13 ms·
Watching Wikipedia's extinction event from a distance
- jordigh 10y agoHm, I've been patrolling my only big contribution to Wikipedia, another niche article: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Medcouple https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Medcouple Woohoo, someone just made a nontrivial edit to it! But other than that, it seems to be mostly flying under everyone's radar. I hope it doesn't get deleted, but it might for being too niche. If it does, I guess I'll have to find a statistics wiki to move it to. Most of Wikipedia's deleted niche content ends up migrating to wikia or similar.
- The_ed17 10y agoIt shouldn't get deleted—on a quick read, it looks like it meets Wikipedia's notability policy.[1] :-) [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Notability https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Notability
- Bartweiss 10y agoHistorically, that's not much protection for a short article. The Deletionists largely won the war, and plenty of acceptably-notable articles get tagged with "en-encyclopedic" or other bases.
- pmoriarty 10y agoIf you think the deletionists won, you should try hitting Wikipedia's "Random Article"[1] link a few times. [1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:Random https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:Random
- ubernostrum 10y agoThis is like saying "well, our side lost 90,000 out of our 100,000 soldiers, but the fact that you can still find 10,000 soldiers on our side means the enemy didn't win!"
- yellowapple 10y agoDepending on the objectives of the military engagement in question, the casualty count is not necessarily the determining factor when it comes to who "won" said engagement.
- lobotryas 10y agoWhat in the world does _that_ prove? The point is: your article can get nuked at any moment unless your article is about a topic familiar to the Wiki Admin demographic OR unless it has a defender (a powerful enough Wiki Admin who will monitor and stand up for the article). That gives me an idea. Wiki Admins should offer a paid service! Pay me monthly and I'll actively protect article(s) of your choosing from deletion or vandalism!
- Bartweiss 10y agoYep, you captured the point I was going for here. It's not that all stubs and oddities are deleted, it's that if an article catches someone's eye the default decision is "delete". That's almost worse, since the results are so haphazard. Outside of a few predictable topics (virtually all cities/towns get long-lasting stubs), Wikipedia is "comprehensive" only to the limits of "no one noticed, or someone powerful stepped up to defend it".
- notatoad 10y agothat's entirely the problem being discussed here: there's a lot of things that shouldn't get deleted that nevertheless do, because there's a large number of wikipedia editors who feel a sense of accomplishment from deleting things.
- dorianm 10y agoHe could post his deleted articles on his blog too meanwhile.
- yread 10y agoThe article has since been restored. Look at the history and the copy-paste from a book: https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Hemovanadin&oldid=764679803 https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Hemovanadin&oldid... How does an experienced user (he has 14k edits!) make an edit like that? EDIT: TIL article history page is not necessarily accurate on deleted articles
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- The_ed17 10y agoWikipedia admin here. The edits that added the copyrighted material have been deleted, so this diff[1] isn't exactly accurate. That said, I've just fixed the history page so that the deleted edits actually appear, even if you can't read the material in them.[2] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Hemovanadin&diff=764679803&oldid=740559466 https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Hemovanadin&diff=... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Hemovanadin&action=history https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Hemovanadin&actio...
- yread 10y agooh I suspected something like that but it left me wondering why would the copyrighted material stay there and the records of the edits disappear - shouldn't it be the other way around? I've also read about RevDel and that leaves the record in place just hides the summary/user/text of edit but leaves the record in history.
- The_ed17 10y agoYou're exactly right on RevDel (revision deletion). However, in this case only certain edits were restored after the article was deleted—but the copyright violations were left deleted, so there was no record of them in the public edit history. That's why I've just restored the edits and revision-deleted the (copyrighted) text, leaving the editor and edit summaries public!
- 10y ago
- cjslep 10y agoI'm far removed from Wikipedia's social/cultural realm and yet I've only ever heard negative things about the deletionist culture there. Is the deletionist rationale that fewer articles == fewer spots for vandalism to occur?
- jordigh 10y agoI think people had a hard time taking Wikipedia seriously when there were more articles about Wookie culture and light sabre colours than there were about chickens or water. So, the deletionist culture seems to be about pride, focus on the serious business so that Wikipedia can be taken seriously and have a better reputation.
- jonathankoren 10y agoPerhaps, but it's also a database and it doesn't really hurt anything. We can point at pretty much any article and find a strange influence of geek male culture all over the encyclopedia. "In Popular Culture" (which I think is now supposed to be removed from articles) all too often simply contained links to video games and obscure anime. Personally, I find the shift to wikia troubling. Mainly because it came down from Jimbo to purge the articles and move them to wikia, which ahem Jimbo runs and profits from.
- emodendroket 10y ago"In popular culture" sections almost never add anything, yeah.
- emodendroket 10y agoI didn't know people took all the "Wikigroaning" stuff seriously.
- maxerickson 10y agoI don't think it is clear that there is really a deletionist culture. There's 5 million English articles. Even a very high quality bot will make hundreds or thousands of mistakes if it is doing anything vaguely interesting across a broad swath of articles. Which doesn't excuse having a crap process at the margin, but nor does a moderate volume of unfortunate experiences make the case that it is all falling apart.
- the_watcher 10y agoIt seems that several of the WikiProjects that are currently being worked on are aimed at improving stub articles ("an article deemed too short to provide encyclopedic coverage of a subject"). From the screenshot of the article the author references, his article was a stub. My guess is that someone tried to improve it, thinking that a book's coverage would be deemed encyclopedic, then when it was deleted, the person who deleted saw that it had previously been a stub and didn't look further into it.
- guard-of-terra 10y agoIt seems that copy paste from book and the insertion of copyright violation banner were made in the same edit. Why on earth?
- The_ed17 10y agoI've just fixed the article history to make the sequence of events clear.[1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Hemovanadin&action=history https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Hemovanadin&actio...
- petee 10y agoI watch topics that interest me, especially if i know nearly nobody else cares about them: - takes 2 seconds every day to check the list (on speed-dial, next to HN) - 30 seconds to read a diff - and 1 second to click 'undo' (or a couple minutes of research/learning for an edit) What's nice, is that there is a dispute process that the community takes pretty seriously, and you can always ask for assistance. As another user pointed out, the article has already been restored :)
- cpncrunch 10y agoI find it ironic that the author of this article bemoans the incompetent wikipedia admin who deleted the article, yet she didn't bother spending the 30 seconds necessary to post a comment on the talk page. Wikipedia works through volunteers, and if you don't bother giving up a little bit of your time to improve it, you don't really have any right to complain. I see regular articles on HN prophesying the death of wikipedia, but it doesn't seem to be going anywhere.
- cooper12 10y agoPretty much every article on HN that is even slightly negative about Wikipedia, Apple, or whatever is the topic of the day devolves into a hatejerk. I've noted this before [0] and it won't end as long as HN keeps being an echo chamber. From browsing HN you'd think Apple completely tanked with the new Macbook and their other controversial changes, but they just had a record quarter. I notice this on sites like reddit and HN a lot, people spread these memes of how a company should function or rather doesn't and they consider themselves the most informed target audience for that company even if it couldn't be further from the truth. Even in this very thread I see so much misinformation about how Wikipedia works and how it's being overrun with deletionists, yet anyone participating in the site could tell you that these fears are overblown. (in fact, in my three years of editing, I've found it harder to actually delete stuff because of inclusionists and random keepers) People just want to say "ackshually, nice thing isn't nice because x...". I'm not going to bother commenting elsewhere in this thread because it gets tiring, but people really need to actually try understanding Wikipedia themselves before repeating misinformation about it again and again. Nearly every thread on HN about Wikipedia is about people crying about that their article with no sources at all got deleted in favor of a popular culture topic that is meticulously sourced. Yet they also complain about Wikipedia being unreliable and biased. You can't have your cake and eat it too, either demand quality controls or create your own fork which has no controls at all and watch what happens to it. [0]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13624239 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13624239
- tlow 10y agoIn October 2010, I authored my first Wikipedia entry[1] and it was immediately tagged for speedy deletion by an admin named Academic Challenger[2], a person who proudly proclaims "I have deleted over 10000 pages from Wikipedia that meet Wikipedia's criteria for speedy deletion." The problem is that he indiscriminately tags most articles for speedy deletion. As my article met the Wikipedia standard for "noteworthiness" I was determined to fight this abuse of power, which I did and through the help of another admin (who unsurprisingly was familiar with Academic Challenger) and restored the page, which is still up today and has been edited by many people who are not me. Wikipedia clearly struggles with content review and creation, but it overall has been highly successful. The question seems to be, moving forward, how might maintain the ethos of Wikipedia in a changing world? [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cleanwell https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cleanwell [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User:Academic_Challenger https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User:Academic_Challenger Looking at the revision history, I do not see Academic Challenger's action in the logs of the talk page. Anyone know why?
- The_ed17 10y agoWikipedia admin here. Re your question, that's because you've accused the wrong editor.[1] :-) Looking at the article at the time it was nominated,[2] there isn't much of an explicit claim to being notable under Wikipedia's policies.[3] However, it was nominated for speedy deletion all of seven minutes after you created it—pretty quick, something I never like to see for articles that fall into a grey area. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Cleanwell&diff=388029379&oldid=388028975 https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Cleanwell&diff=38... - the actual editor was https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User:Terrillja https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User:Terrillja. [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Cleanwell&oldid=388028975 https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Cleanwell&oldid=3... [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Notability https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Notability - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Credible_claim_of_significance https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Credible_claim_of_si...
- tlow 10y agoPerhaps I have remembered incorrectly. I am far out of my depth of knowledge, so I defer to your information. Also please excuse my conflation of notability and "noteworthiness". As you can see and I think we can understand, as my first entry, I didn't know exactly how and what to do. In spite of this, I have this distinct memory of AC being a problem, I will look through my change log (Tlow03) and see if perhaps the article was moved or renamed from my original attempt. Also thank you for this clarification and you're right I think it probably was a grey area, but I do think the compound in question is a novel hand sanitizer that is the only of it's kind I know of. DISCLAIMER: I have no affiliation with the company at this time, a friend once worked there, but I do not and never have had any financial interest. Update: Yes the "boom your contribution is gone and doesn't belong here" almost the moment you write it feels very hostile.
- redsummer 10y agoWikipedia was the original fake news. For instance, someone might edit an article to say that a person was a known political extremist. Someone else might write an article (not on Wikipedia) saying the same thing (after having read the Wikipedia article). Years later, if the information is questioned on Wikipedia, then editors will add a reference to the off-wiki article, and everyone will be happy. Circular fake news, with truth going down the plughole. The entropic heat death of information. I've looked at large articles I contributed to a few years ago and they are now disasters. Full of bowdlerisation, inconsistent style, and false snippets of information. I think the abusive nature of many Wikipedia admins, and the hostility of Wikipedia itself to knowledge, will eventually just make it a 4chan with pretentions.
- maxerickson 10y agoThis criticism would be more useful with concrete examples.
- mmphosis 10y agoThe concrete examples have been deleted.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoWhich means things work as they're supposed to, doesn't it?
- PDoyle 10y agoNo, obviously it does not mean that. That known flaws have been fixed says nothing about the prevalence of unknown flaws.
- TuringTest 10y agoThe "consoles generations" articles have certainly not been fixed.
- macobo 10y ago
- M_Grey 10y agoWikipedia is a very useful resource for some things, especially as a starting point for a number of scientific and technical topics. I would never rely on it though, as a sole source of information.
- sgt101 10y agowhat would, you rely upon, as your sole source of information?
- M_Grey 10y agoI wouldn't.
- eridius 10y agoHacker news comments.
- M_Grey 10y agoTruly not a bad answer, if you had to pick one source. This is a contentious crowd that likes to cite sources and present fully fledged arguments. At the very least I like to use the comments to quickly assess the article, and whether it's a dud or not. Beyond that, sometimes the comments here on good articles still manage to exceed even the articles they're commenting on.
- cooper12 10y agoAs you shouldn't, even Wikipedia itself has a disclaimer against any claims of validity. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:General_disclaimer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:General_disclaimer) Besides, encyclopedias are tertiary sources, they should only be used as general references, not primary sources.
- guaka 10y agohttp://deletionpedia.org/ http://deletionpedia.org/ is a small project to cope with this in a positive way. A couple of years ago, when I was frustrated by deletionism once again, I wrote a bot that automatically copies articles that are about to be deleted.
- stephancoral 10y agothis is awesome, thank you!
- adekok 10y agoMy experience was that the prime criteria for deletion was that the Wikipedia editors be unfamiliar with the material. 1000 pages on Pokemon? Great! 2 pages on obscure technical subjects, of interest to tens of thousands of IT admins world-wide? Nah... get rid of it. I stopped contributing to Wikipedia when my edits were nuked as often as they were made. When spammers and people making negative contributions had their changes last longer than people making positive changes... well... Wikipedia is no longer of interest.
- Frqy3 10y agoWikipedia (with it's current edit culture) is an example of what bikeshedding looks like when scaled up.
- CalChris 10y agoGawker used to have a series on this, The 10 Best Articles Wikipedia Deleted This Week: http://gawker.com/the-10-best-articles-wikipedia-deleted-this-week-1749445064 http://gawker.com/the-10-best-articles-wikipedia-deleted-thi...
- seagreen 10y agoIf anyone's interested I've got thoughts on how to improve wikis here: https://housejeffries.com/page/4 https://housejeffries.com/page/4 My main issue with current wikis is that if you make a contribution and it's deleted, it's gone from the web. I think that if you're making heavy contributions to a page they should start on a personal wiki and then be pulled into the main wiki "pull request" style. That way if some over-aggressive editor deletes your work it stays on the internet, just on your personal wiki instead of the main site.
- chadwittman 10y agoThat's a great idea
- Balgair 10y agoI think this is not going to work on any large scale. Say you are a domain expert in some tiny little plant on some tiny island. Like, you wrote your PhD thesis on that plant. Sure, this is not very 'big', but it merits inclusion into the Wiki. Telling people that want to contribute, that are the domain experts, that have read and debated all the sources of which they may be the definitive source, that they have to go figure out how to set up their own wiki somewhere and then try to figure how to 'pull' and 'push' things to Wikipedia on a semi-regular basis because of some bot's deletion bias is the best way to make certain that Wikipedia is only written by insane people.
- brianpgordon 10y agoSome people do prefer to work on a new article in their user space (sub-pages of their user page which you're free to edit without interference) until it's in shape to be moved to mainspace (the actual Wikipedia that you can search).
- aleksei 10y agoThe point is that the article is likely to be deleted, so if anyone sets up their own wiki it's a net win, since the information won't be deleted altogether.
- dredmorbius 10y agoA few points, as a sometime Wikipedian. 1. Yes, Wikipedia has its challenges, there are flaws in the underlying assumptions of its originators, and it's not perfect. But it is better, in general, than any other resource to date, and is widely transparent to boot. 2. Conflicts over editorial content are nothing new, nor are they distinct to open collaborative projects. A few months back I turned up an instance from 1874, in which the British publishers, and American printers, of Chamber's Encyclopaedia had significant differences of opinion on a number of topics, including on the topics of free trade, (economic) protection, slavery, and biographical details of Elizabeth I and heirs. It's a rare in sight to the process. https://www.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/4xe2k1/chambers_encyclopaedia_editorial_statement/ https://www.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/4xe2k1/chamber... Another set of conflicts of which I'm recently aware concern Joseph Needham, biochemist and sinologist, whose research and writing were emperiled by his naive participation in what turned out to be a Chinese- and Soviet-led propaganda campaign. Documented in Simon Winchester's The Man who Loved China. 3. I've authored or contributed to a number of Wikipedia articles myself. In some cases, particularly in noting the blatant disinformation campaigns of Koch Industries and Libertarian partisans in particular, especially on global climate change, I've been rather frustrated. I've originated a couple of articles. One, on the present NPR president Jarl Mohn, was slated for deletion on numerous grounds when I first submitted it. The result of working with other more experienced editors was a substantially improved and strengthened article which still stands. I'd created the article after being surprised to find it didn't exist at all. Yes, camping out on and watching articles may be useful to avoid more serious disruption, particularly on contentious topics. And Wikipedia does have a problem, as does all media, on ideologically-tainted topics. No, the truth doesn't always win out. But it does pretty well, all told.
- TuringTest 10y ago> But it does pretty well, all told The main problem IMHO is that it stands largely on inertia from a bygone era, the pre-2007 period where most of the existing basic content was put in place by a swarm of highly motivated volunteers with a few loose rules. This is completely different from the current situation, where the bureaucracy has been ossified into a neverending rulebook designed to protect the precious content from vandals and good-willed naive newcomers, in the hands of a shrinking and overworked zealous user base. The original drive that got the whole thing up is gone. The only regulars are equally split among inclusionists and deletionists, but by its very nature deletionism will prevail in the long term - it only takes succeeding once to get rid of an article forever, while people defending interesting content from removal need to keep an active watch and regularly spend effort in fighting for its survival.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- joshuak 10y agoThis reminds me of the very insightful article "Geeks, MOPs, and sociopaths"[1] posted on hn a couple of years ago. I'm not sure to what degree it can be mitigated, but it sure seems like something to account for when engineering social content communities. [1] https://meaningness.com/metablog/geeks-mops-sociopaths https://meaningness.com/metablog/geeks-mops-sociopaths
- wainstead 10y ago> Wikipedia went from people writing an encyclopedia to people writing rules about writing an encyclopedia, or writing bots to defend an encyclopedia, but without enough safeguards to save content from deletionists. Sounds like another example of "A Group Is Its Own Worst Enemy." http://www.shirky.com/writings/herecomeseverybody/group_enemy.html http://www.shirky.com/writings/herecomeseverybody/group_enem...
- ChuckMcM 10y agoI think the periodic outreach for donations on Wikipedia would be more successful if they earmarked some portion of the funds to identify and remove harmful volunteers.
- seqastian 10y ago.. and didn't fight net neutrality in 3rd world countries.
- exception_e 10y agosource?
- saurik 10y agoSeriously? In addition to having been fairly big news, and having been covered and talked about on this website numerous times, it took me all of three seconds with a single generic Google search to get a high-profile news result that focusses on the issue. Knee-jerk challenges to source things should be limited to things that are at least slightly difficult to find sources for and which are also difficult to believe. https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-switch/wp/2014/11/25/wikipedias-complicated-relationship-with-net-neutrality/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-switch/wp/2014/11/25...
- yellowapple 10y agoNot the GP, but while I'd give you credit for the "at least slightly difficult to find sources for" part of that, "difficult to believe" definitely applies (at least for the average person) when it comes to a claim that Wikipedia, of all organizations, acts deliberately to undermine net neutrality. Not that you're wrong, of course; only that asking for a source for such a claim is by no means unreasonable.
- exception_e 10y agoBelieve me, I'm the first person to kindly point out that something is "Googlable" or, in the case of programming, direct someone to the docs. With this, I couldn't believe that Wikipedia would engage in such a unethical practice - didn't even search for it considering that Wikipedia is generally a great org. Thanks for the info.
- swang 10y agoi may have posted this before. when i use to be active on wikipedia editing mainly video game and sports articles, i stumbled upon a large sockpuppet that was constantly adding incorrect pieces of information to articles pertaining mainly to video games, espn, wrestling. this sockpuppet had a very clear M.O. and did the same actions, and even if you made changes, the person would go about and revert them. getting all these accounts for this one sockpuppeter was a huge pain in the ass though, and finally i was exhausted dealing with it, so the next best thing for me was to reduce the surface area he could troll around. so i began looking at articles he had created, there was an article about a nintendo ds bratz game. he had created the article, filled it with random information and had left it. so i nominated it for deletion since it wasn't really a notable video game. now this was before deletionists were a huge thing on wikipedia. i myself am not a huge deletionist but at best this game is a small mention in an article about bratz merchandising. but almost immediately a huge flood of people came in to say that it was a notable game, with links from ign.. they weren't actual articles about the game, just literally the computer generated page they had for the game. i think i made a couple comments arguing why it didn't deserve to have its own page but in the end i just gave up. not worth my time when i was honestly trying to improve the quality of the site. so i guess my whole point writing this is the problem isn't with deletionists, it's the entire bureaucracy of wikipedia. i remember going through arbcom so many times because people disagreed with me about how a video game article should be written. or how alicia keys birthday is incorrect (she was born in 1980, not 1981) but because _everyone_ references wikipedia and cites it as the ultimate source, you can never get it changed because people ACTUALLY monitor and turfwar her wikipedia page.
- bjourne 10y agoHow would deleting an article he had created "reduce the surface area he could troll around?"
- narrator 10y agoDeletionist culture is also a big problem in the Gnome UI. For a long time they were deleting features like crazy. Same goes for Systemd. I think people like deleting features because it's easy and seems like progress. It's a bikeshedding phenomenon. The solution to this is to have a flexible module system so people can have their almost nothing "non-bloated" system and other people can have features. Same could work for wikipedia. You could have the core wikipedia and the alt hierarchy. It could work like usenet.
- digi_owl 10y agoIts rampant across FOSS these days. People should from the hilltops how many lines of "old" code they have eradicated.
- Qcombinator 10y agoWikipedia should never have existed. Encyclopedias exist to provide (a) access to information, (b) organisation, and (c) some guarantee of expertise. It's easy to take for granted how amazing it is to have a world of information at our fingertips, but the Internet itself provides greater access to more information than any encyclopedia ever could. (And of course Wikipedia deliberately eschews original content anyway.) We already have tools to organise and find information on the Internet: it's called Google. Or DuckDuckGo. Or etc. How much authority an encyclopedia has depends on how much you trust its editors to be, or be able to find, experts in the relevant subject matter. A search engine doesn't provide any guarantee of accuracy in its results, but then neither does Wikipedia — most people point out that it's up to you to follow the references and evaluate them. The things Wikipedia is good at are the things that the Internet itself is good at; and the things that the Internet on its own is bad at (e.g. vetting accuracy) is not something that can really be fixed short of turning into Britannica Online. It's not quite that simple, of course. In theory, anyone can throw up a webpage on hemovanadin for the world to see, and it is relatively easy to do so, but it could be easier. What isn't so easy is collaborating — Wikipedia's greatest strength is also its Achilles' heel: anyone from anywhere in the world can contribute, constructively or destructively. But easier collaboration is a technical issue. There's no reason in principle that a centralised body should be required to manage all that. It's just that the availability and user-friendliness of the necessary software currently provide too much friction to ignore.
- exception_e 10y agoThe thing that makes Wikipedia so special is the fact that the community strives to follow the guidelines they have set forth: - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Your_first_article https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Your_first_article - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Notability https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Notability - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Be_bold https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Be_bold I'm not saying that every Wikipedia article adheres to them, but generally speaking, the quality is good and bias is severely frowned upon. "Random" web pages on any given topic miss out on these guidelines and are generally non-collaborative. Full disclosure: I'm a big fan/consumer of Wikipedia... absolutely love the philosophy behind it.
- alexandercrohde 10y agoUh, I really disagree with this article's premise. The author identifies a page he added that was deleted, and his contribution was lost (on more than one occasion), and cites this as evidence of wikipedia's inevitable demise. Though such inefficiencies are unfortunate, and discouraging, I think they only slow progress. I think evenutally an article on Hemovidin will be written and not deleted, and I wouldn't be surprised if most encyclopedias don't even have such an entry. There is some clunkiness around wikipedia, but compared to academia (which almost everybody without journal access and fluency in english is restricted from reading) it's by far superior. In fact, I can't think of another better source of reliable information that is freely and widely accessible.
- nickpsecurity 10y agoIt's part of a larger trend described here that turn the site into what's essentially maintenance mode vs thriving with new content: https://www.technologyreview.com/s/520446/the-decline-of-wikipedia/ https://www.technologyreview.com/s/520446/the-decline-of-wik... It might survive but not the way intended.
- vacri 10y agoI've been reading "Wikipedia is about to die! Everyone is about to leave!" articles for almost a decade. It's still there. Similarly, the low-hanging fruit has already been done. Maintenance-mode was always going to be on the cards. The centrepiece in TFA is about a two-paragraph, four-sentence article. It's a terrible article, and should be rolled into another one. Any article that could be given in two tweets is a trivia-night factoid, not an article - I fundamentally disagree with TFA that it's "articles like this that make Wikipedia great". These kind of brief factoids are the type of content that shitty clickfarms have. TFA even uses Britannica as a defense, saying that it has an article... but click on the link, and "Britannica does not currently have an article on this topic". Hemovanadin has, however, been rolled into another article - 'cell pigmentation'. Not exactly a sterling defense for the author. --- I always see this happen with these bitter predictions of WP's death. People are either complaining about disagreement on an obviously subjective topic (like a politician's bio), or their chain-of-evidence is suspect, like in this case. Here are the stats: https://stats.wikimedia.org/EN/TablesWikipediaEN.htm#editor_activity_levels https://stats.wikimedia.org/EN/TablesWikipediaEN.htm#editor_... Look at the blue columns - number of editors per month/quarter with 5 and 100 edits - and it's been pretty consistent since 2010. Yeah, the heady days of 2007/08 are gone, but again, low-hanging fruit.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- leovonl 10y agoIn 2004, I wrote the first article about a well-known but not very popular brazilian singer in the portuguese Wikipedia. I spent the whole weekend on it, citing references, finding dates, listing albums, etc. A few years ago I went back to find the article much bigger... but it was utter crap. The text was nowhere near unbiased, barely touched facts and seemed more like a bedtime story about flying saucers than a wikipedia article per se. There was more content indeed, but most data was obscured by something that didn't looked at all like an encyclopedia article.
- rurban 10y agoFor exactly this reason I stopped contributing there. Flagrant admin abuse all over with their new speedy deletion tool.