4 ms·
These are good points but I'll nitpick on one of them: we already maintain a collection of emails, phone numbers, etc. for everyone we know, and a public key is
by DennisP 10y ago
These are good points but I'll nitpick on one of them: we already maintain a collection of emails, phone numbers, etc. for everyone we know, and a public key is just one more data point in the contact list.
- brightball 10y agoThat's true. Seems like a great use case for a password management company to add address book management and/or develop an email client.
- anigbrowl 10y agoTotally agree; it's just been my experience that crypto specialists don't care about UX any more than UX people care about crypto.
- tptacek 10y agoWhoah. Hang on there. Crypto specialists aren't the people lobbying loudly for PGP-encrypted email in 2017. They're the ones who made the world's most popular messaging application double-ratchet deniably encrypted by default without the userbase even noticing.
- dredmorbius 10y agoWait: which one is that?
- girvo 10y agoSingal, nee TextSecure, I'd assume. Edit: Crap, I mean WhatsApp, which _uses_ Signal's protocol now.
- dredmorbius 10y agoGotchya. Re-reading Thomas's comment, one of that set at any rate.
- synchronise 10y agoDoes WhatsApp have reproducible builds yet? Do we know that the app isn't storing the keys somewhere else?
- chimeracoder 10y ago> Does WhatsApp have reproducible builds yet? WhatsApp isn't even open source, so no, it doesn't have reproducible builds. (Signal is open source and does have reproducible builds). > Do we know that the app isn't storing the keys somewhere else? No, but WhatsApp is still strictly better than either email or SMS. Even if you don't trust Facebook, that still only leaves three parties that can compromise the integrity of messages (you, the recipient, and Facebook), as opposed to the uncountable number of parties that can passively observe email or SMS in transit.
- anigbrowl 10y agoI'm sorry, I undermined my own point in pursuit of a witty syllogism and I don't want to give the wrong impression that the crypto in apps like Signal (which I prefer) is somehow second-rate.