that it doesn't account for groups whose unifying ideologies make their members noxious. You might run into an unpleasant Lutheran or bird watcher or deficit hawk, but it's just a personality thing. A white nationalist is despicable by virtue of being a white nationalist. Of course, you're still right that the ability to look past that and try to communicate with people regardless is sometimes the only thing that can make a difference... https://www.nytimes.com/2016/11/26/opinion/sunday/why-i-left-white-nationalism.html https://www.nytimes.com/2016/11/26/opinion/sunday/why-i-left...
- kmicklas 10y agoOf course there are despicable people of all political stripes. There are no non-despicable white nationalists though, which is the difference I am pointing out.
- DougN7 10y agoI'd bet most of them were raised that way and just don't have enough outside experience. I have two data points: 1. I worked with an otherwise very bright guy who thought I was insane for wanting to visit Western Europe, because they'd slit my throat for being American. And this was 10 years ago! He's lived a sheltered life but doesn't realize it, and get too much news from one source. 2. My grandmother, one of the sweetest people ever, warned me about "negroes" and staying away from them. She was just a product of her upbringing. Over the years (and after moving out of her small town), she very much changed. Not that many people really want to be evil. Some do, but not most. I find it's usually ignorance. Talking nicely with them is what changes them. I personally hold a belief, and someone from the opposite side of the issue has engaged with me. I ponder it quite a bit, and see their side more humanely than previously.
- DougN7 10y agoYou know, I'm about to give up. There are a small number of people that can see how blinding hate is. How automatically demonizing the other side prevents any real discussion and understanding. But that minority is so small, I don't know what to do about it anymore. I occasionally try to say something like that on FB and it's drowned out by all of the quick 'gotcha' memes being posted. I don't even like having lunch with a bunch of buddies (all smart IT/programmer types) because their idea of discussion is parroting sound bites at each other. I fear we're doomed.
- gydfi 10y agoFind new friends. Move to a more politically diverse area. I do believe we should go back to the old rule that neither religion nor politics should be discussed in polite company.
- snarf21 10y agoDon't forget sex (sexuality), money and privacy too.
- 9q 10y agoNow you are a bigot if you don't openly endorse and actively support all the various life-choices and decisions people make with their sexuality. I really don't care about what sexuality or gender you identify as. It's completely irrelevant in working together as a team to build software.
- neptr 10y agoIn what instances do you find yourself having to openly endorse or actively support others' decisions in their sexuality to avoid being labelled a bigot? My personal experience, and intuition for most other walks of life, is that simply not commenting on or interfering with others' sexuality is enough for the topic to never come up.
- 10y ago
- maxforce 10y agoTo be left-leaning in the 60s and 70s was to be alternative to the mainstream. Today, to be left leaning is to be mainstream. Saul Alinksy's work has undoubtedly been a central tool in this transition. Here are some of Saul Alinsky's "Rules for Radicals" which succinctly represent the behaviour of people today: 2. “Never go outside the expertise of your people.” It results in confusion, fear and retreat. Feeling secure adds to the backbone of anyone. 3. “Ridicule is man’s most potent weapon.” There is no defense. It’s irrational. It’s infuriating. It also works as a key pressure point to force the enemy into concessions. 13. “Pick the target, freeze it, personalize it, and polarize it.” Cut off the support network and isolate the target from sympathy. Go after people and not institutions; people hurt faster than institutions. Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rules_for_Radicals https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rules_for_Radicals
- dtornabene 10y agoI just love this idea. If only I didn't get stares and outright contempt for my (leftist) political views. If only one of the two parties here in America actually ran on a social democratic platform (let alone further left) and won. If only there weren't literally ICE raids sweeping up undocumented people like its interwar europe. This position is just bizarre. Flat out bizarre. It serves only to stfile debate and keep the frame of rhetoric for anyone from the center right over squarely within "I'm in the minority, I'm the victim".
- 9q 10y agoCan I ask you why you are against deporting illegal immigrants? The illegal immigrants obviously understood it was a risk when they came, and any country is entitled to enforce its border security. Practically every single other country in the world heavily enforces its border, and will also deport illegal immigrants. And deporting illegal immigrants doesn't bar you from trying again to enter as a legal immigrant.
- Broken_Hippo 10y ago"practically every single other country in the world heavily enforces its border, and will also deport illegal immigrants" True fact: When I moved to Norway, there wasn't a customs guard on duty when I got off the plane here. The passport was quickly stamped at the layover in Copenhagen, and that is the single stamp in it. I'm sure there are electronic records of my other travels within Europe: Only once have I had any checks getting into a country, and that was more because I was flying back from Amsterdam and they picked me to search for drugs. It would have been somewhat easy for me to just come here, honestly. I didn't and went through immigration instead. People within the EU can pretty freely find work in any country and live there as well, and outside the refugee crisis, I think this likely cuts down on illegal immigration.
- hakkk 10y agoI dont even need to read the article to know this is gonna be some pro-ISIS, pro-islam liberal bullsh*t!
- hkmurakami 10y agoThis reminds me of a problem I have in my day to day life, where I am told something negative about such and such person's character/ability/personality and I immediately subconsciously accept this as an absolute fact, even when I've never met this person! (one example I can think of is believing hearsay personality portrayals of Joe Lonsdale online. I've never met the guy so who knows what he's actually like!) Still looking for the best ways to counteract this flinch reaction I seem to have of hearing hearsay about a person.
- Mikeb85 10y agoThe irony is that Milo is a classical liberal. Lots of his headlines are provocative, once upon a time people understood what rhetoric was. Now people just want an echo chamber, and rail against anyone who disagrees with their group. Also, kudos to the ACLU for supporting Milo's right to free speech. Liberalism is about freedom, not forcing everyone to agree with you.
- Sideloader 10y agoIs Rubio part of the apocalypse cult advocating a confrontation with Russia to "punish" it for transgressions for which no proof has been brought forward? If so, "rational" isn't really his strongpoint.
- AstralStorm 10y agoBut it's what you're saying his actual position or an interpretation of it?