4 ms·
> I don't really see why the whole foods hate is so hip. I think there has long been a resentment of them. 20 years ago I did some technical work for a natura
by wpietri 10y ago
> I don't really see why the whole foods hate is so hip.
I think there has long been a resentment of them.
20 years ago I did some technical work for a natural foods broker. They knew the wholesale price for all sorts of organic and alternative foodstuffs. They were just astounded by Whole Foods markups as compared with other vendors. If I recall rightly, the Whole Foods marketing also rubbed them the wrong way; it had strong class-based elements, taking the natural foods industry from a "power to the people" feel to a "this is fancy and high class" feel.
In a business sense, they've clearly done well by it. They're at the intersection of rising inequality and rising concern over what we eat. But that limits them too; trying for "mass-market luxury" is a precarious position. You end up resented by the true luxury fans as cheapening something they care about. And other companies, ones not constrained by luxury, can go after the mass-market end of things. Plus they still have the essential contradiction between commercial exploitation and the natural do-goodery of the organic foods types.
So the hate seems pretty plausible to me. Their old shtick is working less well; the grocery market is really different 20 years on. They'll need to find a new shtick, but I don't think that will be an easy transition.
- base698 10y agoThe genius of Whole Foods to me was that in the same store you'll see a $35,000 a year new college grad shopping along side a $300,000 a year professional. It hit the upmarket class stuff and kept the hippy stuff too so the educated group would aspire to go there. This as opposed to Fresh Market, which was purely upmarket/upper class.
- galdosdi 10y agoVery well said. This is why I see TJ's eating Whole Foods's lunch. TJ's started from the opposite end. Like what I imagine possibly happening to iOS at the hands of Android, this is a true example of "disruptive" in its earlier definition -- start down market and move up, not the other way around. > Disruptive innovation, a term of art coined by Clayton Christensen, describes a process by which a product or service takes root initially in simple applications at the bottom of a market and then relentlessly moves up market, eventually displacing established competitors.
- valuearb 10y agoMoving downmarket to up is really hard to do. Point in fact, Apple's share of mobile profits is going up, not down.
- MR4D 10y agoMoving from upmarket to down is also hard to do - witness IBM trying to move to PCs from mainframes, and just today, Nikon trying to make a lower range camera (the DL just got canceled due to massive Nikon losses). In my view, Whole Foods is losing out because while they stuck to Organic with a capital "O", they forgot about the rest of the things people want. Clearly everyone is different, but a regular grocery store has the luxury of catering to most of those ( low cost, wide variety, close by, _and_ organic). Whole Foods only can offer one of those (currently). So companies like HEB, which have some very nice grocery stores, can easily shift their product mix to fit the neighborhood they serve. That's a huge advantage, and I don't know how WF can fight them and succeed.
- gech 10y agoNo, thats Fresh Market. Jesus, they have classical music playing
- erichocean 10y ago> trying for "mass-market luxury" is a precarious position I guess, Apple seems to do okay.
- wpietri 10y agoFor now. Laptops are a declining market, and they have circa 10% of it. Phones sales are only growing slowly, and they have a declining share of that market. iPad sales are dropping precipitously. iPods will eventually stop being a product at all. Competition is advancing; their once-innovative products now have pretty close matches, even as the price gap widens. To maintain their position, I think they're going to need to find a new product category, one where they can leap out ahead as they did with all those other products. The watch was a fine accessory, but not a major category. They've never done particularly well in the TV space. There's no other immediately obvious market for them to jump into. Can they do that? We'll see, but the last time they succeeded was with the tablet computer, and that was with Jobs at the helm. So I'd call their future... precarious.
- vidoc 10y ago> They're at the intersection of rising inequality and rising concern over what we eat. But that limits them too; trying for "mass-market luxury" is a precarious position. Thanks, that's basically the best expression of some of the things I've always felt about them without managing to put words on it. They basically have a classic strategy of Luxury, without selling high-end stuff like Harrods/Hediard, the tier they happen to be dominant on is something I would awkwardly label good and healthy. I've always found profoundly immoral the idea that access to this kind of food should be reserved to wealthy people, that it implies a certain cultural baggage, and that it can be used to signal social status. In my neighborhood, I've realized that whole foods on Saturday morning as become a sort of meeting point for the local socialites, which are often perfect caricatures. It's fascinating to witness two acquaintances bump into each other, and almost directly perform a review of the content of their cart, it's almost like if their heilroom tomatoes had replaced their rolexes. Actually, it's funny because I realize I often do something not just remotely similar, when the guy in front of me has a huge cart entirely filled with stuff I know will be expensive: I cant help but to think "wow, he must be packed", then the unavoidable voyeurism related to damage assessment. If it ends up being a 4 digit number and the guy apple pays quickly with zero emotion on his face, it can be intense. Your analysis of how the competition will exploit the weakness of their strange position is spot on.