3 ms·
Various points: 1. Don't assume these are "brilliant" minds. It takes a certain type of mindset to become a college professor. Do not equate this with brillian
by BeetleB 10y ago
Various points:
1. Don't assume these are "brilliant" minds. It takes a certain type of mindset to become a college professor. Do not equate this with brilliance.
2. You're not listing a solution. Ousting the administrators won't solve anything in and of itself. They will be replaced by some other administrators (perhaps of your liking). But what actually is the solution? The realities they have to deal with won't change: Money has to come from somewhere.
3. Some of the author's complaints don't strike me as being a fundamental problem. As an example, it's not obvious why the publishing companies behave the way he would like them to. He's acting as if they have a responsibility towards people like him. Why?
4. Agree with the problem of too many administrators and too many adjuncts and teaching getting the shaft. But don't trust numbers too blindly. As an example, a local university showed their numbers. Since 1980, funding per student from outside (state/federal, etc) dropped a huge amount. Almost all of the tuition increases accounted for it. Overall funding for instruction per student did not drop at all - just the manner in which they obtained it. All the sports stuff was "extra".
5. The latest generation of faculty members - especially in disciplines like engineering - do not share this mindset. It's not at all unusual for me to hear a young engineering faculty member talk about the waste that are the humanities. I suppose primarily it's because the pressure for funding is huge on engineering faculty members, so they are predisposed to viewing everything as a fixed pie, and the less that goes to humanities, the more for them.
6. As several have pointed out, teaching is not something most faculty members today are hired for (especially in STEM). This is a problem from within - not something imposed by administrators.
7. As someone who spent time in academia, faculty members are focused on being individualistic and trying to stand apart from their peers. You cannot expect them to "get together" to oppose these changes. They have trouble getting together for pretty much anything. Don't let multi-author collaborations fools you.
- anigbrowl 10y agoThanks for this very comprehensive reply. 1. I'm trying to be positive :) 2. I should have gone into more detail on that, but the solution I had in mind was not so much a specific policy as a putting-forth of basic principles which they wanted to see administration recentered around. 3. True enough. 4. I know it's more complex than it looks at first glance. Administration increasingly requires compliance with many state and federal regulations which costs money, and likewise sports teams bring in cash from nostalgic alumni, and indirectly subsidize other things. 5. This goes to the heart of what I'm talking about. I find myself wanting to arrange blind dates between members of the engineering, humanities, and economics faculties to figure out ways they could be supporting rather than competing with each other. 6. for sure, and I hope that changes. 7. Clearly I'm leaning too much on a vision of the university as a calling and not enough on its reality as a cut-throat research marketplace. Thanks again for this in-depth exploration of the issues. I'll keep it in mind on my future reading.