4 ms·
I always dislike comments like this from the article: “Something is very, very wrong with the Arctic climate.” The climate can't be "wrong" it has no agency. T
by ChuckMcM 10y ago
I always dislike comments like this from the article: “Something is very, very wrong with the Arctic climate.”
The climate can't be "wrong" it has no agency. The impact of human CO2 production on climate can be "unprecedented" or "destabilizing" or "ill advised" but the word 'wrong' implies that there is a 'right' climate. We know that the climate changes on the planet, we emerged as the more annoying form of hominid during an ice age after all. "Something" caused that ice age, and "something" caused it to end, and that something could not possibly have been us. So who is responsible becomes less important in my mind as responding while we can with effective ways to live and prosper under different climates.
- burke 10y agoA charitable interpretation would be to project the right/wrong axis onto compatibility with our continued flourishing. If you accept human flourishing as "right", the arctic climate is quite wrong. It's a bit of a reach through and I pretty much agree with your point.
- btilly 10y agoThose two somethings need not be the same. We emerged during an interglacial. Which happens regularly during Ice Ages. However we are now seeing conditions that could end the Ice Ages. And the "something" causing that is us.
- themgt 10y agoIf a tree falls on your head it can't be "wrong", the tree has no agency. If a human cuts down the tree, knowing it is likely to fall on your head ... is who is responsible really important? Trees fall on heads all the time. What about important questions, like effective ways for others to prosper while some are crushed by the massive industry of human-felled / human-crushing trees? Whether we could or should stop felling trees onto people is a question beyond science or human judgement on which to opine. This sort of "climate trolley problem" is the final stage of pseudo-rational climate change denial, before it was "it isn't happening", now we're in a postmodernist semantic argument in the face of human destruction of our biosphere. How intellectual.
- espadrine 10y ago> So who is responsible becomes less important in my mind as responding while we can with effective ways to live and prosper under different climates. The hard fact is this: about a thousand politicians have the collective ability to make a large percentage of the planet no longer viable for humans for hundreds of years. You likely know it to be true with regards to nuclear arsenal. Why would it be so hard to accept that the same goes for gas emissions? Humans can burn or cut down phenomenally large forests — they have, and still do, at an increasingly faster rate, thanks to more and more sophisticated technology. Humans can, and do, drill into methane pockets underground, releasing large amounts of gas. And, of course, oil. The second law of thermodynamics is a fact of life. There is no fully sustainable energy consumption scheme. Those we rely most on currently come from accidental geological events; primarily, the lack of bacterial enzymes able to consume lignin prior to the end of the Carboniferous. Just like diagnosing a disease is necessary to get the meds needed to survive, understanding the mechanisms of our planet's viability is necessary for our sake.
- concernedmale 10y agoWow, prick the hive-mind's balloon and get down voted to oblivion. Nothing is wrong with what you said.