3 ms·
It's very simple to let the F-35 look good - stick to BVR combat. The scenarios in which it looked poor was in WVR combat where the F-35 has no benefit of steal
by alkonaut 10y ago
It's very simple to let the F-35 look good - stick to BVR combat. The scenarios in which it looked poor was in WVR combat where the F-35 has no benefit of stealth and an excellent radar, but all the drawbacks of stealth (fewer weapons etc)
I don't doubt the F-35 can dominate in simulations where there either is no WVR engagements or there are other aircraft to take care of those.
Also, aggressor aircraft were presumably 4th gen aircraft which leaves the question open how it would perform against other craft.
- Zhenya 10y agoBVR = beyond visual range: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beyond-visual-range_missile https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beyond-visual-range_missile WVR = within visual range: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Air_superiority_fighter https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Air_superiority_fighter
- sandworm101 10y agoNo aircraft looks good BVR against live targets. There have only been perhaps one or two air-to-air missile kills bvr against aware/equiped targets in the last 40 years (targets with trained pilots and realistic countermeasures). Most pilots assume a 10-15% hit chance in a realworld bvr situation. No aircraft looks good when launching all your bvr weapons (4?) will likely not score a single hit.
- nickff 10y agoIt looks like the historic kill rate with radar-guided weapons has been quite low, but the technology has advanced significantly since it's early deployments around and before the Vietnam war.[1] I would suggest that weapons like the AMRAAM would have a high probability of kill in real large scale conflicts if and when IFF issues are not present. [1] http://pogoarchives.org/labyrinth/11/09.pdf http://pogoarchives.org/labyrinth/11/09.pdf
- crypto5 10y agoIn Yugoslavia war, all(6) air-to-air kills were performed by AMRAAM according to wiki.
- sandworm101 10y agoBut against what target? A poorly-equiped fighter with no EW capability, one that doesnt move becausr it doesnt see the threat? Lets see how the amraam handles a 4th or 5th generation fighter. There are stories of f22s having trouble downing f4 drones.
- crypto5 10y agoAgainst mig-29, modern enough for that time.
- neurotech1 10y agoThe F-16 aggressor jets were likely flying with IR Search & Tracking (IRST/ATFLIR) pods [0] that somewhat negate the stealth advantage of the F-35. They also had external fuel tanks that would negate the kinematic advantage over the F-35. F-35 has the benefit of not requiring external tanks for combat missions. On the flip side, the F-35 would have a Situational Awareness advantage and exploited this for both WVR and BVR engagements. The F-35 pilots won fairly by flying to their jets advantages. [0] http://aviationintel.com/exclusive-usaf-aggressors-fly-with-irst-po/ http://aviationintel.com/exclusive-usaf-aggressors-fly-with-...