2 ms·
"To give an account of his "feud" with Chomsky, Chomsky claims that recursion (in the sense of embedding sentences into sentences) is the defining characteristi
by mcguire 10y ago
"To give an account of his "feud" with Chomsky, Chomsky claims that recursion (in the sense of embedding sentences into sentences) is the defining characteristic of human language that sets it apart from other animal languages. Everett claims that the Piraha language doesn't display recursion and therefore Chomsky's claim is wrong."
I realize that your summary of Chomsky's theory is short, pithy, and misrepresents Chomsky, but your argument here is incorrect.
You say,
* X is the defining characteristic of Y.
* Z (a purported element of Y) does not have X.
The only possible conclusion is that Z is not an element of Y: the Piraha do not speak a human language.
- YeGoblynQueenne 10y agoSure, that's Everett's (wild, unsubstantiable, absurd) claim: that the Piraha, a human people, speak a nonhuman language. And that affects the claim that recursion is the defining characterstic of human language -how, again?