7 ms·
A look at the wireless traffic of MIT students
- unwind 17y agoI would have thought that a place like MIT ran their on-campus wireless using encryption, which should make this kind of sniffing/snooping a bit more difficult. Even our home wlan is encrypted. Weird. Is this by design?
- epochwolf 17y agoThere is little point in trying to encrypt what is effectively public wifi.
- Locke1689 17y agoRADIUS WPA2 with a student ID or something and a separate "public" wifi?
- someone_here 17y agoThat's what my university has (Carleton in Ottawa).
- eob 17y agoAs far as I know, yes, it is by design. MIT's philosophy toward just about everything is famously open. - You can walk around in just about all of the buildings during the day, and many even at night without a special access card. - A CS professor here was the one who founded OpenCourseWare, which helped ignite the fire that led to many universities putting their courseware up for free online) - Course registration is amazingly relaxed, to the point where halfway through the semester it is common to hear a professor say "by the way, if you haven't signed up for this course, you probably need to as the deadline is approaching" - MIT's network is not behind a NAT box. In terms of internet access, this culture means that anyone within radio-range of MIT's campus gets free, unprotected WiFi. A very different reception than you get at that other school down the street cough. :) (Of course, the flip side of this is that you are responsible for your own security). EDIT: I also remember during grad student orientation, the campus police representative explicitly told the auditorium full of new students: "The Cambridge homeless community is part of the MIT community, too. Just because you don't have a home doesn't mean you are not welcome here, so if you see someone who appears homeless on MIT campus, treat them with the respect they deserve." Approximate quote, since this was 2 years ago, but I was pretty blown away at the culture here from day 1.
- icefox 17y agoLast year while at the library there was a room to a lab (where the printers were). To get in you could either punch in the code or next to it was a whiteboard with 5 or so problems each of which gave you one digit in the code.
- brlewis 17y agoI was a student there 1986-1990, then worked full-time on Athena until February, 1998. What you say has been true a long time. There are no-trespassing signs at all MIT entrances only so that the MIT police can legally eject people who cause trouble. Casual visiting is normal. In 1994 I pushed hard to get kerberos-authenticated telnet into the Athena release. The general sentiment from others was that, sure, sniffing passwords was possible, but distributed computing was advancing to the point where people would be able to do everything from their desks, and wouldn't need remote logins. So kerberizing other services was a higher priority.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- drewcrawford 17y ago> In terms of internet access, this culture means that anyone within radio-range of MIT's campus gets free, unprotected WiFi. My university requires you to register MAC addresses, change your hostname, turn on SAMBA, and use PEAP authentication before they will let you connect to their packetshaped and heavily filtered network where you can download a full gigabyte per day. :`-(
- robryan 17y agoI guess one reason would be they have the idea that if you are worried about your activity being tracked that you probably shouldn't be doing it over the public on campus wireless.
- epochwolf 17y agoI've done some of my own wireless sniffing on campus. I didn't actually realize it's a federal crime to do so. Oops.
- jodrellblank 17y agoGiven that realisation, I'd have thought not admitting in public to having comitted a federal crime would jump higher up your priorities!
- jrockway 17y agoGood luck making a case with no evidence and no witnesses. Also, how is listening to a Wifi radio any different than listening to your police scanner or AM/FM radio? I'm not convinced that passive packet capture is a criminal activity.
- jodrellblank 17y agoWhy is you putting a knife in someone considered attempted murder in one case and assault in another and an accident in a third? Why is computing an algorithm that undoes DRM illegal and one which predicts weather not? Why is building something electronic and selling it legal, unless there's a bit of paper in an appropriate office somewhere in the country describing what you've built? We don't legislate things based only on the precise actions of what people are doing, but also the social and mental contexts in which people do them. And listening to an FM radio station is a different act in a different context to listening to a police radio station or a privately owned laptop's WiFi card. I'm not saying I know it is a criminal activity, just that it's not as simple as saying "well it's like listening to public FM radio so it must be legal.". It isn't like it, and that conclusion doesn't necessarily follow.
- jrockway 17y agoWhy is you putting a knife in someone considered attempted murder in one case and assault in another and an accident in a third? This would be a good analogy if knives were being constantly broadcast into my head. Also, since it's impossible to prove that you listened to a radio transmission, I don't see how any law against listening to public Wifi would be enforceable. (Example: saying "I've smoked pot" on the Internet. I just confessed to a crime, but probably won't be spending much time in prison for it. A confession is not enough proof.)
- phreanix 17y agoSomewhat funny quote: "Alas, pretty boring."
- daten 17y agoI thought it sums up the article pretty well. I was expecting much more based on the title. A better title: "Amateur high-level wireless traffic analysis of 21 consenting students during a 45 minute class"
- kevindication 17y agoYou could have rewritten this article without the word wireless. It's only relevant because he didn't have to deal with a switched network. No wireless packet analysis at all? Weak.
- zwieback 17y agoshe
- lazyant 17y ago30% of DNS traffic? isn't this a lot?
- sfall 17y agoit does seem a little high but so many other protocols also require a dns lookup. sometimes more than one
- zokier 17y agoTCP probably uses larger packets so results are bit skewed imho
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- JoeAltmaier 17y agoI wondered about that too. Not the case on my wired network. Perhaps its because many laptops were taken out of suspend and then hardly used, so session-initialization messages dominate. btw Thanks for actually addressing the point of the article.
- silentOpen 17y ago30% is mDNS which is multicast presence notification -- iTunes sharing, Bonjour etc. Blame Apple.
- NathanKP 17y agoI'm surprised that none of the students tried to skew the results as the author expected. If could have been done fairly easily by writing a quick HTML page that uses JavaScript to make a couple iframes continuously load a variety of different sites.
- vault_ 17y agoIt's not even that hard: while [ true ]; do curl www.google.com done
- ghshephard 17y agoOr, my preferred approach: while :; do curl www.google.com; done
- comcastdeals90 17y agoEven in a lecture where you are told someone will be harvesting the usage data, the WoW addict still goes to MMO Champion! I love it! lol
- squidsoup 17y agoI'd be concerned for the students that managed to push mmo-champion.com (a WoW blog) to 9th place!