4 ms·
These are different than what the OP was talking about. He's basically asking about stealth products like segway etc... All your examples were ones where the i
by AndrewKemendo 10y ago
These are different than what the OP was talking about. He's basically asking about stealth products like segway etc...
All your examples were ones where the initial hype around the technology/idea just wasn't ready yet, it wasn't one company playing coy and then coming out with some groundbreaking thing like the iPod/iPhone was.
- Nursie 10y agoWhy do people think the iPhone was groundbreaking? It was evolutionary, it was very, very well polished (something apple are good at) and it was advertised massively. But it wasn't streets ahead of the competition.
- fsloth 10y ago"But it wasn't streets ahead of the competition." I think this is a highly controversial opinion, especially with hindsight. Consumer products are never just about the hardware specs, but about how the entire ecosystem around the product functions.. Two competing platforms (Nokia and Windows phone) tanked and the only viable current competitor (Android) came to market afterwards and driving marketshare by imitating the specific innovations the device had (plus with a certain degree of openness).
- Nursie 10y agoI'm not saying it is all about the hardware. I don't think the iPhone experience was revolutionary either. Nokia tanked due to very, very poor management and branding. Internal competition between engineering units and tens of handsets with overlapping features made the brand slowly sink into the mire. When thinking about the iPhone, remember there was no app store for over a year, and other platforms had had one since 05 or before. Apple got a lot of stuff right, they released a great product. But it wasn't the huge leap forward people like to present and I often wonder if the perception that it was such a leap forward comes from the state of the US market at the time, not the world market (particularly Europe).
- chrisco255 10y agoIt was the first touch-first mobile OS built from the ground up to accommodate gestures. At the time, the limited touch screen phones available had an awkward stylus. Then they packed in GPS with Google Maps, accelerometer, double-sided camera, iTunes access, unlimited data, visual voicemail, etc. And Apple's app store was the first one that didn't suck. The few that had app stores did not have robust SDKs with tooling for building apps, you had to use Java VM and go through an arduous submission process to get your app on any other phone. Apple streamlined it, made it simple, and completely dominated the industry for a reason. The iPhone was clearly revolutionary, and a 10X improvement over any other phone on the market to that point.
- tempestn 10y agoWhen the first iphone came out, it was the only mainstream device to ditch the physical keyboard, allowing for a very large (for the time) touchscreen, while keeping the device thinner and lighter than high-end competitors. This screen, along with pinch to zoom, allowed desktop websites (which were basically all websites at the time) to realistically be used on a mobile device. You certainly could browse websites on other devices, but you wouldn't want to, given a choice. The original iphone is what really started mobile browsing.
- gambiting 10y agoI remember the very first presentation, when Steve Jobs used pinch to zoom and a gesture to rotate an image. My mind was literally blown, and I was using a WindowsCE smartphone for a few years at that point. Also the browser looked like something that didn't suck. It was something above well-polished, it was that moment when you look at something and just think "why didn't anyone else think of this already? it's so simple!"
- Nursie 10y agoMobile browsing had been around for quite a while, and I had used Opera Mobile on various phones for some time. PDAs, when they existed as separate devices, tended to have larger screens than phones, and allowed reasonable browsing too. The iPhone was a great product, I'm not denying it, but I wonder if the perception that it was revolutionary comes from the state of the US market at the time - generally thought to have been years behind Europe and Asia.
- maverick_iceman 10y agoI browsed web in phones before iPhone, the experience was awful. Though there is some truth in your saying that the US market was much behind Japan and Korea at that point. (Europe and rest of Asia was definitely not significantly ahead.)
- wtvanhest 10y agoI used a pocket pc in 2003sh. It was garbage, but the form factor was very close to an iPhone. Treos were damn good and we used them to surf the web, iPhone was just much better. iPhone was incremental, just like the bb was incremental
- cocktailpeanuts 10y agoThe creator of Android doesn't agree with you https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2013/12/the-day-google-had-to-start-over-on-android/282479/ https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2013/12/the-d...
- AndrewKemendo 10y ago>Why do people think the iPhone was groundbreaking? Because every phone that came after it (and currently) follows it's form factor.
- Nursie 10y agoThat's hardly surprising, given its form factor is "it's a screen". It wasn't the first phone to market with that concept, and tablet PCs had been around for a while. They were a total failure, but they were there...