6 ms·
I think the really interesting point from this article is about why bundling is so attractive when marginal costs are close to zero, for both the consumer and t
by cortesoft 10y ago
I think the really interesting point from this article is about why bundling is so attractive when marginal costs are close to zero, for both the consumer and the seller. In the digital world, almost all services have a near-zero marginal cost, so bundling has a clear advantage.
It is also interesting when thinking about WHY people get so attached to the idea of 'unbundling', even when it might not be in their best interest. I think most people look at some of the large cable bundles, for example, and think "man, I am paying for so many things I don't watch!" What they don't realize is that even if the channels they didn't watch were removed, the cable company wouldn't be able to charge them much less, since the marginal cost for additional channels is near zero.
- barney54 10y agoExcept for ESPN. The marginal cost of adding ESPN is about $7 per subscriber. http://www.whatyoupayforsports.com/numbers/ http://www.whatyoupayforsports.com/numbers/
- eganist 10y ago> the marginal cost for additional channels is near zero. Is this really true? Setting aside barney54's ESPN example, I'd think that the emphasis in our current society on monetizing intellectual property would impose an artificial marginal cost for many service providers. I've never worked _in_ any of the major networks or cable companies, so I could be entirely wrong, but the idea that channels present a low marginal cost to networks goes against my intuition when contrasted against e.g. Netflix/Hulu/Amazon's tendencies to cycle shows and films for cost cutting.
- rtpg 10y agoIf you've bundled a channel within the "basic cable" package, that channel is now being sold to millions of people. But the costs to produce/buy the content on that channel don't go up with the number of users, right? It's not that it's cheap, but that it scales relatively quickly. I don't know how much service providers pay to carry these channels though. I'd imagine advertising is still what covers most costs.
- PeterisP 10y agoCost to buy that content does go up with the number of users, the typical licencing agreement of a cable company to distribute a channel has pricing of $x/subscriber. There can be some other conditions, e.g. if you distribute it to less than 100k subscribers then you still pay for a full 100k; or you pay $x for every subscriber that you have, no matter if you show them our channel or not; or you can distribute the nice channel A only to customers who also have our (not so nice) channels B, C and D, etc... but the core principle is that you do pay for content per subscriber. Furthermore, the big content companies produce a lot of content in all genres, and they're (obviously) focused on their average revenue per user - and if they can get $x ARPU for their bundles, where the demand is driven by a few key channels (e.g. they expect everyone who wants A or B to pay for the whole bundle) then any a la carte unbundled packaging that would allow A or B separately makes business sense only if the a la carte customers would on average pay at least as much as the whole bundle costs. There's no extra cost to the content owner to give the whole bundle, rather the other way around (your 'shit channels' can get more advertising revenue since some of those who got it in a bundle would watch it a bit), but there is a loss of revenue if you start paying less for the channels that you do want. Advertising covers the costs for the many shitty channels, those can be got/distributed nearly for free, but things that people actually want on their cable are quite costly, especially sports.
- rtpg 10y agoThanks for this detailed answer! I was thinking more about production costs, of course it makes sense to sell the content based on number of viewers. I'm not very aware of who pays what though. In an alternative universe cable would work like the internet: content carriers. Netflix is basically the most popular thing (normalized for traffic) and even they are basically paying ISPs to help get served better.
- seanp2k2 10y agoNot basically, but literally: https://qz.com/256586/the-inside-story-of-how-netflix-came-to-pay-comcast-for-internet-traffic/ https://qz.com/256586/the-inside-story-of-how-netflix-came-t... Comcast is charging to put data into their tube, and charging for access to the tube. They get paid on both ends. They can do this because they have no competition in most markets and there is little will in Washington to make this situation better for Americans. Edit: also, get ready for Ajit Pai's FCC where Comcast, Verizon, ATT, TimeWarner, etc will be allowed to "zero rate" "select" services (read: when services pay their ransom). Data caps and speeds for the "regular" internet will go down without this, and first-party offerings from the ISPs will of course be exempt from the caps. https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.wired.com/2016/11/att-time-warner-deal-shows-time-stop-zero-rating/amp/?client=safari https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.wired.com/2016/11/att-time-... it's already happening. ISPs refuse to be dumb pipes and want to open additional revenue channels by figuring out creative new ways to charge everyone for moving bits across their network. They will continue unchecked and without meaningful competition.
- EGreg 10y agoAmazon bundles Prime Video with next day shipping!
- monkmartinez 10y agoThe value for a lot of people, myself included, is achieved without the video, music and books. If they went away tomorrow, I would still keep prime for shipping alone.
- ocdtrekkie 10y agoIn the US, I feel this is no longer worth it. I've found a lot of people attached to Prime for the addon services, but I wouldn't pay for Prime now that Walmart offers free two day shipping for orders over $35. Nearly as good as Prime, no subscription. I've almost entirely switched from Amazon.
- majewsky 10y agoKind of off-topic, but serious question: How long are shipping times in the US if you're not on Prime? I'm in Germany, where basically any domestic mail and parcel arrives within one day of sending it off (unless you're on Helgoland or something). Amazon still wants me to enroll in Prime to get next day shipping, but I don't and still get the item the next day anyway.
- Broken_Hippo 10y agoMany things with standard shipping and handling take a week or two to get to you. A letter will take anywhere from a day to 3-5 days in the country, depending on where you are mailing to and from. This is mostly due to the expanse of the country. Boxes generally take a bit longer, and you pay for priority instead of just waiting until their load is big enough. In addition, a good number of places only work during the week to ship it out. This along with other upfront delays make it go a bit longer as well. Oddly enough, sometimes you get packages from overseas before you get a domestic package, even though the quoted mailing time was longer.
- 10y ago
- snarf21 10y agoIt is also why CBS and others have bought up all kinds of niche networks. TruTV (e.g.) could probably never really be profitable but as part of CBS, they get economies of scale. Then all the cable and satellite companies are forced to pay for all of these extra channels. Even a marginal cost is still greater then the amount customers would pay directly or could be likely be sold through advertising. CBS also gets advantages that they can say we have X million subscribers who view our channels every single day!! Even most of that is on CBS proper and not TruTV.
- gydfi 10y agoNobody ever looks at Netflix and complains "I never watch most of these shows, I shouldn't have to pay for them" because Netflix doesn't encourage people to think in those terms. Cable companies caused the demand for de-bundling via a partial de-bundling. If you could get all channels for $50 then nobody would complain. But if they force you to buy half the channels for $25 and half the channels for $25, people start to wonder why they can't just get a quarter of the channels for $12.50.
- pmalynin 10y agoNo the problem is why do I have to pay for cable and still get ads every 20 minutes.
- theseatoms 10y agoBecause consumers have been trained to not expect better.
- hermitdev 10y agoAlso, why do I have to pay for +200 channels to get the sum total of about 10-20 that I ever watch? (edit: grammar)
- gydfi 10y agoWell you don't have to. I've never paid for cable. I have this crazy thing called an aerial which picks up television signals out of the goddamn vacuum.
- FireBeyond 10y ago"picks up television signals out of the goddamn vacuum." But how do you breathe while watching those shows?
- ghaff 10y agoMany people (including myself) cannot pickup broadcast signals out of the vacuum (or the air) even in the general vicinity of major cities.