5 ms·
This criticism would be more useful with concrete examples.
by maxerickson 10y ago
This criticism would be more useful with concrete examples.
- mmphosis 10y agoThe concrete examples have been deleted.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoWhich means things work as they're supposed to, doesn't it?
- PDoyle 10y agoNo, obviously it does not mean that. That known flaws have been fixed says nothing about the prevalence of unknown flaws.
- TuringTest 10y agoThe "consoles generations" articles have certainly not been fixed.
- macobo 10y agoBut you just said this: > I've looked at large articles I contributed to a few years ago and they are now disasters. Examples would be welcome.
- maxerickson 10y agoI think mmphosis was being tongue in cheek given the article being discussed. In any case, they didn't make the claim about disaster articles.
- makomk 10y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:List_of_citogenesis_incidents https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:List_of_citogenesis_... Note that of course, like everything on Wikipedia this is probably neither complete nor necessarily accurate.
- maxerickson 10y agoTo the extent that it is complete, that list counters the criticism made. Incidents that have been documented and dealt with aren't an example of bad information existing forever. It's also a pretty short list.
- makomk 10y agoBy definition, we don't know about the incidents that have not yet been detected and once we find out about them they're no longer undetected and so don't qualify as proof under your standard. Also, there are several entries on the list that hung around for 6-8 years and made their way into publications like scientific journals, books, and obituaries that are effectively going to be around forever. One particularly embarrassing example on the list involved a real person being falsely accused of taking part in a major points shaving scandal in college despite not even being on the team at the time, with multiple major publications repeating the claim. It was only discovered after 6 years or so because a film reviewer got an email claiming he was omitted from a film about the scandal because he wasn't even on the team, and believed that person enough to start digging despite all the coverage insisting otherwise: http://awfulannouncing.com/2014/guilt-wikipedia-joe-streater-became-falsely-attached-boston-college-point-shaving-scandal.html http://awfulannouncing.com/2014/guilt-wikipedia-joe-streater...
- yellowapple 10y agoI had no idea the game console "generation" counting was a result of citogenesis. The more you know...
- gydfi 10y agoPepe the Frog would be a good example. At some point the Clinton campaign sent out a press release claiming that the silly green frog was a "white supremacist symbol", in an attempt to tar Trump supporters, who had been extensively using the frog, by association. Within an hour or two, Pepe's Wikipedia page had been edited and locked to make the "white supremacist" claim. Journalists researching Pepe came along and confirmed via Wikipedia that he was indeed a white supremacist symbol, and boom, now you've got hundreds of citeable articles making the same claim.