3 ms·
I tried reading Brave New World. It was atrocious. It was such a heavy-handed, corny, poorly written caricature of the left. I'm baffled by its enduring popu
by pmoriarty 10y ago
I tried reading Brave New World. It was atrocious. It was such a heavy-handed, corny, poorly written caricature of the left. I'm baffled by its enduring popularity among intellectuals.
- xiaoma 10y agoIt's fascinating that you see it as a caricature of the left, given that Huxley was a left-leaning pacifist who even today would be far to the left of at least the last 4 Democratic presidential candidates on quite a few issues. Sadly, the entire western world is just a lot more authoritarian than it was during Huxley and Orwell's time.
- pmoriarty 10y agoThere's nothing about sympathizing with or even being on the left that prevents criticism of the left. The left is infamous for the amount of internal bickering, denunciations, and recriminations that go on. That said, Huxley's critique of the left (if it can even be called that) didn't seem like one based on any left-wing principles or ideas. I really don't know where he was coming from on that. It really felt like it could have been written by some cheap right-wing tabloid. Maybe that's why it was so popular.
- xiaoma 10y agoThis is sadder still. You're saying you feel pacifism and anti-war sentiments are no longer a part of the left? Huxley was critiquing Hitler and especially Stalin. Is that your idea of "the left"?
- pmoriarty 10y agoNo. Not in the least. I wish I had I had a copy in front of me, so I could give you specific examples. It's been a long time since I read it.
- cityofdelusion 10y agoI'm curious as to how you got this impression of the book. The book was quite critical of a lot of different systems from both the political left and right, which makes sense given when the book was written (1930s UK). The world in the book is a strange blend between pure decadence, socialism and consumerism. The society is atheist, but worships Henry Ford. There is a communist equality, but it is enforced through strong castes. Everyone is happy and free, but the world controllers act as an oligarchy of dictators. Science is valued, but only the right kinds. I believe the book is popular among intellectuals because, like Fahrenheit 451, the society shown has an anti-intellectual and anti-knowledge streak.
- jstewartmobile 10y agoBrave New World was a prophecy of modern-day Western materialism and social control, and Aldous Huxley was the architect of left-wing counterculture. You need to turn-off your modern-day trigger-word trip-wires and read it again.