3 ms·
I fell in love with the Amiga ever since I saw an Amiga 1000 in the first issue of Amiga World. Amigas were clearly light years ahead of virtually all other p
by pmoriarty 10y ago
I fell in love with the Amiga ever since I saw an Amiga 1000 in the first issue of Amiga World.
Amigas were clearly light years ahead of virtually all other personal computers at the time -- with the arguable exception of the Atari ST, which had the reputation of being better for music. But the Amiga was better for games and had better graphics. As a hardcore gamer, I knew instantly that the Amiga was what I wanted. Somehow I convinced my parents to get me an Amiga 500, as my second computer (after the TI99/4A) and spent a lot of time collecting games and demos, and connecting to BBS'.
Somehow the rest of the world didn't really see the clear superiority of the Amiga, and stuck with their boring IBM PC's and Macintoshes. Commodore collapsed, and virtually every other personal computer became extinct, as most people just wanted to buy whatever they had used at work (IBM PC) or school (Apple). This was an early lesson for me that superior technology does not always win. In fact, it's often the inferior technologies that win, for a variety of reasons -- especially marketing.
I kept my Amiga for a long time, but eventually migrated to Unix (SunOS, Irix, Dec Alpha's OSF/1, and Solaris), and eventually to Linux on a PC. It had become increasingly clear that newer tech had left the Amiga in the dust. Some people still stuck with the Amiga long after I stopped using it, but I donated mine long ago. Sometimes I wish I'd kept it, so I could bring it out for nostalgia's sake every now and then, but it's a lot of equipment to lug around.
I often wonder how the personal computer landscape would have changed had the Amiga won. Back then, it seemed like Microsoft, the IBM PC, and Apple have kept us back 10 or 20 years with their dominance.
- BjoernKW 10y ago> it seemed like Microsoft, the IBM PC, and Apple have kept us back 10 or 20 years with their dominance. I used to think so, too. However, the Amiga might've just been a fluke. The very architecture that made it unique and so far ahead of its time also was its limitation in terms of technology. There wasn't really a way forward beyond the AAA chipset, which never even made it into production. Hombre, the proposed next generation of the Amiga, was supposed to be very different from and mostly incompatible with previous Amiga computers. The software had serious limitations from today's point of view, too. There was no memory protection and no multi-user capability. Adapting Amiga OS accordingly would have taken serious effort, perhaps to the point it wouldn't have been recognisable anymore. So maybe, while a truly awesome machine the Amiga sadly enough was just an outlier of computing technology that was the right thing at the right time but wasn't viable in the long run.
- flohofwoe 10y agoI've been recently thinking about this a lot. I think the critical year was 92/93 between the release of Wolfenstein3D and Doom. These were the PC's killer apps that showed everyone that a powerful generic hardware can be better than a highly specialised "hardware game engine" like the 8-bit homecomputers and later the Amiga and ST. But at this time the Amiga's architecture was already 8 years old and pretty much unchanged apart from the incremental 1200 update (just imagine what happened in the same time span after '93 on the PC!). I have to disagree about the OS being limited, even by today's standard. It was sort of cobbled together under the hood, but the end result was unbelievable when you put it next to a PC or even Mac of the mid 80's to early 90's. Even in 1990, when I was finally able to buy my own Amiga it was like alien technology (even compared to a Mac Plus, which was completely unaffordable).
- digi_owl 10y agoThe problem of the Amiga was basically that it was clock cycle linked. To really get things going with the platform you had to count cycles so neither the CPU not the chipset got hung up waiting for the other. This made the platform frozen from the moment it shipped. In contrast the PC was less rigid, and only really had the x86 ISA and the BIOS memory map in common (and even the latter is falling by the wayside in recent years). There was also the whole clone aspect. The Amiga stood and fell with its parent company, Commodore. Once Compaq and the others cloned the BIOS chip, IBM could belly up and the PC platform would barely blink.
- pjmlp 10y agoI like to think its architecture is what gave rise to the idea of having dedicated sound and graphics cards on all computers and game consoles. I followed another path, settling on Windows, after a decade of UNIX. The UNIX culture never seemed to be much welcoming to the demoscene culture, which had more points of contact with the gaming culture on Windows. For a while in the late 90's there was a website that tried to be Poet for GNU/Linux. They never managed to have more than a few demos there.
- pmoriarty 10y ago"The UNIX culture never seemed to be much welcoming to the demoscene culture" I'm not so sure it's that so much as the demoscene is not interested in Linux. I've tried to drum up interest on pouet in creating demos for Linux, and no one seemed interested, and some were even hostile to the idea.
- pjmlp 10y agoSpeaking from my own experience back in the day. Demoscene conflates with gaming culture, no one is religious over APIs, rather over computer systems, e.g. Atari vs Amiga. What matters is becoming the master, able to show that demo that everyone though impossible, streching that specific OS/machine to the max, on the big screen. Sharing code, talking about hippie ideals of having APIs that would make all hardware systems look the same, without that special touch what means to own an e.g. Amiga, are not well received. For GNU/Linux users there aren't special computers, with its differentiating architecture and special features that make them unique, a special flavour, all look like an UNIX clone. So one gets two communities talking past each other.
- pmoriarty 10y agoYou're saying the demoscene has a problem with Linux because it's generic? Then please explain why the most popular demoscene platform is Windows, which is about as generic as it's possible to get.
- 10y ago