3 ms·
In the pre-internet era travel was a code word for open mindedness toward other cultures. A fairly standard trope in travel writing was freaking out the reader
by VLM 10y ago
In the pre-internet era travel was a code word for open mindedness toward other cultures. A fairly standard trope in travel writing was freaking out the reader to a perfectly acceptable level at the time of writing. This is obsolete today. Due to globalism we're moving our culture over there to replace theirs and moving their people over here to replace ours. Open mindedness is seen as wrong, "no platforming", utter intolerance toward anything non-progressive and if they're equally progressive over there, there's nothing new to experience there. People who would have found travel interesting in 1970 when I was young now experience unusual non mainstream cultures by visiting various 4chan boards and looking for people who still use the N-word in 2017, or who go camping, or are NEETs.
What travel as a verb still happens in 2017 is now about western style decadence or social signalling and both are heavily organized. If you want decadence you read the resort reviews about how good the all inclusive drinks are and proximity to nude beaches and dance clubs and such, its all heavily organized and indexed and sorted and CRUD-app-ified. Who wants to read a book about a quirky end user scrolling thru yelp or airbnb? If you want social signalling, perhaps you need that trip to Africa for volun-tour-ism for that ivy league application, you contact people who organize that from top to bottom, social signalling has been pretty well product-ized.
Some of the death of old style travel writing is the death of optimism. Sure my grandpa was one of the few who could go to Scotland for a month with my grandma, it was semi-realistic to afford for joe 6 pack. The days of the middle class ever being able to afford that are long gone along with the optimism; retirement means if you economically and physically survive the medical industrial complex, you get cat food and ramen at best, not a semi-realistic a trip to Scotland. When people are banned from an activity its human nature to claim to stop desiring it until it becomes real; millennials are too poor live in the burbs, they've been totally screwed over; response, we never wanted to live there anyway nah na nah na na. Plus or minus some gaslighting by people with a bridge to sell to suckas. Permanent decline in standard of living means you'll never travel internationally except maybe as a refugee, natural human response, I never wanted to anyway, not gonna read the book extolling the virtues and excitement of travel, etc.
- edblarney 10y agoEven though there is a lot of truth in your comments, I know a lot of people to 'travel' and they do it rather normally. No instagrams. Just regular travel. "Permanent decline in standard of living means you'll never travel internationally" This is total rubbish. People are travelling way, way more than ever before. I live in Montreal, one of the poorest metro areas in North America and the 'millenials' here travel a LOT. They prioritize it a little more than other things, and it's easily affordable. Travel is cheaper and more accessible than ever.
- VLM 10y agoI agree with your comments in that I missed a major theme which is the sub culture of people who read books, the vast middle class plain old Joe 6 pack American, HN readers which are a very peculiar subgroup of the population but mistakenly think they typical, and finally the population of people still wealthy enough to travel don't seem to have much overlap anymore. At one point lots of joe 6 packs read books and a nice book about visiting the home land of Ireland sounds like a nice amount of adventure and was semi-realistic enough to consider, not so much anymore.
- shostack 10y agoWhile I agree with some of your points, millennials are not fleeing suburbia because they can't afford it. They are moving to urban job centers because that's where the best chance of employment is with a decent range of employers so you aren't locked into one or two who can abuse you because they know you have no other nearby options. Millennials would rather have a higher cost of living and lowered job risk these days. Then there are other aspects like, not wanting to drive everywhere because cars are so baby boomers, wanting amenities nearby, etc. They also have different views about kids and are having them later, so don't need the bigger living space just yet.