5 ms·
From what I understand our legal system was designed to fail "open". Or rather that we are willing to let a guilty person go free rather than an innocent person
by godelski 10y ago
From what I understand our legal system was designed to fail "open". Or rather that we are willing to let a guilty person go free rather than an innocent person go to jail.
I know everyone wants to have a perfect justice system but we have to ALSO decide which direction we would like it to fail until that time comes (never). In essence cases like this are more about this question. When the system fails, which direction do we want it to fail in?
- godzillabrennus 10y agoThat was before the for profit prison industry became a cancer that incentivized keeping non-violent people in prison.
- e40 10y agoI think that's most of it, but I also think there's been some weird shift in the way police and prosecutors behave over the last decade. Much has been written how we now effectively have debtor's prisons. People are fined and imprisoned because they can't pay the fines. The crazy part for me is that this has all happened while the crime rate has been steadily going down, so there's not even a justification for it (from a crime standpoint).
- jamessb 10y agoAs a starting point, see the Wikipedia article on Blackstone's formulation [1]: "It is better that ten guilty persons escape than that one innocent suffer". It refers to an interesting article, "n Guilty Men" [2]. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blackstone%27s_formulation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blackstone%27s_formulation [2]: http://www2.law.ucla.edu/volokh/guilty.htm http://www2.law.ucla.edu/volokh/guilty.htm
- godelski 10y agoThanks, these are interesting reads.
- bluejekyll 10y agoYou have an interesting point. I think the struggle that I see as a layperson, is that the system fails hard when it fails. Let me ask a question, is jail the appropriate sentence for a contempt of court charge? This is not the first time, reporters have been jailed for many months bc of contempt of court charges. Is this the appropriate sentence for the crime of not complying with a court order? I don't know what the alternative would be... also, on the question of guilt vs. innocence. I can see myself agreeing with you that since the state has such a high burden of proof to meet, that the defense has a an implicit advantage, the issue is that the statistics are showing a far greater issue of a imbalance of justice being applied at different levels of society. There is no good reason that I can see where an innocent poor person goes to jail because of a bad defense, vs a guilty rich person who gets off because of a great defense. Justice is supposed to be blind.
- godelski 10y agoWell I would consider myself a layperson and welcome anyone with actual experience to help educate me on the subject matter. I'm saying this because I'm just offering my own opinions. In reference to your question I'll pose another question: "Should this be counted as being in contempt of court?" As to the innocent people going to jail because of bad defense, I think this is why we need to fail in the direction of the innocent. I'd personally rather guilty men go free than innocent men be imprisoned. I think if we're going to figure out the limitations of the 5th Amendment in the digital age we need to decide which direction the system is going to fail. I think many on HN will agree with me, but I'd be interested to know what the country as a whole believes (if anyone has that info).
- cortic 10y agoI've always been confused by this proposition; If there is an innocent person convicted of a crime, then there also has to be a guilty person that has gone free.. so it seems the ultimatum has to be "are we are willing to let a guilty person go free rather than let a guilty person go free and an innocent person go to jail." Which has a much more obvious answer..
- iopq 10y agoLet's say you have 200,000 suspected criminals, some % of which are criminals. How many of them are you willing to put in prison? If it's looking that most likely around 30% are guilty, do you put 60,000 in prison and say "oh well, some false negatives, some false positives, whatever" or do you just put 30,000 in prison to prevent most innocent persons from going to jail? Then you are letting half of the guilty people go free It's a question of how many innocent people you are willing to jail to catch more real criminals
- cortic 10y agoI see what you are getting at, but it would still be; 60,000 = "oh well, some false negatives, some false negatives AND false positives, whatever" 30,000 = "oh well, some false negatives" Although i get the feeling we are moving into semantics, its just always bothered me the way this was worded. Anyway thanks for that perspective, made me think.
- angry_octet 10y agoOr to give it an engineering flavor, the ROC: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Receiver_operating_characteristic https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Receiver_operating_characteris... It seems we accept a higher FAR (False Alarm Rate, a diagnostic which gives a false positive) for certain communities (poor people, minorities) than others. The consequence matters too: even people who support the retributive aspect of the death penalty may reject it in practice because of the excessive false conviction rate.
- morgante 10y agoThat's assuming a hypothetical crime actually happened in the first place. In many cases it's possible that no crime ever happened. (For example, if the man in the article never actually had child porn that doesn't mean someone else did.)