4 ms·
> With that said and not to diminish the good work. It is sad and eye-opening more progress has not been made on these issues. The reasons for this are not har
by gajjanag 10y ago
> With that said and not to diminish the good work. It is sad and eye-opening more progress has not been made on these issues.
The reasons for this are not hard to find. Indeed, you hit the nail on the head in the next paragraph by pointing out the role of governments.
> I'm not sure what can be done on that or what that means, just a bit breathtaking how governments can help people or really screw things up on a scale nothing else even comes close to.
A case study of this in Ethiopia serves as a point in William Easterly's critique of "technocratic aid" in general and Gates's approach specifically:
http://www.seattletimes.com/opinion/guest-the-flaw-in-bill-gatesrsquo-approach-to-ending-global-poverty/ http://www.seattletimes.com/opinion/guest-the-flaw-in-bill-g...
He elaborates upon this at length in his book "The Tyranny of Experts: Economists, Dictators, and the Forgotten Rights of the Poor".
The way I like to think of it is that money, especially in large sums like the $50 billion in the foundation, is a potent tactical weapon. However, wars are not won on tactics/technology alone, but also on strategy. Here that amounts to solid leadership/deployment of the capital. I think this letter shows that they have done a pretty good job with it. Nevertheless, it is easy to fall into complacency and arrogance here. I only hope that they continue to listen, observe, and learn.
- nojvek 10y agoWhat really stood out to me was Melinda going in field and talking to women. The sex worker story really touched me. She is worth billions and could be living a life of ultimate luxury. She instead prefers to strongly fight for empowering women. I hope Bill, Melinda, and Warren live a long life to be able to fulfill their goals.
- erikpukinskis 10y ago> She could be living a life of luxury, instead prefers to fight Let's be honest... She is doing both. Have you seen their house? No judgement, but she's not in Mali every day.
- pierrebai 10y agoIs that not a false dichotomy? Providing help , like bed nets to prevent mosquito bites in order to reduce malaria, does not promote nor prevent other fight for more freedom in Ethiopia. Sure, the Gates foundation could have chosen to concentrate on that other front, but criticizing one type of aid for not help with something else is pretty uninteresting.