5 ms·
> But the problem is, if you've just spent 40 years paying a mortgage (which I assure you is probably a non-insignificant amount of your lifetime income in aggr
by AnthonyMouse 10y ago
> But the problem is, if you've just spent 40 years paying a mortgage (which I assure you is probably a non-insignificant amount of your lifetime income in aggregate), you would expect to be able to recoup at least some of that expense, no?
It's not just that. Imagine that you've just taken out a 40 year $500,000 mortgage. How happy are you going to be if next year your house is now worth $250,000 but you still owe $490,000 on it?
As far as I can tell the best solution to this is to expand the housing stock in the presence of moderate inflation, so that nominal housing prices stay the same while real housing prices fall.
The US has a huge debt problem in general and moderate inflation helps with that too -- if the government creates new money it's that much less they have to borrow or tax and it reduces the real value of the national debt and everyone's mortgage, student loans, etc.
- hudibras 10y ago>Imagine that you've just taken out a 40 year $500,000 mortgage. How happy are you going to be if next year your house is now worth $250,000 but you still owe $490,000 on it? The thing is, this is exactly what happens with everything else that an American consumer purchases with a loan: cars, boats, RVs, everything that is purchased with a credit card. As has been said before, a house is just a wooden box that you leave out in the rain for 30 years. But yet we expect that this box will become more valuable over time...
- zero_intp 10y agoI think a reasonable assumption should be made regarding home ownership, "Assume to pay (yearly) 3% of the current purchase price in maintenance or deferred work."
- PretzelFisch 10y agoI think your confusing house cost and property cost. There are not a lot of 500k homes around.
- accountface 10y agoi always assumed house prices went up because the population center expands and the price balloons out from the center, I guess i'm kind of dumb though
- someguydave 10y ago"if the government creates new money" In other words you are asking the government to steal value from people who own debt and give it to people who owe debt. That is neither fair nor an obvious win in the long run.
- SubiculumCode 10y agoNot this again. People do not own the value of a dollar, just the dollar's IOU. If you have a house, you do not own the value of the house, you own the house. ——The values of your dollars and your houses depend on valuations by the rest of society, and you do not own that, and thus the value of your dollars and houses cannot be stolen. In fact per the Constitution, the government has thr exclusive right to choose the number if dollars to produce, and we investors made a prediction that the government's money creation policies would continue a certain way. In the case where the government produces more money than we had predicted doesn't make us victims of theft, just poor investors. As a matter of policy, there are multiple stakeholders: those owning debt want deflation, those born without wealth want inflation so that there are enough dollars in circulation to match the growth in population.
- someguydave 10y ago>People do not own the value of a dollar, just the dollar's IOU. Value of your dollar holdings= (value of all dollars) * (number of your dollars / number of all dollars). You assert that nobody is promising the value of your dollar holdings will remain constant. I agree that this assertion is true, but it's also obvious that failing to maintain the "value of all dollars" is a good way to impoverish all dollar holders, possibly permanently. Convincing people that you aren't going to allow them to maintain the value of their dollar holdings is a good way to encourage them to sell dollars.
- AnthonyMouse 10y agoAnd if people sell dollars then we get inflation, which allows the housing stock to expand and reduce real housing costs without putting everyone underwater on their mortgages by reducing nominal housing prices. What seems to be the problem?
- yummyfajitas 10y agoImagine I've just borrowed $500,000 in order to purchase the same amount of AAPL. Then someone else starts producing phones that people like better than the iPhone, AAPL tanks and my securities are worth only $250,000! I'd be super unhappy about this. But the "best solution" to this is not for the government to somehow prevent people from buying non iPhones so my AAPL stocks don't go down. The best solution is for me to recognize that placing highly leveraged bets on the stock market is extremely risky and that I just lost money because I made a bad bet. What you are describing is socialized losses, privatized gains. Why is that a good thing?
- sulam 10y ago<nitpick>there's no leverage if you use $500K to buy $500K of AAPL. Financial leverage is created when you multiply the buying power of a fixed amount of money through financial vehicles like options. It could be as simple as using the fact that your brokerage is usually willing to loan you money up to a certain percent of your assets in the account. You can then use that loaned money to buy more stock, perhaps as a hedge or perhaps to double-down on your original investment thesis</nitpick>
- yummyfajitas 10y agoAs I said, Imagine I've just borrowed $500,000 in order to purchase the same amount of AAPL...
- sulam 10y agoBah, my mistake for not reading more carefully. Sorry!
- AnthonyMouse 10y agoThe difference between a house and shares of AAPL is that the government has been encouraging people through words and laws to over-invest in houses (and likewise student loans etc), leading to a huge bubble. The bubble is the fault of government policy, not people rationally buying houses based on the existing policy environment. To fix this, there are going to be losses. The question is, who should primarily suffer them? The homeowners who reasonably relied on official policy, or the banks who promoted and benefited from that policy? > What you are describing is socialized losses, privatized gains. It isn't. The losses would otherwise be suffered by a majority of American families, which sounds pretty "socialized" to me. Those are also who would receive the gains from inflation. The best place to actually put the losses would be the government, except "the government" doesn't actually have any money, it just spends your money which it takes through taxes or inflation. And the money has to go to homeowners/borrowers rather than come from them, so what you would effectively need is a tax on creditors, which is what inflation is. It's essentially the same logic as the 5th Amendment Takings Clause. If the government is going to take your property they should compensate you for it. Normally this doesn't apply to things like zoning changes for pragmatic reasons -- the taken value would be too large for the government to afford and then they could never make zoning laws. Which is nothing but a pragmatic injustice. If we can avoid that we should, and in this context inflation would allow us to do it. Inflation is a type of tax and you're just making the equivalent argument to "all taxes are theft".