4 ms·
I don't think it is clear that there is really a deletionist culture. There's 5 million English articles. Even a very high quality bot will make hundreds or th
by maxerickson 10y ago
I don't think it is clear that there is really a deletionist culture.
There's 5 million English articles. Even a very high quality bot will make hundreds or thousands of mistakes if it is doing anything vaguely interesting across a broad swath of articles.
Which doesn't excuse having a crap process at the margin, but nor does a moderate volume of unfortunate experiences make the case that it is all falling apart.
- Bartweiss 10y agoI think it's a bit confusing to equate deletionism with something done by bots? The most infamous exchanges are almost all about active, human users seeing an article (possibly flagged by a bot), putting it up for Speedy Deletion, and steamrolling people who support keeping it. The more pernicious approach, related to the one detailed here, is that articles are "pruned" for quality (removing e.g. external links sections) and then deleted for being incomplete. My experience and reading certainly suggests that Wikipedia has a problem (as confirmed by new editor and article counts), but it largely seems to be about disparate groups aligning harmfully. Some people want to remove external links, some people want to fragment large articles into more focused sub articles, and some people want to delete everything that's excessively narrow or short on content. As a result, each faction does its thing and the end result is content moving from "good and comprehensive" to "deleted entirely" by several innocuous steps.
- maxerickson 10y agoI think it's a bit confusing to equate deletionism with something done by bots? I don't think it's a big leap to assume that people running bots review the output less and less before acting on it.