3 ms·
This raises an interesting question: On clouds where you can provision baremetal instances, is it possible for the tenant to modify/corrupt firmware/hardware in
by rwmj 10y ago
This raises an interesting question: On clouds where you can provision baremetal instances, is it possible for the tenant to modify/corrupt firmware/hardware in such a way that the machine is subsequently "owned" and untrustworthy after it is returned to the pool of available hardware?
- Groxx 10y agoI'd assume so, in the same way you can do such things on commodity hardware (e.g. bios and disk-firmware viruses, very likely others).
- buildbot 10y agoDefinitely, if you can update the bios from your operating system then you could load something malicious. Also, I wonder if you could read the current IPMI password for a machine from the operating system, and if baremetal providers set those passwords to some default...
- mjg59 10y agoIf you're able to get access to the management network then you've basically already won - IPMI implementations just aren't good enough in general to resist any kind of determined attack. But to answer your question, conforming implementations shouldn't let you read the password back over the local interface. Whether that's true in reality, well…
- buildbot 10y agoHmm so with ipmitool you can test passwords for every registered IPMI user - so that's scriptable. (How fast can you test? who knows) Then, you can get the IPMI network VLAN from ipmitool as well, if your hosting provider was lazy and didn't use the dedicated port. After that, configure your box to be on that VLAN and then you're in???
- mjg59 10y agoYes. Some vendors have mitigations against that (Oracle have done significant work in this respect), but otherwise there's no especially good reason to believe that public bare metal providers are giving you trustworthy machines.