3 ms·
Why use PGP anymore when you can use Keybase and the next generation of key management? Instead of having one master key for your identity, the paradigm is cha
by EGreg 10y ago
Why use PGP anymore when you can use Keybase and the next generation of key management?
Instead of having one master key for your identity, the paradigm is changed:
Identity is a set of claims "X on domain A is Y on domain B". That's it.
"Domain" can refer to a server-based service such as reddit, or a client app on a device.
Such proofs are easy:
1) For public identity on sites which don't support this scheme, X simply signs something with their private key for A, and posts it on A at a URL only they control (such as an About page or a Facebook post). Presumably, X and A had to cooperate to do that. Now, to prove "you are X on A", you simply claim your your identity and the url to check, and sign it with the same private key. The verification proceeds by checking the https url for the actual claim. You hold that key. If A wants to revoke your identity proof, they just delete it from eg your profile. Each site A has to be supported individually by the client lib though, because "urls you control" are different on each site.
2) For private identity on sites that cooperate, there is a huge variety of things you could do. Everything from oAuth 2, to the signature scheme above, except the user id X on A can be different for each relying party B.
So the claim "X[B] on A is Y on B" is a private claim - others can verify it only if they identify themselves as B (eg X must be logged into A and using https on A and B and doing cross-domain communication using iframes).
They can't satisfy these conditions unless they spoof B's SSL certificate and trick X into visiting their site via a poisoned DNS. And in that case they can just find out that X is X[B] on A. Very limited privacy leak. They still can't decrypt or sign anything as X on A.
This is the scheme anyone can implement and use. It should be standardized IMHO somewhere.
- hdhzy 10y agoThere is an RFC extension for OpenPGP that does just that: https://tools.ietf.org/html/draft-vb-openpgp-linked-ids-00 https://tools.ietf.org/html/draft-vb-openpgp-linked-ids-00 It's implemented in Android OpenKeychain.
- rch 10y agoPlanned to say this as well. The Keybase model is working well for me, and there's nothing special about that network: similarly implemented alternatives could probably strengthen one another.
- jsprogrammer 10y agoYou still need to trust a set of claims under that scheme. What if claims can be generated faster than you can verify them?
- nickik 10y agoI would love to be able to use Keybase to send encrypted email. Sadly currently Keybase does have a email as a main property on the profile and fetching it from the GPG is not very cool. I really want to be able to type Twitter, Hacker News or Github names into emails.
- milesrout 10y agoYou can just use Keybase to distribute PGP keys though, right?