4 ms·
I gotta say, that experiment would not convince me. I own a sodastream. To get fizzy water, I need to inject CO2 under pressure into water to get it to become
by marcus_holmes 10y ago
I gotta say, that experiment would not convince me.
I own a sodastream. To get fizzy water, I need to inject CO2 under pressure into water to get it to become fizzy.
Wafting some pure CO2 over a glass of water would not make it fizzy or change its PH
Wafting some pure CO2 over a kilometre-deep flask of water would definitely not change it
Considering we're talking about increasing the level of CO2 from 0.000002% to 0.000004%, and then wafting it around the surface of a vast ocean, I don't think the experiments can be compared at all...
- phaemon 10y ago> increasing the level of CO2 from 0.000002% to 0.000004% What is that a percentage of? (if it's atmosphere you meant, you've gone the wrong way with your zeros)
- marcus_holmes 10y agowell we've gone from 200ppm to 400ppm. I might be a couple of zeroes off because it's a percentage, but the point is that this is trace gas, not pure CO2 which is what my sodastream uses
- phaemon 10y agoThat would be 0.02% to 0.04%.
- marcus_holmes 10y agono, 0.02% = 0.0002 = 2 parts per ten thousand, so another two zeros on that. 0.0002% I make it
- ac29 10y ago>Wafting some pure CO2 over a glass of water would not make it fizzy or change its PH Yes, it would change the pH [0]. CO2 dissolves in water to form carbonic acid [1]. [0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Henry%27s_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Henry%27s_law [1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbonic_acid https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbonic_acid
- marcus_holmes 10y agoI understand the principle ;) My point is that nature is not bubbling pure CO2 through the ocean to make it fizzy or acidic. Using fizzy water to demonstrate the acidity of the ocean is just bad science.