11 ms·
> They cannot be compelled to testify against themselves. In my joking statement (that mirrored yours) I was referring to exactly that. Giving police informati
by scotty79 10y ago
> They cannot be compelled to testify against themselves.
In my joking statement (that mirrored yours) I was referring to exactly that. Giving police information that currently is only inside a mind of a suspect. Not documents, not physical keys, not anything else.
I don't care that you can be compelled to provide documents. Which is silly by itself. Whole business of law should expect no cooperation from the suspect and should accept help from him with suspicion. Giving him opportunity to provide documents is giving him opportunity to forge some. Giving him opportunity to provide password to a machine may give him opportunity to give one that will cause the machine to overwrite the data you are trying to gain access to. Giving him opportunity to confess without double checking every bit of information he discloses with hard evidence is providing him the opportunity to take fall for someone else's crime.
> But there is no exceptional injustice underway here. This is the way the system works.
So the system is just temporarily exceptionally unjust. Unless you can somehow say that jailing a guy indefinitely for failing to disclose information only he poses, at the same time having not enough evidence that he committed any crime, is somehow just.