3 ms·
>> I'm a huge fan of Mumford, but I think he's stretching a bit when he says that natural images have grammar like language has grammar. That seems to be what
by YeGoblynQueenne 10y ago
>> I'm a huge fan of Mumford, but I think he's stretching a bit when he says that natural images have grammar like language has grammar.
That seems to be what he's saying- that the process of vision in living things is actually a grammar.
He doesn't have to be entirely correct for his intuition to be that useful though. We don't have to assume an existing grammar to fit a bunch of data to a grammar (like we do in grammar induction, where there's no such assumption when, say, someone models DNA sequences as a grammar etc).
After all, a grammar is just a representation. The question is how good that representation is- in theory as well as in practice. In theory, it's a good representation if it helps us answer questions about the process we're trying to model. In practice it's good if it allows us to reproduce the process, especially automatically, with computers, and predict the behaviour of agents that employ this process etc etc.