4 ms·
Governments often classify protest groups as "terrorists." The UK government has spent millions investigating non-violent environmental groups for one example,
by Someone1234 10y ago
Governments often classify protest groups as "terrorists."
The UK government has spent millions investigating non-violent environmental groups for one example, using anti-terrorism funds, teams, and laws to do so.
Companies asking the government to squish protestors is also extremely common all around the world. I mean in the US right now we have oil pipelines which primarily benefit private companies getting built by the Army Corps of Engineers using public money and protesters harassed & beaten by police. All to reduce an oil company's costs and/or increase their profit margins.
- gydfi 10y ago>Governments often classify protest groups as "terrorists." And many terrorist groups claim merely to be "protestors" so it's tricky.
- toomanybeersies 10y agoIsn't the land simply the property of the Army Corps of Engineers, and it's being built by a private company? The USACE is a weird organisation. It's part of the US army, but almost exclusively does domestic civil engineering and public works.
- Retric 10y agoFirst, finding useful things to do with all those military people outside of wartime is a major issue especially when they need to suddenly stop doing that during a war. Second, a lot of civil infrastructure has military implications. EX: It's hard to make a dam you can't take out with explosives, but you can do a lot of things down stream to make destroying it less important. So, as a bonus it keeps the organization's skills up to date.
- omegaworks 10y agoThe land was illegally annexed by the government. The Sioux signed a treaty that was broken by the US, were offered money in compensation for the land, which they refused. That land abuts the reservation's surface water sources. Without it they have no water security, an asset they consider priceless. The ownership remains contentious.
- malandrew 10y agoThat land was stolen from the Arikara/Sahnish by the Sioux using guns and horses acquired from trading with Europeans. The descendants of the Arikara/Sahnish now live on the Fort Berthold Indian Reservation. The venue to resolve this dispute was in the courts and the timevto do it was Years and decades before there was a project planned for that land. However, if we're really going to go down this absurd path, let's take the entire Standing Rock reservation away from the Sioux and hand it over to the Arikara/Sahnish.
- crumpled 10y agoI find that history interesting. What absurd path? I honestly don't understand what you are getting at.
- senorjazz 10y agoNot the op, but I think they mean by "absurb path" that if the land is taken from the Sioux and given back to the Arikara/Sahnish because the Sioux took it violently, there might be quite a lot of other US land that has to be given back as that too was taken violently.
- malandrew 10y agoThe absurd path of the court of public opinion and a cultural marxist framed discussion of the "oppressed vs oppressors". Protesting on land that is currently recognized as private land is depriving its owners of its use. If the ownership is in dispute, the venue to resolve that dispute is in the courts. Literally no one cared about the land until a pipeline was going to be placed on it. FWIW, my original source for this information is a friend who is 1/4 Sioux and thinks the protest is absurd. I've fact checked his claim. The Sioux only occupied the land east of the Missouri river in pre-contact America. The Arikara/Sahnish were agrarian people driven off their land by the Sioux.
- omegaworks 10y agoThe problem with going to court is precedent. The Sioux don't want the court to rule in favor of the government. That would set precedent about the government's ability to force the exchange of native land for fiat currency. The problem is that in the west private ownership carries with it a right to destroy. If the army corps wanted to build a wind farm on the plot, there wouldn't be a problem. They want to build an oil pipeline over the water supply. If a disaster were to occur, there is court precedent for abdicating the company of any responsibility for cleanup.[0] The present administration's Indian Affairs appointee wants to preserve this privatization agenda at all costs[1], so there's even less likely recourse if damages should occur. 0. http://articles.timesofindia.indiatimes.com/2012-06-28/india/32456094_1_ucil-union-carbide-india-ucc http://articles.timesofindia.indiatimes.com/2012-06-28/india... 1. http://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-trump-tribes-insight-idUSKBN13U1B1 http://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-trump-tribes-insight-i...
- golergka 10y ago> The UK government has spent millions investigating non-violent environmental groups for one example, using anti-terrorism funds, teams, and laws to do so. Not sure what situation you're talking about here in particular, but curious: do you think that government should investigate organization only after violence occurs? Or do you think that environmental organizations by their nature can't turn violent and terrorist?
- ue_ 10y agoI don't know about the person you're asking, but I'd rather not have a state prying into my business at all, in fact I'd lke it even less than if someone else did it. The idea that a person or group has the right to intrude in my privacy is something I oppose, and I see no reason why having force (And claiming you have the right to use it against people you don't like) and calling yourself a state changes that. The government can mind it's own business, as I pay it only to avoid government threat to my autonomy. It is illegitimate, propped up by no more than the monarch who claims God props her up.